You’re driving through Westerville, heading toward the edge of Columbus, and suddenly the suburban sprawl just... stops. That’s when you hit Little Turtle Golf Club. It’s a bit of an anomaly. Most people in Central Ohio hear "private club" and immediately think of the stuffy, high-walled fortresses in New Albany or the historic, somewhat intimidating atmosphere of Scioto. But Little Turtle is different. It’s laid back. Honestly, it’s basically a neighborhood hangout that just happens to have one of the most challenging Pete Dye designs in the Midwest.
If you’ve spent any time playing Little Turtle Golf Club Columbus OH, you know the reputation. People call it "The Turtle" for a reason, and usually, it's because the course has a way of snapping back at you if you get too aggressive.
The Pete Dye Influence (And Why It’ll Drive You Crazy)
Let’s get the elephant out of the room. This isn't a "grip it and rip it" kind of place. Pete Dye, the legendary architect behind TPC Sawgrass and Whistling Straits, designed this track back in the early 70s. If you know Dye, you know his hallmarks: visual intimidation, railroad ties, and greens that require a surgeon’s precision. At Little Turtle, he didn’t hold back.
The course recently underwent a massive $3 million renovation, and it changed the vibe significantly. They brought in Hurdzan Golf Design to modernize things. They didn't just slap on some new grass; they fundamentally rethought how the course plays for the modern golfer. The bunkers are cleaner. The drainage—which, let's be real, used to be a major issue during Ohio's rainy springs—is lightyears better than it was a decade ago.
It’s a par 71. Short? On paper, maybe. In reality? Not even close.
You’ll find yourself standing on tees where the fairway looks about as wide as a sidewalk. Take the par-4 14th hole, for example. It’s a beast. You’re looking at water, narrow landing zones, and a green that doesn't care about your feelings. You can’t just muscle your way through this course. You have to think. You have to plot. It’s a chess match with grass.
✨ Don't miss: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
What People Get Wrong About the Membership
There’s this weird misconception that Little Turtle is strictly for the elite. It’s not. While it is a private facility, the culture here is remarkably "un-country club." You’ll see guys in hoodies. You’ll see families grabbing dinner at the Tavern who aren't even there to golf. It’s a lifestyle club, which is a buzzword people use a lot lately, but here it actually fits.
The membership structure is actually pretty flexible compared to the old-school clubs in the Columbus area. They offer junior memberships for the under-40 crowd, which has brought a much younger, more energetic demographic to the property.
- There’s no crazy, decade-long waiting list.
- The initiation fees aren't going to require a second mortgage.
- The social calendar is actually full of stuff people want to do, like bourbon tastings and live music, rather than just formal galas.
The pool area is a massive draw in the summer. It feels more like a resort than a local club. If you have kids, this is usually the selling point. While you’re out there losing three balls in the creek, the rest of the family is actually enjoying themselves.
The Food Scene at Little Turtle
Okay, let's talk about the Tavern. Usually, golf course food is a gamble. It’s either a soggy deli sandwich or an overpriced steak that tastes like cardboard. The kitchen at Little Turtle actually puts in the work.
They’ve leaned into the "upscale casual" thing. The burgers are legit. But honestly, the sleeper hit is the pizza. I know, a golf club with good pizza sounds fake, but they have a dedicated oven and the crust is actually worth the carbs. It’s become a go-to spot for people living in the surrounding Little Turtle neighborhood, which creates this cool community feel that most private clubs lack because they’re too busy trying to keep the public out.
🔗 Read more: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
Practice Facilities and the Fitness Factor
If you’re serious about your game, the practice range is solid, though it can get crowded on Saturday mornings. They have a massive putting green that mimics the undulations you’ll face on the course, which is necessary because the greens at Little Turtle are notoriously fast. If you don't spend twenty minutes there before your round, your three-putt percentage is going to skyrocket.
They also added a fitness center. It’s not just a couple of rusty dumbbells in a basement. It’s a full-service gym with modern equipment. This is part of that "lifestyle" shift. Members are actually using the club for their morning workouts before heading to the office.
Is It Worth the Drive?
If you live in Downtown Columbus or the Short North, you’re looking at a 15 to 20-minute drive. For some people, that’s a dealbreaker. But when you consider the cost-to-value ratio, it’s hard to beat.
Think about it. You can pay double at a club closer to the city and deal with a much more rigid atmosphere. Or you can head out to the Turtle, play a course that will actually make you a better golfer because it punishes bad decisions, and then hang out in a bar where people actually know your name.
The course is tucked away behind some condos and forest, so it feels isolated in a good way. You don’t hear the highway. You just hear the sound of your ball hitting a tree because you tried to hero-shot a 5-iron over a creek. We’ve all been there.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
Realities of the Course Conditions
I’m not going to sit here and tell you it’s Augusta National. It’s a Midwest course. In July and August, when the Ohio humidity hits 90%, the rough gets thick and punishing. The staff does an incredible job with the greens, keeping them rolling true even in the heat of the summer, but like any course with this much elevation change and water, maintenance is a constant battle.
The bunkers were a point of contention for years. They’ve fixed a lot of that with the recent renovations, using better sand and improved liners. It makes a difference. Nothing ruins a round faster than hitting out of a "bunker" that’s actually just wet red clay. You won't find much of that here anymore.
Getting Started and Next Steps
If you’re thinking about checking out Little Turtle Golf Club Columbus OH, don't just cold-call the membership director and sign a contract. You need to see it first.
How to actually vet the club:
- Request a Preview Round: Most private clubs, Little Turtle included, will let prospective members play a round to get a feel for the course. Do this on a weekday if you can to see the "real" pace of play.
- Check the Social Calendar: Ask to see the last three months of member events. If it’s all bridge tournaments and you’re into fitness and craft beer, it might not be your vibe. Luckily, Little Turtle leans toward the latter.
- Walk the Fitness and Pool Area: Go during a time when people are actually there. If you have a family, show up on a Saturday afternoon. If you can’t see yourself spending four hours there, the membership isn't worth it.
- Talk to the Pro: The golf staff here is knowledgeable and actually stays around. Ask about their lesson programs. A club is only as good as its pro shop’s ability to help you stop slicing.
Once you’ve done the walkthrough, look at the different membership tiers. They have social memberships if you aren't a golfer but want access to the gym, pool, and dining. It’s a smart way to get your foot in the door without committing to a full golf equity membership.
Ultimately, Little Turtle is for the golfer who wants a challenge without the ego. It’s a place where the course is tough, but the people are easygoing. In the crowded Columbus golf market, that’s a harder combination to find than you’d think.