You’re walking through the rain-slicked, blood-stained streets of Krat, specifically the Rosa Isabelle Street area, and you hear it. A faint, strained voice calling out from a window. It’s a classic trope in Soulslikes—the "window NPC"—but the story of Lies of P Leah hits different. It isn’t just about fetching an item. It’s a gut-punch that forces you to confront the core lie of the entire game: can a puppet truly love, or are they just programmed to mimic the motions of a broken heart?
Honestly, most players stumble onto this quest by accident while trying to survive those terrifying white-clad puppet dancers. But once you talk to the woman behind the glass, the atmosphere shifts from survival horror to something much more melancholic.
Finding the Julian the Gentleman Questline
To understand Leah, you first have to meet Julian. He’s standing near the Stargazer at Rosa Isabelle Street Culvert, looking absolutely devastated. He asks you to find his wife’s belongings. He calls her Leah. He tells you she was a puppet, which, in the world of Krat, is a scandalous, almost unthinkable confession. Humans and puppets don't marry. Or do they?
The quest is mechanically simple but narratively heavy. You go down into the sewers, fight through some garbage, and find a puppet corpse dressed in a beautiful wedding gown. That’s Leah. Or what’s left of her. Beside her is a ring.
The Choice That Defines Your Playthrough
When you return the ring to Julian, he asks you a question that defines your humanity score. He asks if you believe Leah loved him. Now, you’ve seen the corpse. It’s wires and porcelain. But you’ve also felt the "Ergo" throughout the game—the soul-like essence that powers these machines.
🔗 Read more: Jigsaw Would Like Play Game: Why We’re Still Obsessed With Digital Puzzles
- If you tell him the truth (that puppets can't love), you stay "robotic."
- If you lie and say she loved him, you gain humanity.
This is where Lies of P Leah becomes more than just a footnote. If you choose to lie, Julian gives you a wedding ring and a gesture. But more importantly, you start to see the cracks in the Grand Covenant. If a puppet like Leah can "love" enough to stay by her husband's side until the end, what does that say about Geppetto’s creations? It’s a tiny story, sure. But it carries the weight of the entire game’s philosophy.
Why Rosa Isabelle Street Makes This Quest Work
The setting is everything here. Rosa Isabelle Street was once the pinnacle of Krat’s culture—theaters, high fashion, romance. Now it’s a graveyard. Finding a "marriage" between a human and a puppet in the middle of this ruin feels like finding a flower growing in a nuclear crater.
The developers at Neowiz didn't just throw this in for flavor. They used Leah to mirror the tragedy of the King of Puppets. Everything in this district is about the performance of being human. Leah wasn't performing. Or maybe she was? That's the beauty of it. You never actually talk to her. You only see the aftermath of her existence. You see the "Wedding Ring" item description, which talks about a bond that transcends the law of the city.
Some players miss the "Leah" connection entirely because she’s never named in a dialogue box above a head. She’s a memory. She’s a prompt. She’s a reason to feel bad for a guy standing in a sewer.
💡 You might also like: Siegfried Persona 3 Reload: Why This Strength Persona Still Trivializes the Game
Breaking Down the Humanity Mechanics
Lies of P uses these small encounters to track your "Humanity." It’s not just a hidden stat; it changes your physical appearance. Your hair grows. Your heart beats louder. By engaging with the Lies of P Leah quest and choosing the empathetic path, you’re essentially choosing to believe in the impossible.
- Talk to Julian at the Culvert.
- Find the lady in white near the street's end.
- Retrieve the "Wedding Ring."
- Lie to Julian.
It’s a four-step process that most people finish in ten minutes. But the implications? They last until the credits roll.
The Tragic Reality of Puppet Relationships
In the lore, puppets are bound by the Grand Covenant. They cannot lie. They must obey. But the Covenant says nothing about love. This is the loophole Leah exists in.
Was she malfunctioning? The Puppet Frenzy turned most puppets into mindless killers. Yet, here is Leah, who seemingly stayed "loyal" to Julian. This suggests that Ergo—the crystallized life energy—retains memories of the people it used to be. If the Ergo inside Leah was once a woman who loved, it explains why she didn't join the massacre. It makes her death even more tragic because she wasn't just a machine that broke; she was a soul trapped in a metal shell that finally gave out.
📖 Related: The Hunt: Mega Edition - Why This Roblox Event Changed Everything
I’ve seen people argue on Reddit and Discord about whether Julian was just delusional. Some think he was "using" a puppet to cope with loneliness. But if you look at the way the ring is positioned and the specific dialogue Julian uses, it's clear the writers wanted us to see this as a legitimate, albeit strange, romance.
Actionable Insights for Your Playthrough
If you’re currently running through Rosa Isabelle Street, don’t rush past the Culvert. Here is how to handle the Lies of P Leah situation to get the best rewards:
- Check your inventory: Ensure you actually pick up the ring next to the puppet. It’s easy to miss if you’re sprinting away from the flaming projectiles.
- The "Sad" Gesture: You only get this by lying to Julian. You need gestures to interact with certain statues later in the game (like the one in St. Frangelico Cathedral) to boost your Humanity even further.
- Listen to the Music: After completing the quest, go back to Hotel Krat and play a record. The "Humanity" gained from the quest often triggers the "Your springs are reacting" message, which is a key milestone for unlocking the "Rise of P" ending.
Don't treat this as a checklist item. Look at the puppet’s design. Notice the contrast between the white lace and the grime of the city. The game wants you to feel uncomfortable. It wants you to wonder if you’re doing the right thing by lying.
Ultimately, the story of Leah is the story of Krat. It’s a place that tried to manufacture perfection and ended up with a beautiful, heartbreaking mess. Whether she loved him or not doesn't actually matter to the world—but it matters to your version of P. That choice to validate Julian’s grief is one of the most "human" things you can do in the game.
To maximize the impact of this questline, ensure you have talked to Antonia at the Hotel about the history of the street before heading down. It adds a layer of nostalgia to the carnage that makes Leah’s fate feel much more personal. Once you've returned the ring and seen Julian's reaction, take the "Sad" gesture and use it in front of the puppet's body. It doesn't trigger a secret item, but it’s a moment of roleplaying that fits the somber tone of a world where even love is a puppet's lie.