It’s late. You’re scrolling. Maybe you’re stressed, or maybe you just need to feel something that isn't a notification ping. You decide to listen to Pentatonix Hallelujah for the hundredth time. Why? Because even though Leonard Cohen wrote it and Jeff Buckley "perfected" it, this Texas-born a cappella group did something to the song that shouldn't actually work on paper. They stripped away every single instrument and somehow made it sound heavier than a full orchestra.
Most people don't realize that when Pentatonix released this track on A Pentatonix Christmas back in 2016, they weren't just covering a classic. They were taking a massive risk. "Hallelujah" is arguably the most over-covered song in the history of modern music. It’s been done by everyone from Bon Jovi to Susan Boyle. It's the song that judges on American Idol tell contestants to avoid because it’s "too big." Yet, within days of hitting YouTube, the PTX version became the definitive modern interpretation for a whole new generation.
The A Cappella Magic You’re Actually Hearing
Let’s be real for a second. Most a cappella feels a bit... collegiate? It’s often very "Glee" or "Pitch Perfect," with lots of snappy fingers and "do-be-do" sounds. But when you listen to Pentatonix Hallelujah, that’s not what’s happening.
The arrangement, crafted largely by the group’s own members, utilizes the human voice as a literal soundboard. You have Avi Kaplan (the group’s original bass) hitting notes that feel like they’re vibrating in your chest. Then you have Kevin Olusola, who isn't even beatboxing here—he's providing a rhythmic, breathy foundation that acts like a cello.
It’s about the dynamics. The song starts with Scott Hoying’s solo, which is vulnerable and almost conversational. It doesn't scream "look at me." It says "listen to the story." By the time Kirstin Maldonado and Mitch Grassi layer in their harmonies, the sound pressure level increases without the help of a single amplifier or drum kit. That’s the "wall of sound" effect that keeps people coming back.
Why Leonard Cohen’s Lyrics Matter Here
Cohen’s original lyrics are famously "horny and holy." It’s a song about brokenness, sex, and religious disillusionment. When PTX performs it, they lean heavily into the "holy" aspect, which is why it became a Christmas staple, despite the song having absolutely nothing to do with the birth of Jesus.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
Interestingly, they chose specific verses. They skip some of the more overtly carnal lines found in the original 1984 Various Positions version, opting instead for the verses that emphasize the "broken Hallelujah." This makes the song feel universal. Whether you’re religious or just someone who’s had a really rough year, the phrasing hits home.
The Visual Impact of the Desert
If you’re watching the music video while you listen to Pentatonix Hallelujah, the setting adds a whole other layer. They filmed it in a stark, prehistoric-looking desert landscape. No glitz. No costumes. Just five people in winter coats standing in the dirt.
- The isolation of the setting mirrors the isolation in the lyrics.
- The lack of "production" makes the vocal talent the only focus.
- The cinematography uses slow, sweeping pans that match the 6/8 time signature of the song.
There is a specific moment at the 2:15 mark where the harmony peaks. If you watch their eyes, they aren't looking at the camera; they are looking at each other. That’s the secret sauce of Pentatonix. They are a "unit" in the most literal sense. They have to hear each other to stay in tune. There is no Auto-Tune safety net that can fix a five-part chord if the intervals are off.
Breaking Down the Vocal Stack
If you want to nerd out on the technical side, pay attention to the "stacking." In the final chorus, they aren't just singing the same notes. They are using complex jazz-influenced clusters.
Mitch Grassi’s countertenor is doing the heavy lifting on the high end. Most men can't hit those notes in a full voice, but Mitch makes it sound like a flute. Meanwhile, Scott and Kirstin provide the "meat" of the harmony in the mid-range. When people say they want to listen to Pentatonix Hallelujah on repeat, it’s usually because their brains are trying to untangle those five distinct layers of sound.
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Honestly, it’s a masterclass in vocal production. They recorded this in a way that feels intimate—like they are standing three feet away from you—but also cavernous.
Common Misconceptions About the Cover
Some purists argue that the PTX version is "too pretty." They say Cohen meant for the song to be gravelly and weathered.
I get that. But music evolves.
The beauty of "Hallelujah" is its elasticity. It can be a dirge, a prayer, or a pop anthem. Pentatonix turned it into a testament of human capability. When you realize that every "snare hit" or "bass hum" is coming from a human throat, the song takes on a different meaning. It becomes a celebration of what we can do with nothing but our breath.
How to Get the Best Experience
Don't listen to this on your phone speakers. Seriously.
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
If you're going to listen to Pentatonix Hallelujah, use a decent pair of over-ear headphones or a solid sound system. You need to hear the sub-harmonics of the bass and the slight intake of breath before the big notes. That’s where the humanity lives.
- Check out the 4K version: The official YouTube upload is high-res and captures the textures of the landscape and the subtle facial expressions of the group.
- Listen for the "Vocal Percussion": Even in this "stripped" version, Kevin Olusola is doing subtle things with his breath to keep the tempo locked.
- Compare the Eras: If you really want to see how the group has changed, listen to this 2016 version and then find a live recording from their 2024 or 2025 tours. The arrangement has matured, and Matt Sallee (the new bass) brings a different, darker timbre to the low end compared to Avi.
What to Do Next
If this song moved you, don't stop there. The world of vocal-only music is deeper than you think.
Start by looking up the "making of" videos for the A Pentatonix Christmas album. It’s fascinating to see how they layer these tracks in the studio. Then, go back to the source—listen to Leonard Cohen’s 1984 original. It’s haunting, weird, and synthesizery. It’ll give you a whole new appreciation for how far the song has traveled.
Finally, if you’re a singer yourself, try to pick out just one of the harmony lines while the song plays. It’s a lot harder than it sounds. It forces you to really listen to the architecture of the music rather than just the melody. Whether you're a casual listener or a die-hard fan, there's always something new to find in those five minutes of music.
Go back and hit play again. Pay attention to the silence between the notes this time. That’s where the real Hallelujah is.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Search for "PTX Hallelujah Stems": If you can find the isolated vocal tracks, it will blow your mind how much work goes into each individual part.
- Explore the "Cello-boxing" version: Kevin Olusola has solo versions of songs where he plays cello and beatboxes simultaneously; it’s the spiritual cousin to this arrangement.
- Update your playlist: Add the 2016 version alongside the live "Hallelujah" from their The Greatest Hits collection to hear how their blend has tightened over a decade of touring.