Honestly, taking a beloved 2D masterpiece like Lilo & Stitch and trying to squeeze it into a live-action mold was always going to be a gamble. Disney’s 2025 remake didn't just try to replicate the 2002 magic; it basically rewrote the DNA of the story. If you’ve seen the trailers or caught the flick in theaters, you know the vibe is... different.
The live action Lilo & Stitch is a weird beast. It’s got a lot of heart, mostly thanks to newcomer Maia Kealoha, but it also makes some creative pivots that have left die-hard fans scratching their heads.
The Casting Drama and the Real Faces of Hawaii
When Disney first announced the cast, the internet did what the internet does. It exploded. Sydney Elizebeth Agudong, who plays Nani, faced a wave of criticism from people who felt her casting was a step backward for colorism in Hollywood. Nani in the original was a dark-skinned, realistically built Native Hawaiian woman. Agudong is Hawaiian, born and raised on Kauai, but her lighter skin tone became a massive talking point about visibility and representation.
Then there was the David Kawena situation. Originally, Kahiau Machado was set to play Lilo’s surfing buddy/Nani's love interest. That didn't last long. Old social media posts surfaced, the "n-word" was involved, and Disney pivoted fast. They brought in Kaipo Dudoit instead. Honestly? Dudoit fits the vibe well, and he brings a genuine local energy to the role that feels less like a "Disney prince" and more like a guy you'd actually see at a surf break in Makaha.
Who’s Who in the 2025 Remake
- Lilo: Maia Kealoha (A literal ray of sunshine in her film debut).
- Stitch: Chris Sanders (Yes, the original director is back to voice the blue menace).
- Nani: Sydney Elizebeth Agudong.
- David: Kaipo Dudoit.
- Jumba: Zach Galifianakis.
- Pleakley: Billy Magnussen.
- Cobra Bubbles: Courtney B. Vance.
- Mrs. Kekoa: Tia Carrere (The original Nani! This was a top-tier cameo/role swap).
Where Did the Drag Go?
One of the biggest "wait, what?" moments for fans involves Agent Pleakley. In the original 2D version, Pleakley's whole thing was his love for Earth fashion—specifically women’s clothing. He was a low-key queer icon for a generation of kids.
In the live action Lilo & Stitch, he spends most of his time in a CGI "human suit" that looks like a generic guy in a polo. Director Dean Fleischer Camp (the guy behind Marcel the Shell with Shoes On) actually went on TikTok to defend this. He showed off concept art of Pleakley in a wig and dress, saying he "really tried" to make it work. Apparently, the "logic" of the live-action world made the silly disguises harder to pull off without it looking terrifyingly uncanny.
Instead of physical clothes, the aliens use holographic tech. It’s a bit of a bummer. It takes away that tactile, chaotic energy of the original where they were just two weirdos in a rental car.
A Massive Plot Pivot: Jumba the Villain?
The most jarring change in the remake is the ending. In the 2002 version, Jumba is a "lovable" mad scientist who eventually becomes part of the family. Captain Gantu was the real muscle and the primary antagonist.
The remake tosses Gantu out the window.
Instead, Jumba stays the primary threat throughout the movie. He even tries to "reprogram" Stitch into Experiment 627—a deep-cut reference for fans of the TV show. This makes the final act feel way more personal, but it also makes the "Ohana" ending a bit trickier to swallow. How do you welcome a guy into your home after he tried to lobotomize your best friend?
The San Diego Twist
The movie also tries to ground Nani's struggle. We find out she had a full scholarship to study marine biology in San Diego. She’s not just "working a job"; she’s actively sacrificing a massive future to stay with Lilo. It adds a layer of grief to her character that the original only hinted at.
Filming on Oahu: The Real Star
Unlike some Disney remakes that look like they were filmed inside a giant grey computer (looking at you, Lion King), this one actually went to Hawaii. They filmed all over Oahu—Makaha, Haleiwa, and Waikiki.
Using real locations makes a huge difference. You can feel the humidity. The surfing scenes at Makaha Beach aren't just green-screened nonsense; they used real water and local surfers. It gives the live action Lilo & Stitch a sense of place that saves it from being a total corporate product.
Is It Worth the Watch?
Look, if you're a purist, the CGI Stitch might weird you out at first. He’s "furry" now. But once Chris Sanders starts talking, you sort of forget the CGI and just see the character.
The film is shorter than you'd expect—about 108 minutes—and it moves fast. Maybe too fast. The relationship building between Nani and Lilo feels a bit rushed because the movie is so focused on the alien shenanigans.
✨ Don't miss: Kelly Bishop’s The Third Gilmore Girl: Why This Memoir Hits Different
What you should do next:
If you're planning on seeing it, go back and watch the 2002 original first. Not to compare them—because the remake will lose that fight every time—but to appreciate the small Easter eggs. Look for Tia Carrere as the social worker Mrs. Kekoa; her interaction with the "new" Nani is easily the most emotional part of the film for long-time fans. Also, keep an eye out for Jason Scott Lee (the original David) who has a small but meaningful cameo.
Ultimately, this remake is for the kids of 2025, not necessarily the kids of 2002. It’s messier, more technical, and a little less "weird," but the core message—that family is what you make it—is still buried under all those pixels.