You’ve probably heard of Plains, Georgia, because of the peanuts and the 39th President. But right there on Hospital Street sits a brick building that’s basically a living time capsule. Most people call it the Lillian G. Carter Nursing Center, though its official name has flipped around a few times over the decades. It isn't just a place where seniors go for rehab; it's the actual spot where Jimmy Carter entered the world in 1924.
Back then, it was known as the Wise Sanitarium.
It’s kinda wild to think about, but Jimmy Carter was the first U.S. President ever born in a hospital. Before him, everyone was born at home. His mother, "Miss Lillian," was a registered nurse there. She wasn't just any nurse; she was a woman who basically ignored the Jim Crow laws of the time to treat whoever needed help, regardless of skin color. Today, that legacy of grit and care is supposed to be what keeps the doors open.
The Weird History of Wise Sanitarium
In 1921, three brothers—the Wise doctors—built this place. It was a big deal for a tiny town like Plains. It only had 60 beds, but it was one of the first small hospitals in Georgia to get real accreditation.
Then things got messy.
✨ Don't miss: Ankle Stretches for Runners: What Most People Get Wrong About Mobility
There was a massive explosion in 1936. The building was abandoned for years. Eventually, it was sold for a pittance—like $2,300—and then flipped a year later for $50,000 after some serious repairs. Honestly, the fact that it’s still standing after an explosion and decades of name changes is a miracle in itself. In 1976, they renamed it to honor Miss Lillian.
What the Lillian G. Carter Nursing Center is Like Today
If you walk in there now, you aren't going to see a museum. It’s a 100-bed skilled nursing facility. They do the heavy lifting: physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech-language pathology.
It’s currently owned by a group called Mid GA Health Properties (under the Harborview umbrella). They’ve got a mix of long-term residents and people just staying for a few weeks to recover from surgery.
- The Vibe: It’s small-town Georgia.
- The Food: They actually partner with "Georgia Grown" to use local products. You'll see gourmet snack carts with fresh fruit and pastries.
- The Tech: They’ve leaned into telemedicine. This is huge because Plains is rural. If a resident needs a specialist, they don't always have to drive to Americus or Albany; they can do a virtual consult right there.
The Real Talk on Ratings
Look, I’m not going to sugarcoat it. Nursing home ratings are a roller coaster. As of early 2026, the facility (often listed as Lillian Carter Health and Rehabilitation) holds a 4-star health inspection rating from Medicare. That’s solid. But—and there’s always a but—their staffing ratings have historically been lower, sometimes hovering around 2 stars.
🔗 Read more: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil
High turnover is a plague in the nursing industry, and this center hasn't been immune. They’ve had citations for things like care planning and respiratory care in the past. If you’re looking at this place for a family member, you've gotta look past the "Presidential Birthplace" plaque and check the most recent CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) reports.
Why Miss Lillian Still Matters Here
Bessie Lillian Gordy Carter was a force of nature. She joined the Peace Corps at 68. She went to India to treat leprosy. When she worked at the sanitarium in Plains, she’d work 20-hour shifts for $6 a day. Sometimes people couldn't pay, so they gave her chickens or firewood.
That spirit is what the facility tries to market. They talk a lot about "God having dominion" and being a faith-based organization. They even have a "Silver Quality Award" from the American Health Care Association.
Navigating the Costs
It isn't cheap, but then again, nothing in healthcare is. Monthly rates can swing wildly.
💡 You might also like: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis
- Basic Care: Starts around $1,895 but can rocket up to $5,800 depending on the room.
- Room Types: They’ve got semi-private, shared, and some private suites.
- Payment: They take Medicare and Medicaid. Honestly, about 95% of the people there are long-term residents, so navigating the Medicaid "pending" status is something their admin team handles a lot.
Is it the right fit?
If you're looking for a shiny, high-tech metro facility, this isn't it. It’s an old building with a lot of history. It feels like the South.
The proximity to Phoebe Sumter Medical Center (about 8 miles away) is a safety net. But the real draw is the community. In a town of 700 people, everyone knows who is in the nursing center. You aren't anonymous there.
Actionable Steps for Families
- Show up unannounced. Don't just take the "scheduled tour." Walk in on a Tuesday afternoon. Smell the air. See if the call lights are blinking for ten minutes or two.
- Check the turnover. Ask the administrator specifically: "How many of your RNs have been here longer than a year?"
- Verify the bed count. They are licensed for 100 beds, but the daily census is often lower (around 50-60). A lower census usually means more individual attention, which is a plus.
- Review the 2567 form. This is the public record of every deficiency found during state inspections. It’s usually kept in a binder near the front entrance. Read it.
The Lillian G. Carter Nursing Center is more than just a nursing home; it’s a piece of American history that’s still trying to function in a very difficult modern healthcare market. It’s got flaws, sure, but it’s also got a legacy that few other facilities in the world can claim.
To get the most accurate picture of current care, visit the Medicare Care Compare website and search for provider number 115550. This gives you the raw data on fines, staffing hours per resident, and recent health citations that marketing brochures might skip over. If you're local, stop by the Plains Welcome Center first; the locals usually have the most honest "boots on the ground" perspective on how the facility is running lately.