Robert Durst was a ghost long before he actually died. For nearly forty years, the scion of one of New York’s most powerful real estate dynasties lived in the hollowed-out space between a "person of interest" and a convicted killer. Most people think they know the story because of that chilling hot-mic moment in a bathroom, but the reality is much weirder. It’s a tale of $100 million, a pair of latex masks, a sandwich that cost $5.99, and a trail of bodies that spanned from the skyscrapers of Manhattan to a dingy apartment in Galveston, Texas.
He was a man who had everything. Then he spent the rest of his life acting like a man with nothing to lose.
The Disappearance That Started It All
It began in 1982. Kathie McCormack Durst was a bright medical student, just months away from her degree. Then, on a cold January night, she vanished. Robert—or "Bobby," as his friends called him—told police he dropped her off at a train station in Katonah, New York. He said they had a drink, they argued, and she left for their city apartment.
Honestly, the holes in his story were big enough to drive a truck through.
Five days passed before he even reported her missing. When he finally did, he was already cleaning out her closet. Her family, the McCormacks, knew something was wrong immediately. They spent decades screaming into the void, trying to get the NYPD and Westchester authorities to take Robert seriously as a suspect. But money talks. The Durst name carried a lot of weight in New York, and for a long time, that weight kept the investigation at a standstill.
🔗 Read more: The Sinking of Prince of Wales and Repulse: Why the Battleship Era Ended in Three Hours
Life as a Mute Woman in Galveston
By the year 2000, things were getting hot again. New York investigators had reopened Kathie’s case. Robert didn't stick around to chat. He fled to Galveston, Texas, but he didn't go as a millionaire. He went as "Dorothy Ciner," a mute woman in a wig and house dresses.
Think about that for a second. One of the richest men in America was living in a $300-a-month apartment, pretending he couldn't speak, just to hide from a cold case.
This is where the life and death of Robert Durst takes its most grisly turn. In 2001, body parts started washing up in Galveston Bay. They belonged to Morris Black, Robert’s neighbor. Robert was arrested, but here’s the kicker: he skipped bail. He was eventually caught in Pennsylvania for—get this—shoplifting a chicken salad sandwich. He had $37,000 in cash in his car, but he couldn't help himself. He had to steal the sandwich.
The trial that followed was a masterclass in "how to get away with murder." His lawyers argued that Morris Black had threatened Robert with a gun, and during a struggle, the gun went off. Robert, in a "disassociative state" fueled by panic, then decided to dismember the body.
The jury acquitted him. They actually let him go.
👉 See also: Santa Paula Fire Today Live: What Most People Get Wrong About the Current Risk
Susan Berman and the Letter That Changed Everything
While all the Texas drama was happening, another body had been found in Los Angeles. Susan Berman was Robert’s long-time friend, the daughter of a Las Vegas mobster, and his unofficial spokesperson. She was found shot execution-style in her home on Christmas Eve, 2000.
Police had received an anonymous note with her address and the word "CADAVER" written in block letters. For years, it was just another mystery.
Then came The Jinx.
During the filming of the HBO documentary, director Andrew Jarecki confronted Durst with a letter he had written to Berman years prior. The handwriting was identical to the "cadaver" note. Even the misspelling of "Beverley Hills" was the same. Robert’s reaction on camera was visceral. He started burping, blinking manically, looking like a man who had finally seen the floor drop out from under him.
The most famous part, of course, is when he went to the bathroom with his microphone still on.
✨ Don't miss: Why the 11th September 2001 Attack Still Defines Our Modern World
"There it is. You're caught," he whispered to himself. "What the hell did I do? Killed them all, of course."
The Final Act in a California Hospital
Robert was arrested in New Orleans the day before that final episode aired. He was found with a latex mask, a fake ID, and a pile of cash. He was ready to run to Cuba. But this time, the clock ran out.
The trial for Susan Berman’s murder was a marathon, delayed by COVID-19 and Robert’s own crumbling health. He sat in the courtroom in a wheelchair, looking frail and skeletal, often with a catheter bag visible. It felt like a performance, but he was genuinely dying. In September 2021, a jury finally found him guilty. He was sentenced to life without parole.
He didn't last long. On January 10, 2022, Robert Durst died of cardiac arrest in a hospital in Stockton, California. He was 78.
Because he died while his case was still being appealed, his conviction was technically "abated" under California law. Basically, in the eyes of the court, he died an innocent man. It’s a final, frustrating irony for the families of Kathie Durst, Susan Berman, and Morris Black.
What This Story Teaches Us Today
Looking back at the life and death of Robert Durst, it’s easy to get lost in the "true crime" spectacle. But there are real lessons here about wealth and the justice system.
- The Power of Persistence: The McCormack family never stopped fighting for Kathie. Their pressure is the only reason the case stayed alive for forty years.
- The Danger of Hubris: Durst didn't have to do that documentary. His lawyers told him not to. He thought he was smarter than everyone else, and that's ultimately what did him in.
- Check the Fine Print: Technicalities like "abatement by death" show that the legal system doesn't always provide the emotional closure families need.
If you’re following this case, the best way to honor the victims is to look past the "eccentric millionaire" headlines. Focus on the actual evidence that was buried for decades. You can still look up the Westchester District Attorney’s reports or the trial transcripts from the Los Angeles case to see the sheer volume of circumstantial evidence that was ignored for far too long. Understanding how he slipped through the cracks is the only way to make sure it doesn't happen again.
The story officially ended in a prison hospital, but for the people he left behind, the questions never really stop. Knowing the timeline is one thing; seeing how money can stall the truth is another entirely.