New York real estate is a beast. You spend hours scrolling StreetEasy, looking at floor plans that look like Tetris pieces, and eventually, you stumble upon a place like 245 East 73rd St. It’s a pre-war building. It’s got that Upper East Side charm people talk about in movies. But if you're actually thinking about moving here, or even just curious why this specific block of 73rd Street feels different than, say, 79th, you need the ground truth.
The Reality of 245 East 73rd St
Located between Second and Third Avenues, this building is basically the definition of "prime location" without the soul-crushing noise of a major avenue. It was built back in 1928. That matters. It means the walls are thick enough that you won't hear your neighbor’s 3:00 AM Netflix binge, but it also means the plumbing has some... personality.
Most of the units here are cooperatives. If you’re new to the city, a co-op isn't just an apartment you buy; it’s a corporation you join. The board at 245 East 73rd St is known for being thorough. They care about who moves in because they’ve lived there for twenty years and don't want a rotating door of Airbnb guests. It’s a "full-service" building, which in New York parlance means there is a 24-hour doorman who will likely know your name, your dog's name, and exactly how many packages you order from Amazon in a week.
The architecture is classic Art Deco. You’ve got the sunken living rooms in some units—a total vibe if you like that 1930s sophisticated feel—and high ceilings that make a 600-square-foot studio feel like a palace. Sorta.
Why the Neighborhood Matters More Than the Square Footage
You aren't just paying for the four walls at 245 East 73rd St. You’re paying for the 10-minute walk to Central Park. You’re paying for the proximity to the Q train at 72nd Street, which basically saved the Upper East Side when it opened a few years back. Before that, residents were shoved onto the 6 train like sardines. Now? You can get to Midtown or Union Square in a flash.
Honestly, the food scene right here is underrated. Everyone talks about the West Village, but have you tried the bagels around here? Or the random Italian joints that have been open since the building was built? It’s a neighborhood where people actually stay. You see the same folks walking their Labradors every morning. It’s quiet.
🔗 Read more: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
But let's be real about the "lifestyle" part.
Living on 73rd Street means you’re in the heart of the "Gold Coast" adjacent area. You have the luxury of Madison Avenue boutiques nearby, but you're far enough east that it doesn't feel like a tourist trap. The downside? Grocery shopping is an Olympic sport. You’ve got options, sure, but lugging bags from Morton Williams or the Whole Foods on 87th isn't always a party.
The Financials and the "Gotchas"
If you're looking at a listing for 245 East 73rd St right now, look at the maintenance fees. This is where people get tripped up. In a pre-war co-op, maintenance covers your property taxes, the doormen’s salaries, the heat, the water, and the upkeep of that beautiful lobby.
Is it high? Usually.
Is it worth it? That depends on if you value a guy opening the door for you when you have three bags of groceries and a screaming toddler.
Also, look at the flip tax. Many buildings in this tier have a percentage that goes back to the building when you sell. It’s how they keep the elevators running without hitting everyone with a massive assessment every five years. It’s a trade-off. You pay a bit more when you leave to ensure the building doesn't fall apart while you're there.
💡 You might also like: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
Design and Renovations: The Pre-War Struggle
Here is the thing about 245 East 73rd St: the apartments vary wildly. One unit might be a time capsule from 1974 with shag carpet and wood paneling. The one next door might be a minimalist masterpiece with Poliform kitchens and heated marble floors.
Renovating here is... an adventure.
Because it’s a co-op, you can’t just swing a sledgehammer. You need board approval. You need licensed contractors. You need a lot of patience. If you're buying a "fixer-upper" in this building, factor in an extra six months just for the paperwork. The end result is usually stunning because the "bones" are so good. You have real hardwood floors, not that laminate stuff. You have plaster walls. You have moldings that actually have detail.
What Nobody Tells You
The basement. No, seriously. In these old UES buildings, the basement is the heartbeat. 245 East 73rd St has laundry facilities and storage. If you can snag a storage cage, do it. In a city where people pay $500 a month for a closet-sized locker, having storage in your building is like finding gold.
Also, the light. Because the building is situated among other mid-rise structures, the lower floors can feel a bit like a cave if you’re facing the back. But the higher floors? You get that classic New York city-scape light that makes everything look like a Pinterest board. If you're sensitive to "Seasonal Affective Disorder," aim for floor seven or above.
📖 Related: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Navigating the Market at 245 East 73rd St
Markets fluctuate, but the Upper East Side is usually a steady ship. It doesn't see the insane spikes of Williamsburg, but it also doesn't crash as hard. People always want to live here. Schools like PS 158 are a huge draw for families. The safety factor is high.
If you see a unit for sale, check the "days on market." If it’s been sitting for 100 days, something is off—either the price is delusional or the board requirements are so stiff that nobody can pass. Most likely, it’s the price. In 2026, buyers are savvy. They know what a square foot is worth on 73rd Street.
Expert Tips for Potential Residents
- Check the Board Minutes: If you're buying, have your lawyer read the last two years of board meeting notes. Are they fighting about a leaky roof? Is there a lawsuit with the commercial tenant downstairs? This is the boring stuff that saves you thousands.
- Visit at Night: The vibe of 73rd Street changes when the sun goes down. It’s quiet, which is great for sleep, but make sure you’re comfortable with the lighting and the walk from the subway.
- Measure Everything: Pre-war floor plans are "generous" with their measurements. Bring a tape measure. That "king-sized" bedroom might only fit a king bed and literally nothing else.
Living at 245 East 73rd St is a choice to embrace a specific version of New York. It’s not the flashy, glass-tower-in-Hudson-Yards version. It’s the "I know the guy at the corner deli and my doorman knows my mom's name" version. It’s refined, a little bit stubborn, and deeply rooted in the history of the neighborhood.
Actionable Next Steps
If this building is on your radar, start by looking at the most recent sales data on public records like ACRIS or through a focused search on specialized real estate portals. Don't just look at the asking price; look at the "sold" price from the last 18 months to get a real sense of value.
Reach out to a broker who specifically handles the Upper East Side. They often know about "pocket listings"—apartments that haven't hit the public market yet. Because these buildings are close-knit, word of a move often travels through the building staff and long-time residents before a sign ever goes up.
Finally, prepare your financial "board package" early. Co-ops like this require a mountain of paperwork, including tax returns, reference letters, and a full breakdown of your assets. Having this ready to go can be the difference between getting the apartment and losing it to someone who was faster on the draw.