Let's be real for a second. We all remember that summer in 2019. CBS finally brought the UK juggernaut across the pond, and we were introduced to a Fiji villa filled with hopeful singles. We watched, we voted, and we genuinely thought some of these people were "endgame." But looking back at Love Island USA couples still together season 1, the list is... well, it’s nonexistent.
It’s a ghost town.
If you came here looking for a heartwarming story about a wedding or a villa baby from the OG American season, I hate to be the one to break it to you. Not a single couple that walked out of that villa hand-in-hand is still together today. Not the winners. Not the runners-up. Not even the "soulmates" who left early.
Why does this matter? Because Season 1 was the guinea pig. It was shorter, the vibes were different, and the casting was still finding its feet. While later seasons like Season 6 have produced couples that seem to have real staying power, the inaugural class of Love Island USA basically served as a lesson in how hard it is to make a "situationship" work when the cameras stop rolling and the Fiji tan fades.
The Winners Who Didn't Last: Zac and Elizabeth
Zac Mirabelli and Elizabeth Weber were the golden couple. They coupled up on Day 1. They stayed loyal. They were boring in that "we're actually in love" way that usually wins people the $100,000. When they won, it felt like a sure thing.
They lasted about four months.
They announced their split in December 2019. Elizabeth took to her Instagram Stories to explain that "things didn't work out," which is the standard PR-friendly way of saying the real world hit them like a freight train. Zac was based in Chicago; Elizabeth was in New York. While that's not a cross-country trek, the pressure of being the "face" of a new franchise probably didn't help.
🔗 Read more: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
Years later, Elizabeth has been pretty open on her YouTube channel and social media about the experience. She’s mentioned that the bubble of the villa creates a false sense of intimacy. You aren't paying bills. You aren't deciding whose family to see for Thanksgiving. You're just drinking iced coffee and talking about your "type on paper." Once the public eye shifted to Season 2, the glue holding them together seemingly dissolved.
The Dylan and Alexandra Collapse
Then we had Dylan Curry and Alexandra Stewart. They were the relatable ones. They had chemistry that felt a bit more grounded than Zac and Elizabeth’s fairytale edit. They finished as runners-up, and for a while, it looked like they might actually outlast the winners.
Nope.
They broke up even before Zac and Elizabeth did. By late November 2019, Dylan posted on his Story that they had decided to go their separate ways. Alexandra later revealed on a podcast that a major injury Dylan suffered shortly after the show put a massive strain on their blossoming relationship. Imagine trying to navigate a brand-new, high-pressure relationship while also dealing with a serious physical recovery. It’s a lot.
Alexandra has remained one of the most vocal alumnae of the season. She’s stayed in the influencer sphere and has been very transparent about how the "fame" aspect of the show can be isolating. When you are part of the list of Love Island USA couples still together season 1, or rather, the list of those who aren't, you realize these people are often just twenty-somethings who had a wild month in the sun.
What About the Rest of the Finalists?
Ray Gantt and Caro Viehweg were the high-energy pair of the season. They actually gave it a real shot. Unlike the others, they stayed together for about a year. They even appeared on another reality show, The Amazing Race, which is historically known as the ultimate "make or break" test for couples.
💡 You might also like: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
It broke them.
Or, more accurately, they broke up before the show even aired. Their split was a bit more tumultuous than the others, with rumors of infidelity and general "he said, she said" drama filling the tabloids for a few months. Ray later appeared on Ex on the Beach, effectively cementing his status as a reality TV veteran rather than one half of a lasting Love Island couple.
Cashel Barnett and Kyra Robinson had a weird journey. Cashel was dumped, Kyra stayed, then Kyra left and they reconnected. They were "together" for a bit, broke up, tried again, and eventually called it quits for good. It was a rollercoaster that proved that even if you find your way back to each other outside the villa, the fundamental issues that existed in Fiji usually follow you home.
Why Season 1 Failed to Produce Long-Term Love
You have to look at the landscape of 2019. Love Island USA was a massive experiment. The contestants didn't really know what they were signing up for in terms of post-show scrutiny.
- The Duration: Season 1 was significantly shorter than the UK version and even later US seasons. Relationships need time to bake. A few weeks isn't enough to build a foundation that survives a flight back to the mainland.
- The Distance: This is the perennial killer of Love Island couples. When you live in different states, the "influencer lifestyle" of traveling for events only sustains you for so long.
- The "First Season" Syndrome: Everything was shiny and new. The cast was focused on the experience, but the infrastructure for supporting these couples post-show wasn't as robust as it is now.
Where are they now?
Most of the Season 1 cast has moved on entirely. Some have pivoted to fitness coaching, others are full-time influencers, and some have retreated back to "normal" jobs, scrubbing their Island past from their LinkedIn profiles.
Elizabeth Weber and Alexandra Stewart even started a podcast together called After the Island, where they dish on subsequent seasons. It’s a bit poetic—the women who didn't find lasting love found a lasting friendship and a business venture instead. In many ways, that's a more successful outcome than a forced relationship.
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
The Successors are Doing Better
It’s interesting to compare the Love Island USA couples still together season 1 (zero) to later seasons. Season 6, for instance, has couples like Kenny and Jana or Cordell and Serena who, as of early 2026, are showing much more promise. Maybe it's because the casting has improved. Maybe it's because the "bombshells" are more vetted. Or maybe, the newer contestants have learned from the mistakes of the Season 1 OGs.
If you’re looking for love that lasts, Season 1 is basically a cautionary tale. It was a fun summer fling for the entire country, but just like a real summer fling, it wasn't meant to survive the winter.
What to Watch for Next
If you're tracking the success rate of these shows, don't just look at who is still posting pictures together. Look at who is moving in together. Look at whose families are intermingling. In Season 1, none of that happened.
For fans of the franchise, the takeaway is simple: enjoy the drama, vote for your favorites, but don't buy the wedding guest outfit too early. The villa is a vacuum. The real test starts at the baggage claim.
If you're diving back into the archives, watch Season 1 for the nostalgia and the "where it all began" vibes. Just don't expect a "happily ever after" in the credits.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out the After the Island podcast if you want the unfiltered truth about what happens when the cameras stop.
- Follow Elizabeth Weber on YouTube for her deep dives into the production side of things—it's eye-opening.
- Monitor the Season 6 couples' social media; they are currently the best bet for breaking the "Love Island Curse."