The wait is finally ending. After years of headlines, false starts, and a decade of agonizing silence for the victims' families, we have a date. On January 13, 2026, Suffolk County Supreme Court Judge Timothy Mazzei made it very clear: the Long Island serial killer trial of Rex Heuermann will begin shortly after Labor Day 2026. "Come hell or high water," the judge said.
Heuermann, a 62-year-old architect from Massapequa Park, isn't just facing one or two charges anymore. He’s looking at ten charges of first- and second-degree murder involving seven different women. This case has basically evolved from a local tragedy into one of the most complex forensic puzzles in American history.
The Evidence That Changed Everything
Honestly, the prosecution’s case rests on two pillars: a 723-page inventory of evidence and a digital "planning document" that sounds like something out of a horror movie.
This document, a deleted Word file found on Heuermann’s hard drive, allegedly served as a literal blueprint for murder. It reportedly included categories for "Body Prep," instructions on removing tattoos, and notes about the strength of various ropes. It even made references to Mindhunter and listed dump sites that matched where actual bodies were found. That’s not just a coincidence; it’s a confession in digital ink.
The DNA "Magic" Showdown
The defense team, led by Michael Brown and Danielle Coysh, is throwing everything at the wall. They’ve called the prosecution’s advanced DNA testing "magic."
👉 See also: Why the 2022 Shooting at the Funeral in Racine Still Haunts Our Safety Conversations
They are specifically fighting the use of whole genome sequencing. This is the first time this tech—which can map an entire genetic code from tiny, degraded hair samples—will be used in a New York state trial.
- The Pizza Crust: Detectives followed Heuermann and grabbed a discarded pizza box from a Manhattan trash can. They say the DNA on that crust matches hairs found on the victims.
- The Privacy Argument: The defense is actually arguing that taking DNA from garbage violates Heuermann’s constitutional rights. It's a bold move. They're basically asking if the government can "learn everything about us" just by looking at what we throw away.
- The "Ogre" Description: One witness described a man who looked like an "ogre," standing about 6'4" or 6'5", with dark bushy hair and glasses. Heuermann is a massive man, and the description is, well, eerily spot on.
The Seven Victims
It’s easy to get lost in the legal jargon, but we’ve got to remember the people at the heart of this. The trial covers decades of alleged violence.
- The Gilgo Four: Melissa Barthelemy, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello. Their bodies were found in 2010, wrapped in burlap.
- The "Cold" Connections: Sandra Costilla (killed in 1993), Jessica Taylor, and Valerie Mack.
Interestingly, the defense is trying to get the Sandra Costilla charge thrown out entirely. They’re pointing at John Bittrolff, a convicted killer, as a more likely suspect for her death. They say the single hair linking Heuermann to Costilla just isn't enough to prove intent or presence.
👉 See also: Who Is the Oldest Living US President? The Surprising Truth About the Post-White House Club
A Corridor for Predators?
Something huge happened in December 2025 that most people missed. Police arrested Andrew Dykes for the murders of Tanya Jackson and their daughter Tatiana. For 14 years, everyone assumed they were victims of the same Long Island Serial Killer.
They weren’t.
This revelation basically confirms what some investigators feared: Ocean Parkway wasn’t just one man’s dumping ground. It was a corridor used by multiple predators. While this doesn't clear Heuermann, it complicates the narrative that every body found near the beach belongs to him.
💡 You might also like: Did anybody hit the lottery last night? Here is the real story on the latest winners
What Happens Next
Heuermann is currently in protective solitary confinement for 23 hours a day. He’s pleading not guilty, and his lawyer has pretty much nixed any talk of a plea deal. They want a trial.
The prosecution, led by District Attorney Ray Tierney, has until March 2026 to respond to a massive batch of defense motions. After that, we hit the final stretch before the jury is seated in September.
If you're following this, stay focused on the pre-trial hearings in the spring. That’s where the real battle over the pizza crust DNA and the "planning document" will be won or lost. You should also watch for any movement on the "Asian Male Doe" or Shannan Gilbert cases—though Heuermann hasn't been charged in those, they remain the biggest unanswered questions in the Gilgo Beach saga.
Check the Suffolk County Court calendar regularly for hearing dates, as these sessions often reveal the specific digital forensic evidence that will be presented to the jury.