Netflix has basically become the unofficial home for the "Lindsay Lohan Renaissance." If you’ve been following her career trajectory since 2022, you know exactly what I’m talking about. First, we had Falling for Christmas, which was cute, then Irish Wish, which was... well, it was a movie. Now, we have Our Little Secret. It’s the third installment in her multi-picture deal with the streaming giant, and honestly, the vibes are a little bit different this time around.
The premise is a classic trope trap. Two resentful exes—Avery (Lohan) and Logan (Ian Harding)—find out that their current partners are actually siblings. Naturally, this discovery happens right as they are forced to spend Christmas under the same roof. It’s messy. It’s awkward. It’s exactly what Netflix subscribers crave during the holidays when they want to turn their brains off and look at pretty decorations and knit sweaters.
But there is a specific reason this one feels a bit weightier than her previous holiday outings. We finally get to see Lohan play off a comedic powerhouse. Kristin Chenoweth joins the cast as the formidable, slightly terrifying matriarch of the family, Erica. If you’ve seen Chenoweth in anything, you know she doesn't just "act" in a scene; she consumes it. This dynamic creates a friction that was missing from the sugary-sweet Falling for Christmas.
The Logan and Avery Problem: Chemistry or Just History?
One thing people always get wrong about Our Little Secret is assuming it's a straightforward "enemies-to-lovers" story. It’s not. It’s more of an "exes-who-never-really-processed-their-breakup" story.
Ian Harding, whom most people recognize as the guy from Pretty Little Liars, has a very specific type of screen presence. He’s charming, but in a way that feels a bit more grounded than the typical Hallmark-style male lead. When he and Avery are forced into a storage closet (yes, the movie actually goes there), the dialogue doesn't feel like a scripted poem. It feels like two people who used to know everything about each other and now realize they know nothing.
Why the "Secret" Part Actually Works
The central conflict—the secret itself—is where the movie derives most of its energy. Avery is dating Cameron (Jon Rudnitsky), and Logan is dating Brooke (Katie Baker). The fact that Cameron and Brooke are siblings is the "small world" coincidence that drives the plot, but the real meat is the fear of social annihilation.
- They aren't just hiding a past fling.
- They are hiding a long-term, failed relationship that ended badly.
- They are doing it in the house of a woman (Erica) who smells weakness like a bloodhound.
If they confess, they ruin the holiday for the people they supposedly love. If they keep quiet, they have to lie to everyone’s face while sharing a dinner table. It’s a low-stakes disaster movie. That’s the secret sauce of the modern Netflix rom-com. It’s not about life and death; it’s about the soul-crushing embarrassment of being found out.
💡 You might also like: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
Breaking Down the Production: Behind the Scenes of Our Little Secret
Director Stephen Herek is no stranger to this genre. He’s the guy who gave us 101 Dalmatians (1996) and The Mighty Ducks. He knows how to frame a family dynamic that feels lived-in. Filming took place in various locations that perfectly mimic that high-end, snowy New England aesthetic, even if the actual "magic" mostly comes from the set decorators and the lighting department.
The cinematography doesn't reinvent the wheel. It uses a warm, amber-heavy color palette that makes every room look like a Crate & Barrel catalog. This is intentional. Netflix knows that for Our Little Secret, the background is just as important as the dialogue. Viewers want to see the oversized ornaments and the perfectly dusted snow on the porch. It’s aspirational cozy-core.
The Supporting Cast is Carrying the Load
While Lohan is the draw, the supporting cast keeps the engine running. Jon Rudnitsky brings a specific kind of "earnest but slightly oblivious" energy to Cameron. He is the perfect foil for Ian Harding’s more cynical Logan. Then you have the legendary Tim Meadows. He brings a dry, understated humor that balances out Chenoweth’s high-octane performance.
Honestly, the scenes without the leads are sometimes the funniest. The movie understands that a family Christmas isn't just about the couple; it's about the weird aunts, the competitive siblings, and the dad who just wants to eat his ham in peace.
How Our Little Secret Fits Into the "Lohan-ance"
There is a lot of talk about how Lindsay Lohan has "changed" her acting style. In the early 2000s, she was the queen of the frantic, high-energy teen comedy. Mean Girls and Freaky Friday relied on her impeccable comedic timing. In Our Little Secret, she’s more subdued. She’s playing an adult with a career and real-world anxieties.
Some critics argue that she's lost that "spark," but that's a misunderstanding of what she's doing. She’s leaning into the "straight man" role. In this movie, she’s the one reacting to the chaos around her. It’s a more mature performance, even if the material is light. She’s anchoring the movie. Without her groundedness, Chenoweth’s character might have drifted into cartoon territory.
📖 Related: America's Got Talent Transformation: Why the Show Looks So Different in 2026
The Script's Weirdly Specific Humor
The writer, Hailey DeDominicis, threw in some jokes that feel surprisingly "internet-literate." There are references and beats that feel like they were written by someone who actually spends time on social media, rather than a room of executives trying to guess what people find funny. It’s subtle. You’ll catch a look Avery gives the camera—or a specific way Logan describes their past—that feels more "real" than your average TV movie.
Addressing the Critics: Is it Too Predictable?
Look, if you're watching Our Little Secret expecting a David Lynch plot twist, you’re in the wrong place. Of course it’s predictable. We know where the characters are going to end up before the first commercial break (if Netflix had commercial breaks).
The value isn't in the what, it's in the how.
The tension comes from the "near misses." It’s the moment when someone almost walks into the room while Avery and Logan are arguing. It’s the accidental touch that lingers a second too long. The movie leans into the tropes because the audience expects them. Deviating too far from the formula would actually hurt the "Discover" potential of a film like this. People search for "movies like Falling for Christmas" because they want that specific feeling. This movie delivers that feeling with a slightly sharper edge.
Comparison: Falling for Christmas vs. Our Little Secret
| Feature | Falling for Christmas | Our Little Secret |
|---|---|---|
| Tone | Pure Fantasy / Whimsical | Sarcastic / Cringe-Comedy |
| Conflict | Amnesia | Hidden Past |
| Antagonist | None (Nature?) | Social Pressure / Mother-in-law |
| Setting | Luxury Ski Resort | Family Estate |
The shift from a resort to a home makes the stakes feel more personal. In a resort, you can leave. In a family home during a snowstorm, you are trapped. That claustrophobia is what makes the comedy work.
What Real Fans are Saying (And What They’re Missing)
If you dig through the forums and social media threads, there’s a divide. Younger fans who only know Lohan from her recent Netflix era think it’s a masterpiece of the genre. Older fans who grew up with The Parent Trap are looking for that specific nostalgia hit.
👉 See also: All I Watch for Christmas: What You’re Missing About the TBS Holiday Tradition
The thing they’re missing is that Our Little Secret isn't trying to be a nostalgia trip. It’s trying to be a 2024/2025 holiday staple. It’s designed to be rewatched every December while you’re wrapping gifts. It’s background noise that occasionally demands your full attention with a witty one-liner from Kristin Chenoweth.
Common Misconceptions About the Ending
Without spoiling the specifics, many people think the movie takes the easy way out. I’d argue it actually handles the "resolution" better than most. It acknowledges that you can't just fix a year of lying with a single apology. There are consequences. The characters have to actually deal with the fallout of their deception, even if it is wrapped in a bow by the time the credits roll.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Next Movie Night
If you're planning on watching Our Little Secret, don't just put it on. Maximize the experience.
- Watch it as a double feature. Pair it with Irish Wish. It’s fascinating to see the evolution of Lohan’s "Netflix persona" between the two films. You can see her getting more comfortable with the format.
- Pay attention to the background characters. The "secret" isn't the only thing happening in that house. The B-plots involving the other family members are surprisingly well-developed and offer some of the best laughs.
- Look for the Easter eggs. There are small nods to Lohan’s previous work hidden in the set design and some of the dialogue. It’s a fun game for long-time fans.
- Manage your expectations. This is a comfort movie. It is designed to make you feel good, not to challenge your worldview. Lean into the cheesiness.
The "secret" to enjoying Our Little Secret is acknowledging that it’s exactly what it says on the tin: a glossy, well-acted, slightly chaotic holiday romp that reminds us why we liked Lindsay Lohan in the first place. She’s got the charm. She’s got the timing. And now, she’s got the perfect platform to keep this streak going.
Before you press play, make sure you have the right mindset. This isn't high art; it's high-quality entertainment. It’s the cinematic equivalent of a hot chocolate with way too many marshmallows. Is it too much? Maybe. But that’s exactly why we love it during the holidays. Keep an eye on the chemistry between the leads—it's more nuanced than you might expect on a first watch.
Next Steps for the Viewer:
Check your Netflix region settings to ensure you have access to the full "Lohan Suite" of films, as some titles vary by territory. If you’ve already seen the film, look up the official soundtrack; the holiday covers used throughout the movie are specifically curated to match the "cringe-but-cute" aesthetic of Avery and Logan's journey.