If you’ve spent any time in the Outlander universe, you know Lord John Grey as the stiff, honorable, and secretly pining British officer who keeps bailing Jamie Fraser out of trouble. But honestly? The Lord John Gray books are a completely different beast. While the main series is a sweeping, time-traveling romance that occasionally gets bogged down in the sheer weight of its own drama, the Lord John sub-series is tighter. It’s punchier. It’s basically Diana Gabaldon writing historical "whodunnits" with a side of queer yearning and 18th-century espionage.
Most people stumble into these books because they’ve run out of Claire and Jamie content. They expect a light snack. What they get is a complex, richly textured look at a man living a dangerous double life in a society that would literally execute him for being who he is.
It’s messy. It’s brilliant.
Where the Lord John Gray Books Fit in the Timeline
You can’t just jump in anywhere. Well, you could, but you’d be confused as hell. The Lord John Gray books mostly take place during the "wilderness years" of the main Outlander timeline—specifically the twenty-year gap while Claire is back in the 1940s and Jamie is suffering through the aftermath of Culloden.
Gabaldon started this whole side project with a short story called Lord John and the Hellfire Club. It was supposed to be a one-off. But John is a character who demands space. He’s a soldier, a diplomat, and a member of the upper crust, which gives Gabaldon a chance to explore parts of the 1700s that a Scottish rebel or a 20th-century nurse simply can’t access. We’re talking London high society, the Prussian army during the Seven Years' War, and the humid, treacherous landscape of Jamaica.
The Reading Order That Actually Makes Sense
If you want to read these without your brain melting, follow the internal chronology. Start with Lord John and the Hellfire Club (found in the Lord John and the Hand of Devils collection). Then move to the first full-length novel, Lord John and the Private Matter.
- Lord John and the Private Matter (The one with the syphilis subplot—no, seriously).
- Lord John and the Brotherhood of the Blade (This is the big one. It digs into John’s father’s scandal).
- Lord John and the Hand of Devils (A collection of three novellas).
- The Scottish Prisoner (The holy grail for Jamie Fraser fans).
There are others, like Lord John and the Plague of Zombies, which sounds like a B-movie but is actually a very grounded mystery set in Jamaica involving slave revolts and a mysterious medical condition.
Why John Grey is a Better Protagonist Than Jamie Fraser (Don't Fight Me)
Look, Jamie is great. He’s the King of Men. We get it. But Jamie is also... perfect? He’s a 6’4” warrior-poet who is always on the right side of history. Lord John is more human. He makes mistakes. He serves an empire he doesn't always believe in. He navigates a world where his very existence is a capital crime.
📖 Related: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
The Lord John Gray books thrive because John is an observer. He’s smart. He’s a bit of a Sherlock Holmes figure, but with more emotional baggage. When he’s investigating a murder in London or a supernatural sighting in the Caribbean, he’s using his status as a "gentleman" to mask his vulnerability.
The tension in these books isn't just about "who did it." It’s about "will John get caught?" Whether it’s his affection for Jamie or a brief encounter with a fellow soldier, the stakes are incredibly high. Every interaction is a chess match.
The Scottish Prisoner: The Crossover You Need
If you’re skeptical about a spinoff, The Scottish Prisoner is the book that will change your mind. It’s a dual-POV novel. You get Lord John and Jamie Fraser forced into a reluctant partnership. It’s set in 1760, while Jamie is a paroled prisoner at Helwater.
It’s tense.
Jamie hates John (mostly because John is in love with him and Jamie finds the whole situation morally reprehensible and personally invasive). John is trying to be a "good man" while essentially owning Jamie. The power dynamic is fascinatingly toxic and deeply moving.
Gabaldon uses this book to bridge the gap between their early animosity and the deep, platonic (mostly) love they share in the later Outlander novels like A Breath of Snow and Ashes. If you skip this, you’re missing the foundational work of their friendship. You're seeing the "what" without the "how."
Historical Accuracy vs. Fiction
Gabaldon is a stickler for detail. In the Lord John Gray books, she dives deep into the Seven Years' War. You’ll learn more about 18th-century cannon fire and military logistics than you ever thought possible. Some readers find the battle scenes in Brotherhood of the Blade a bit dense.
👉 See also: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
They are.
But they serve a purpose. They show the grind of John’s life. He isn't just a romantic figure; he’s a professional soldier. The realism makes the moments of personal drama hit harder. When he’s in the trenches of Europe, his memories of the English countryside feel like a fever dream.
The "Hellfire Club" and the Darker Side of London
One thing these books do better than the main series is capturing the grit of London. The Outlander books are very "nature-heavy"—lots of herbs, mountains, and mud. The Lord John books are about coffee houses, brothels, and back-alley deals.
The Hellfire Club novella introduces us to the "mollies"—the underground gay subculture of the 1700s. It’s a tragic, hidden world. Gabaldon doesn't sugarcoat it. These men weren't living some liberated secret life; they were terrified. John moves through this world with a mix of curiosity and intense fear.
It adds a layer of social commentary that the main series lacks. While Claire is fighting for medical progress, John is fighting for the right to simply exist without being hanged at Tyburn.
Common Misconceptions About the Series
A lot of people think you have to read the main Outlander books first. You don't.
Actually, the Lord John Gray books work perfectly well as standalone historical mysteries. If you like Patrick O'Brian or Bernard Cornwell, you’ll probably dig these. They have that same "men at war" energy, just with a much more sensitive, internal protagonist.
✨ Don't miss: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Another misconception? That they're just "short stories."
Brotherhood of the Blade and The Scottish Prisoner are hefty novels. They have the same word-count weight as many standard fantasy books. They aren't "side stories"—they are essential pillars of the Outlander mythos. They explain why John is so loyal to the Frasers later on. They explain his relationship with his brother, Hal, who is one of the most underrated characters in the entire franchise.
The Character of Hal Grey
Hal (the Duke of Pardloe) is the perfect foil for John. He’s high-strung, incredibly protective, and burdened by the family’s disgraced reputation. Their brotherly dynamic is one of the best parts of the series. Hal knows John’s secret—or at least strongly suspects it—and the way he protects John while still being a rigid, conservative aristocrat is some of Gabaldon’s best character work.
Actionable Steps for New Readers
If you're ready to dive in, don't just buy the first thing you see.
- Check your library for "Lord John and the Hand of Devils." It contains three stories that act as a great "vibe check" for the series. If you like these, you’ll like the novels.
- Listen to the audiobooks. Jeff Woodman narrates the majority of the Lord John series, and he is spectacular. He gives John a dry, witty, slightly weary voice that fits the character perfectly.
- Don't skip "The Custom of the Army." It’s a novella that takes John to Quebec. It’s short, fast-paced, and features an electric chair (sort of). It shows the sheer variety of the settings Gabaldon explores.
- Keep a family tree handy. The Greys have a lot of relatives, and the British aristocracy is a tangled web of titles. You’ll be Googling "Is a Marquess higher than an Earl?" every five minutes otherwise.
The Lord John Gray books offer a perspective that is often missing from historical fiction: the perspective of a man who is an integral part of the establishment but is also its greatest "deviant." It’s a story about the masks we wear and the price of honor.
If you want the full picture of the Outlander world, you have to read these. They aren't optional extras. They are the heart of the 18th-century narrative, told through the eyes of its most complex gentleman. Start with The Private Matter. It begins with John seeing something he shouldn't in a London garden, and honestly, things just get more complicated from there.