You've probably seen the mixed reviews by now. Honestly, when Lord of the Rings Return to Moria first dropped on PC and then crawled its way onto consoles, the reception was... well, let’s call it "cautious." Some people expected Valheim in a gold-plated Tolkien skin. Others wanted a direct sequel to the films. What Free Range Games actually gave us was something much weirder and, in my opinion, far more interesting. It's a survival-crafting game that actually cares about the Fourth Age. That matters.
Most Lord of the Rings games are obsessed with the War of the Ring. We get it. Sauron is bad. The Ring must be melted. But Return to Moria picks up the pieces after the credits roll. Gimli Lockbearer, voiced by the incomparable John Rhys-Davies, is an old Dwarf with a grudge against a mountain. He wants his home back. You aren't playing as a superhero. You're a blue-collar Dwarf with a pickaxe and a very dim torch.
The game is clunky. I’ll admit that right out of the gate. The combat feels a bit like swinging a wet pool noodle at first, and the building mechanics can be finicky. But there is a specific magic that happens about five hours in. You’re deep in the Western Halls, the light is failing, and you hear a distant drum. Doom, doom. If you’re a fan, it hits different.
What Return to Moria actually gets right about Khazad-dûm
Geography in this game isn't just a random map. While the world is procedurally generated to a degree, it follows a vertical logic that feels claustrophobic in all the right ways. You aren't just walking through "Level 1" and "Level 2." You are descending into the guts of the world.
The darkness is a mechanic, not just a visual filter. If you spend too much time in the pitch black, your Dwarf gets "Despair." It’s a status effect that slowly drains your life. It forces you to be a literal light-bringer. You’ll find yourself obsessively placing torches along every corridor, turning the terrifying abyss into a home. It’s a psychological shift. You start the game fearing the dark; you end the game owning it.
Let's talk about the singing. This is the coolest feature I've seen in a survival game in years. When you are mining a vein of Iron or Mithril, you can press a button to have your Dwarf burst into song. If you're playing co-op, your friends join in, harmonizing. It’s not just for flavor—it actually buffs your stamina. It captures that "Heigh-Ho" energy but grounds it in the melancholy of a fallen civilization. It’s peak Tolkien.
The building system and the "Restore" mechanic
Most survival games let you build a base anywhere. In Lord of the Rings Return to Moria, you certainly can do that, but the game encourages you to reclaim. You find ruined dwarven outposts—shattered hearths and broken stone beds—and you fix them.
💡 You might also like: Playing A Link to the Past Switch: Why It Still Hits Different Today
There is something deeply satisfying about finding a ruined hall that’s been cold for a thousand years and lighting the fire again. You aren't just an architect; you're a restorer. You’re cleaning up the mess the Balrog left behind.
- The Hearth: This is your anchor. It determines your build zone.
- The Meal Table: Unlike other games where you eat a berry and move on, Dwarves need a proper spread. You cook big batches of stow-bread or meat roasts and sit down together.
- The Forge: This is where the progression happens. You find fragments of old recipes carved into statues, piece them together, and suddenly you can craft a Belegost-style axe.
Surviving the Orc Hordes and the Siege Mechanic
Combat is where the "clunk" lives, but it’s also where the tension is. The game uses a "noise" system. If you spend too much time mining with a heavy hammer, you’re going to wake up the neighbors. A meter on the screen fills up as you make noise, and eventually, a Horde is triggered.
It's terrifying. One minute you’re happily chipping away at a wall, and the next, forty Goblins are pouring out of the cracks in the ceiling. It turns the game into a tower defense hybrid for five minutes. If your base isn't reinforced with sturdy stone walls, they will tear your chests apart and steal your loot.
The enemy variety is surprisingly deep. You start with standard Orcs and Goblins, but as you go deeper—into the Lower Deeps and the Shadow-touched areas—you run into things that even the Orcs are afraid of. Bolg’s descendants are there, and they remember the battle of the Five Armies. They hate you. You feel that hatred in every encounter.
The Mithril problem
Everyone wants Mithril. It's the "endgame" material. But the game doesn't just hand it to you. You have to earn your way into the deepest parts of the mountain, where the air is thin and the shadows are literal poison.
The progression curve is steep. You'll hit walls—figuratively and literally. You might need a Tier 3 pickaxe to break a certain rock, but to get that pickaxe, you need to find a specific forge located in a room guarded by a boss that can one-shot you. It’s a loop that rewards patience. If you try to rush Return to Moria, you will die. A lot.
📖 Related: Plants vs Zombies Xbox One: Why Garden Warfare Still Slaps Years Later
Why the "Mixed" reviews might be misleading
I think people wanted Dark Souls combat or Minecraft level of building freedom. This game is neither. It’s a very specific niche: a narrative-driven survival game.
The story matters. Following the "Mines of Moria" trail left by the Fellowship is a highlight. Finding Gandalf’s scratches on a stone or seeing the bridge of Khazad-dûm in its ruined state provides a sense of place that other Middle-earth games lack. They used actual lore experts to make sure the linguistics and the history lined up. For a nerd, that’s worth the price of admission alone.
The performance at launch was admittedly rough. Frame rate drops in the Elven Quarter were legendary. However, patches have smoothed out a lot of the jank. If you played it at version 1.0 and hated it, it might be time to look at it again. The "Golden Update" added a sandbox mode that removes the story gates, letting you just exist as a Dwarf in a mountain. It’s a completely different vibe.
Comparing Moria to other survival giants
| Feature | Return to Moria | Valheim | Grounded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atmosphere | Oppressive, dark, cinematic | Open, ethereal, adventurous | Whimsical, terrifying, suburban |
| Building | Restorative stone-working | Structural integrity physics | Creative, modular, organic |
| Combat | Weighty but simple | Punishing and stamina-heavy | Precise, parry-focused |
| Story | High-fantasy sequel | Mythological progression | 90s movie mystery |
Return to Moria doesn't have the physics of Valheim, but it has better "vibes." It doesn't have the polish of Grounded, but it has the weight of Tolkien's world. It’s a trade-off.
Is it worth playing solo?
Honestly? It's harder. The game is clearly balanced for a crew of 2 to 4 Dwarves. When a Horde hits and you're alone, it’s a desperate struggle to keep your walls up and your head on your shoulders.
But playing solo makes the mountain feel bigger. The silence of the mines is more profound when there isn't a friend burping over voice chat. You start to notice the sound design more—the way the stone groans under the weight of the world above. It becomes a horror game. If you like that feeling of being an underdog against an impossible environment, solo play is the way to go.
👉 See also: Why Pokemon Red and Blue Still Matter Decades Later
If you do go solo, my advice is simple: Over-build. Don't just put up a wooden fence. Spend the extra time to smelt the iron and build the reinforced stone walls. You’ll thank me when the first Siege hits at 3:00 AM.
Moving forward in the Fourth Age
The developers have been surprisingly vocal about their roadmap. We’ve already seen the addition of cross-play and the sandbox mode, but the community is clamoring for more. More biomes, more "Old World" monsters, and perhaps more cameos from the wider world of Middle-earth.
The game is a labor of love. You can tell. Even the way the Dwarves talk to themselves when they're tired—it feels authentic to the source material. It isn't a cash grab. It’s a niche game for a niche audience that happens to love digging holes and singing about gold.
If you’re looking for a game that respects your time with a tight 30-40 hour campaign, this is it. It’s not an "infinite" survival game, and that’s okay. It has an ending. You have a goal. You want to see the sun again.
Your next steps in the Deep
If you’re jumping in for the first time, don't just wander aimlessly. Follow these steps to actually survive the first few nights:
- Repair every statue you see. Statues give you recipe fragments. Without them, you're stuck with a wooden club and a prayer.
- Focus on the Great Forge. Your first major goal should be reaching the Elven Quarter and finding the resources to light the first Great Forge. This unlocks the gear that makes the Orcs manageable.
- Manage your light. Never enter a new room without a torch in hand or a way to build a standing lamp. The Despair mechanic will kill you faster than a Goblin will.
- Listen to the music. The soundtrack is more than just background noise; it's a cue for danger. When the drums start, stop mining and find a corner to defend.
Lord of the Rings Return to Moria isn't perfect. It's dusty, it's sometimes frustrating, and it's buried under a lot of expectations. But for those who ever wanted to reclaim the halls of their ancestors, there is simply nothing else like it. Grab a pickaxe, find a friend, and start digging. Just watch out for what's lurking in the shadows of the Lower Deeps. Some things are better left undisturbed.
For the most up-to-date strategies on specific boss fights or build designs, checking the community-run Wiki or the official Discord is your best bet, as the procedural nature of the mines means your layout will always be a little different from everyone else's.