You’re walking through the Estella Opera House. It’s creepy. Spiders made of puppets are hanging from the ceiling, and the music is just unsettling enough to make you want to sprint to the boss. But then you find it. A Bright Red Apple. In a world full of gears, oil, and blood, a piece of fruit feels weirdly out of place. Most players just shove it in their bag and forget about it.
That is a huge mistake.
The Lies of P apple isn't just some health item you accidentally stumbled upon. Honestly, if you eat it, you’ve basically locked yourself out of one of the most poignant side quests in the entire game. Neowiz didn't put it there for your health. They put it there to test if you’re actually paying attention to the tragic ghosts haunting Krat.
Where to Find the Apple and Why You Can’t Eat It
Finding the thing is the easy part. It’s tucked away in a chest in the Estella Opera House. Specifically, you’ll find it near the backstage area before you hit the boss fight with the King of Puppets. It’s bright. It’s red. It looks delicious compared to the metallic rot everywhere else.
But here is the kicker: you only get one.
There is no "Apple Merchant" waiting around the corner to sell you a bushel of these. If you use it from your inventory, it’s gone. You get nothing. No buff, no special animation, just a wasted opportunity. In a game that is essentially a dark retelling of Pinocchio, items often have a symbolic weight that outweighs their literal utility. The apple is the prime example of this design philosophy.
Giving the Lies of P Apple to Adelina
The real reason you want the Lies of P apple is for Adelina the Actress. You’ll find her in a small room in the Opera House, tucked away and looking pretty rough. She’s poisoned. She’s dying. And she’s incredibly thirsty.
📖 Related: Go Go Archipelago Portal: Why Players Are Still Hooked
When you talk to her, she mentions how much she misses the taste of fruit. If you have the apple in your inventory, you get a prompt to give it to her. Do it. Don't hesitate.
Why? Because this is how you progress her story to its natural, albeit depressing, conclusion. After you defeat Romeo (the King of Puppets), return to her room. She’ll be gone—well, passed away—but she leaves behind the "Fascination" record and a small token of gratitude. Records are the lifeblood of the "Humanity" system in this game. If you’re aiming for the "Rise of P" ending, you need those tunes. Skipping the apple means skipping the record, which might mean failing to become "human" enough by the end of the journey.
The Connection Between Humanity and Music
It’s kinda fascinating how Neowiz tied physical objects to the abstract concept of the soul. In Lies of P, listening to records isn't just a vibe. It literally changes your character's internal chemistry. You’ll see a prompt saying "Your springs are reacting" or "You feel warmth."
Giving the Lies of P apple to a dying woman is a selfless act. It doesn't help you in combat. It doesn't give you a new sword. It’s just a kind thing to do in a city that has forgotten what kindness looks like. That’s the core of the game’s "Lie" mechanic. It’s not always about telling a literal falsehood; sometimes, it's about acting with a human heart in a mechanical body.
👉 See also: Last of Us Walkthrough Part 1: How to Survive the Prologue Without Losing Your Mind
A Missed Opportunity for Many
I’ve seen dozens of players reach the end of the game and wonder why they’re missing one specific record. Usually, it’s because they found the apple, didn't see an immediate use for it, and either ignored Adelina or progressed the world state too far.
If you kill the boss before giving her the apple, the questline is basically bricked. She dies anyway, but without the comfort of the fruit, and you don’t get the reward. It’s a harsh lesson in timing that Soulslikes love to teach.
Why the Apple Matters for the Platinum Trophy
If you’re a completionist, the Lies of P apple is a non-negotiable item. You cannot get the "Golden Melody" trophy without the Fascination record.
- Humanity Points: Essential for the best ending.
- World Building: Adds layers to the tragedy of the Opera House.
- Record Collection: Necessary for 100% completion.
It’s also worth noting that the apple stays in your inventory across New Game Plus if you haven't used it, but why wait? The reward is better on your first run when you’re still trying to figure out who P really is.
Comparing the Apple Quest to Other Side Stories
Think about the quest with the woman looking for her "baby" (the puppet). Or the old man at the window. Lies of P constantly asks you to indulge the delusions or final wishes of the dying. The apple quest is the most "physical" version of this. It’s a tangible object you have to carry and surrender.
Most games would just have a dialogue tree. Here, you have to find the item, hold onto it, and resist the urge to see what happens if you click "use" in the menu. (Spoiler: nothing happens, you just lose the item).
Steps to Ensure You Don't Mess This Up
If you are currently playing or planning a run, here is exactly how you handle this. First, get to the Estella Opera House. Don't rush to the boss. Scour the rooms until you find the chest with the red apple. It’s not hidden behind an illusory wall or anything crazy, but it’s easy to run past if you're dodging the fire-breathing puppets.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Google game no internet is basically the most played game you never meant to start
Once you have it, find Adelina. She’s on the ground floor, right-hand side of the main hall area, up a small set of stairs in a side room. Give it to her immediately. Do not wait.
After you finish off the King of Puppets—which, by the way, is one of the hardest fights in the early-to-mid game—walk back to her room. Pick up the record. Put it on the gramophone at Hotel Krat. Sit there. Listen to the whole thing. Your "Humanity" will thank you.
What if you already ate it?
Look, if you already ate the Lies of P apple, you’re out of luck for this playthrough. There is no second apple. You’ll have to wait until New Game Plus to fix that mistake. It’s a bummer, but that’s the nature of the genre. Every choice, even something as small as eating a piece of fruit, has a consequence. In this case, the consequence is a quieter, less human journey.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check your inventory: If you’ve passed the Opera House and still have the apple, go back to Adelina's room. If she's still alive, give it to her.
- Prioritize the Record: If you already have the "Fascination" record, make sure you listen to it at the Hotel until the very end to trigger the Humanity gain.
- Note for NG+: If you missed it, pin a note to your next playthrough's checklist. This is one of the top three easily-missed items for the True Ending.
The world of Krat is unforgiving, and the Lies of P apple is a rare moment of grace. Don't waste it. It represents the difference between being a mindless machine and a puppet who finally learns how to feel.