You’re wandering through the rain-soaked, corpse-strewn streets of Elysion Boulevard. Everything in Krat wants you dead. Then, you hear it. A ragged, sobbing sound coming from a lighted window. This is your introduction to the Lies of P Weeping Woman, an NPC who provides one of the earliest and most poignant examples of the game's core mechanic: the choice between a harsh truth and a comforting lie.
It's a gut-punch.
In a world filled with clockwork monstrosities, this woman is just... grieving. She’s sick with the Petrification Disease, she’s losing her mind, and she’s lost her baby. Most players stumble upon her by accident, but her quest is actually vital if you're trying to unlock specific endings or just want to understand what makes Neowiz’s Soulslike so special. Honestly, if you ignore her, you’re missing out on the emotional soul of the game’s first act.
Finding the Weeping Woman and the Broken Baby Puppet
So, where is she? You’ll find her near the Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard Stargazer. You have to navigate across some rooftops and deal with a few annoying puppets—including one of those large, bulky ones that loves to slam its fists—before you find a window with a silhouette of a woman.
She asks you for a favor. She wants her baby back.
She says the Krat City Hall authorities took her child. She’s desperate. Now, here’s the thing: you can’t actually find a human baby. Krat is a graveyard. Instead, you have to progress toward the Krat City Hall Courtyard. Just before the boss fight with the Scrapped Watchman, there’s a small side area guarded by a large puppet. Defeat him, and you'll find an item on the ground.
💡 You might also like: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026
It’s the Broken Baby Puppet.
The description is grim. It’s a wooden doll, dressed in infant clothes, meant to mimic a child. It’s a cruel mockery of what she lost. Picking it up triggers the next phase of the quest, and this is where the Lies of P Weeping Woman choice actually matters for your playthrough.
The Lie vs. The Truth: What Should You Choose?
When you return to the window with the doll, the woman is ecstatic. She thinks you’ve brought her Elena back. She asks you point-blank: "Isn't she beautiful? My Elena, she's a beautiful baby, isn't she?"
You have two options.
- "She's a cute baby" (The Lie)
- "That's a puppet" (The Truth)
If you tell her she’s a cute baby, P’s "springs are reacting." This is the game's way of telling you that your humanity is increasing. You get the Feel record—which is a masterpiece of a track—and a Vivid Ergo Fragment. More importantly, you've comforted a dying woman in her final moments.
📖 Related: Grand Theft Auto Games Timeline: Why the Chronology is a Beautiful Mess
If you tell her the truth? You get the Ergo, but you don't get the record. You also break her heart. She realizes her delusion is just that—a delusion. She dies in despair.
Why does this matter? Because Lies of P isn’t just about dodging and parrying. It’s about the "Humanity" stat. To get the Rise of P ending (widely considered the "best" or "true" ending), you need to lie. A lot. You need to show empathy. The game argues that being human isn't about biological parts; it's about the capacity to feel and to spare others from unnecessary pain.
The Hidden Complexity of the Weeping Woman Quest
Most guides just tell you "Lie to get the record." But let's look at the lore for a second. The Lies of P Weeping Woman is a victim of the Petrification Disease. This isn't just a cough; it turns people into stone and messes with their heads.
There's a theory among the community—and supported by item descriptions found later in the game—that many "mad" NPCs aren't just crazy. They are reacting to the loss of the "Grand Covenant," the set of rules that governed puppets. When the puppets went rogue, the humans who relied on them lost everything. This woman represents the total collapse of the social order in Krat.
Why the "Feel" Record is Essential
Don't sleep on the records. In Lies of P, listening to records at the Hotel Krat is one of the primary ways to gain humanity. The track you get from this quest, "Feel," is a haunting, melancholic song that perfectly captures the vibe of Elysion Boulevard.
👉 See also: Among Us Spider-Man: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With These Mods
To maximize the benefit:
- Go back to Hotel Krat.
- Use the gramophone.
- Sit there and listen to the entire song.
- You'll see a notification that "Your springs are reacting" or "You feel warmth."
If you’re going for the Platinum trophy or all achievements, you literally cannot skip this. You need every record to complete the collection, and since this one is missable if you tell the truth, you have to commit to the lie.
Common Mistakes Players Make
I’ve seen people complain that the quest is "bugged" because they can't find the woman after the boss fight. Pro tip: Don't wait too long. While most quests in Lies of P don't "expire" immediately, it's best to finish this before you move on to the Cathedral area.
Another mistake? Accidentally selling the Broken Baby Puppet. Just... don't. It’s a quest item, but sometimes people get click-happy at the merchant. Also, make sure you actually talk to the woman before going to the City Hall courtyard. If you pick up the doll without having the quest active, you might be confused about why you're carrying a creepy wooden infant in your inventory.
Actionable Steps for Your Playthrough
If you are currently staring at that window on Elysion Boulevard, here is exactly what you need to do to get the best outcome:
- Talk to her first. Ensure the quest is active in your log.
- Clear City Hall. Head to the courtyard before the Scrapped Watchman boss.
- Grab the Doll. It's in the corner of the courtyard, usually guarded by a puppet with a shovel or a large blunt instrument.
- Lie. Tell her the baby is cute. No, it's not "honest," but in the context of P's journey toward becoming human, it is the "right" choice.
- Listen to the Record. Don't just let it sit in your inventory. Go back to the Hotel and play "Feel" from start to finish.
The Lies of P Weeping Woman quest serves as the perfect litmus test for the player. It asks you if you value objective truth over subjective mercy. In the world of Krat, where the truth is usually a pile of gears and cold blood, a small lie can be the most human thing you ever do.
Check your inventory for the "Feel" record now. If it's not there and you've already cleared the area, you might have told the truth. In that case, you'll have to pick it up in New Game Plus to fix your humanity score.