You're going to lie. A lot. Or maybe you won't? That’s the thing about hunting for the platinum in Neowiz’s soulslike hit; the game basically demands that you play it like a puppet master pulling its own strings. If you’re looking for a Lies of P trophy guide, you’ve probably already realized that this isn't a "one and done" kind of deal. It’s a journey through a crumbling Belle Époque city that requires at least two full playthroughs, though most people end up doing three because they messed up a single dialogue choice at the eleventh hour.
The game is brutal. It’s fast. It rewards parrying over dodging, which is a hard habit to break if you’re coming straight from Elden Ring. But the trophies? They’re mostly tied to your "Humanity." This isn't just a hidden stat; it's the heartbeat of the entire completionist run. If you don't listen to enough records or tell the right lies, you’re locked out of the best endings.
The Three Ending Problem
Most players hit a wall when they realize there are three distinct endings: Real Boy: They All Lived Happily Ever After, Free from the Puppet String, and Rise of P. You cannot get these in one go without some serious cloud-save manipulation on PlayStation, and even then, it's risky.
The "Real Boy" ending is the easiest because it’s basically the "bad" ending. You just give Geppetto what he wants at the end. Easy. Done. But "Rise of P"? That’s the white whale. You need high humanity—enough that your hair turns grey and the cat in Hotel Krat actually lets you pick it up. If the cat still hisses at you, you’re not human enough. It sounds silly, but that’s the metric.
Honestly, the hardest part is the Nameless Puppet. If you’re going for "Free from the Puppet String" or "Rise of P," you have to fight this guy. He is, without a doubt, the hardest boss in the game. He doesn't have a specter to help you. It's just you, your parry timing, and a lot of swearing. If you give up and hand over your heart to Geppetto, you miss the trophy for defeating him. Don't be that person.
🔗 Read more: Getting the Chopper GTA 4 Cheat Right: How to Actually Spawn a Buzzard or Annihilator
Why Humanity is Your Most Important Stat
Lying makes you human. It’s the central irony of the game. Every time you see the prompt "Your springs are reacting" or "The Ergo is whispering," you’re gaining humanity.
How to farm Humanity effectively:
- Listen to Records: You have to listen to them from start to finish at the gramophone in Hotel Krat. No skipping. You can’t just start it and walk away; you need to let the music play until the little notification pops up.
- Solve Riddles: The Arlecchino riddles aren't just for loot. They're humanity goldmines.
- The Pray Gesture: Go to the cathedral, find the statue, and use the "Pray" gesture. It’s a tiny detail, but it moves the needle.
- Lie when it matters: When the lady asks if her baby is beautiful (and it's clearly a puppet), you tell her it’s a cute kid. It’s a white lie. It counts.
Collectibles that Ruin Runs
If you’re following a Lies of P trophy guide, you’re probably worried about missing a single letter or a weapon. You should be. The Special Weapon Collector and Normal Weapon Collector trophies are notorious.
The "Golden Lie" weapon is the biggest offender. You can only get it if your humanity is nearly maxed out. If you’ve lied enough, the nose on the portrait of the boy in Geppetto’s office will grow into a long wooden staff. You can pluck it off the wall. If you played a "Truth" run, you’re locked out. Period. Start over.
Then there’s Eugénie’s quest. This one is a headache. To get her trophy and the "Far East Princess" story, you have to kill Alidoro, finish his cryptic vessel, and then talk to her. But wait—there are two different outcomes based on what you tell her about Alidoro’s identity. You need two playthroughs just to see both sides of her story. It’s these little branch points that make the platinum feel like a marathon.
💡 You might also like: Why Helldivers 2 Flesh Mobs are the Creepiest Part of the Galactic War
Boss Trophies and the Specter Crutch
Let’s talk about the bosses. Romeo, King of Puppets. Simon Manus. Laxasia the Complete. These are not easy fights. Laxasia, in particular, feels like she walked out of Sekiro and decided to ruin your afternoon with lightning bolts.
For the trophies, you just need to kill them. The game doesn't care if you use a Specter (the AI summon). There is no "Solo Only" trophy. If you’re struggling with the Green Monster of the Swamp—and you will, because that second phase is nonsense—just use the Star Fragments. There’s no shame in it. The only exception is the Nameless Puppet, where the game forces you to stand on your own two feet.
The Quartz Grind
You need to max out your P-Organ. That sounds suggestive, but it’s just the skill tree. You need a lot of Quartz. Most of it is dropped by mini-bosses or hidden in Trinity Rooms. If you miss the Trinity Keys, you miss the Quartz. If you miss the Quartz, you don't get the "Extreme Potential" trophy. Explore every corner of Venigni Works and the Arche Abbey.
Clean-up and New Game Plus
New Game Plus (NG+) in Lies of P is actually... fun? That’s rare. You keep your level, your weapons, and your P-Organ upgrades. More importantly, you unlock new P-Organ stages (Phase 6 and 7) that make you feel like a god. You can suddenly block "unblockable" red attacks. It changes the game.
📖 Related: Marvel Rivals Sexiest Skins: Why NetEase is Winning the Aesthetic War
You have to do NG+ for the platinum because of the Golden Records. These versions of the songs only appear in the second run and are required for the Record Collector trophy.
A Quick Checklist for the Final Stretch:
- Did you kill every Butterfly? They drop essential upgrade materials.
- Did you finish the Venigni quest? You need to find his butler, Pulcinella, and upgrade his shop fully.
- Did you find all the gestures? Some are tied to talking to NPCs after specific bosses. If you teleport away too fast, you might miss the window.
- The Sophia Choice: In the late game, you have to decide what to do with Sophia. This is the ultimate "point of no return." For the "Rise of P" ending, you give her peace. For "Free from the Puppet String," you let her live.
Nuance in the Narrative
One thing a lot of people overlook is the "Truth" run. People assume you just have to tell the truth 100% of the time. It’s actually more about not gaining humanity. You can still get the "Free from the Puppet String" ending by telling the truth, but it’s a hollow victory. The game wants you to feel the weight of these choices. When you finally get that Platinum, "Lies of P," it feels earned because you’ve seen every possible version of Pinocchio’s tragedy.
The difficulty curve is front-loaded. Once you get past the Fallen Archbishop Andreus, things click. You start to understand the rhythm. By the time you’re hunting for the last few trophies in the Arche Abbey, you’ll be parrying bosses into oblivion without even thinking about it.
Actionable Next Steps for the Platinum:
- Start with a "Lie" Run: Prioritize humanity and the "Rise of P" ending first. It’s the most content-heavy and gives you the "Golden Lie" weapon.
- Upload Saves: Right before the final choice in Geppetto’s office, upload your save to the cloud. You can get the "Real Boy" ending, reload, and then fight the Nameless Puppet for the other endings. This saves you an entire 30-hour playthrough.
- Buy All Throwables: If a boss is brick-walling you, especially in NG+, stock up on Shot Puts and Thermite. They are incredibly overpowered and can stagger a boss from across the arena.
- Check the Portrait: After every major boss, go back to Geppetto’s office. If the nose on the portrait has a glow, interact with it.
- Decrypt Everything: Never leave a Cryptic Vessel sitting in your inventory. Take them to Venigni immediately. They lead to the outfits and weapons needed for the "Collector" trophies.
- Focus on Capacity: In your P-Organ and stat leveling, don't sleep on Capacity. Being able to wear the heavy defensive liners without being "Slightly Heavy" is the difference between surviving a combo and dying in two hits.