You know that feeling when you meet an NPC in a Souls-like and your "betrayal senses" start tingling immediately? That's exactly how it goes with the Lies of P Alidoro encounter. He’s standing there in St. Frangelico Cathedral, wearing a ridiculous dog mask and acting like he’s the only refined soul left in a city full of bloodthirsty puppets. He looks like a hero. He talks like a savior. But if you’ve spent more than five minutes in Krat, you already know nobody is actually that nice.
Alidoro is the guy who swaps your hard-earned Boss Ergo for high-tier weapons. That makes him indispensable. You need him. You might even like him for a second because his gear is objectively awesome. But the more you dig into his story, the more you realize he’s basically the human embodiment of a trash fire.
Who Exactly Is the Real Alidoro?
It's a mess. Honestly, the biggest twist isn't even that he’s a jerk—it’s that the man you meet isn't even the real Alidoro.
The "Alidoro" you interact with for 90% of the game is a nameless fraud. He was a lowly assistant, a nobody who followed the real, legendary treasure hunter around. When things went south during the Puppet Frenzy, this "assistant" decided he liked the idea of being famous more than he liked his mentor's life. So, he killed him. He put on the mask, stole the identity, and started parading around as the great Alidoro.
If you find the Cryptic Vessel later in the game and have Venigni decode it, you get the full, ugly picture. The real Alidoro was actually a decent guy who wanted to protect his daughter, Eugénie. The fake one? He’s just a coward who realized that in a dying city, having a famous name is the best way to stay alive.
Most players miss the subtlety here on the first run. You see a guy in a dog mask and think, "Oh, cool, the shopkeeper." You don't realize you're talking to a murderer who is actively lying to your face every time you trade in a piece of Ergo. It's brilliant writing because it mirrors the "Lie" mechanic of the game itself.
📖 Related: FC 26 Web App: How to Master the Market Before the Game Even Launches
The Eugénie Connection and Why It Breaks Your Heart
Eugénie is one of the few genuinely kind people in Hotel Krat. She’s talented, she’s hardworking, and she’s obsessed with the "legendary" Alidoro because she thinks he’s the hero who saved her. Watching her talk about him while you know the truth is physically painful.
The Choice at the End of the Quest
Eventually, the game forces your hand. After the attack on Hotel Krat, you find the fake Alidoro chilling in the Relic of Trismegistus. He’s unrepentant. He’s smug. He basically tells you that he’s been working with the Alchemists and that he doesn't care about the lives he ruined.
Here is where the branching narrative actually matters:
- You Kill Him: Most people do this immediately. He’s annoying, and he deserves it. Plus, you need his Cryptic Vessel to finish Eugénie's quest.
- The Truth vs. The Lie: After reading the decoded vessel, you go back to Eugénie. You can tell her the fake Alidoro was just a talented jerk, or you can tell her the truth—that the fake murdered her real brother (the real Alidoro).
If you tell her the truth, it’s heavy. She realizes her entire life’s inspiration was a lie. But if you lie to her to protect her feelings, you get a different reward. It’s one of those rare moments in Lies of P where the "Humanity" points feel secondary to the actual emotional weight of the conversation.
Why Alidoro Matters for Your Build
Let's pivot to the gameplay because, let’s be real, you aren’t just talking to him for the lore. You want the Seven-Coil Spring Sword or the Holy Sword of the Ark.
👉 See also: Mass Effect Andromeda Gameplay: Why It’s Actually the Best Combat in the Series
Alidoro is the sole gateway to Special Weapons. Without him, those Boss Ergo crystals sitting in your inventory are just glorified paperweights. If you accidentally send him to Venigni Works instead of Hotel Krat early on, don't panic. He’ll survive, but you’ll have to track him down near the Fuoco boss arena. He’s a survivor, if nothing else.
Even after you kill him (and you really should kill him), his shop doesn't disappear. Rookie the Explorer (or sometimes just known as the "New Merchant") takes over his spot at the Hotel. You don't lose access to the boss weapons, which is a relief. It means the game encourages you to enact justice without punishing your character progression.
The Most Misunderstood Part of His Lore
People often think Alidoro was just a random thief. But if you read the item descriptions on the gear he sells, there's a recurring theme of "stolen legacy." The fake Alidoro didn't just steal a name; he tried to steal a destiny.
He represents the dark side of the game’s central theme. If P is a puppet trying to become a human through lies and empathy, Alidoro is a human who became a monster through lies and greed. He’s the perfect foil. While you’re gaining humanity by learning how to love and sacrifice, he’s losing his by being a selfish parasite.
He isn't a "villain" in the sense that Simon Manus is. He's just a small, pathetic man who took advantage of a tragedy. That makes him way more hateable than a giant monster.
✨ Don't miss: Marvel Rivals Emma Frost X Revolution Skin: What Most People Get Wrong
How to Handle the Alidoro Encounter Like a Pro
To get the most out of this storyline and ensure you don't miss the best gear or the "True" ending path, follow these specific steps:
- Talk to him immediately at the St. Frangelico Cathedral Chapel. He's up the elevator near the library.
- Send him to Hotel Krat. Don't be a troll and send him to the factory; it just makes your life harder for no reason.
- Buy the weapons you want early. While his replacement takes over, it's just easier to have him at the Hotel while he's still breathing.
- Don't skip the Cryptic Vessel. After you kill him at the Relic of Trismegistus, take that document to Venigni. Read it. If you don't read it before talking to Eugénie, you lose the chance to get the "Far East Princess" record or the "Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1" record depending on your choices.
- Check your inventory for "Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel." It’s the smoking gun. It proves the guy was a fraud.
Dealing with Lies of P Alidoro is a litmus test for how you play these games. Do you just want the stats, or do you care about the world? Honestly, even if you only care about the stats, his death is mandatory for 100% completion. It’s one of the few times the game gives you a "good" reason to be violent toward an NPC.
Stop holding onto that Boss Ergo. Go find the man in the dog mask, get your weapons, and then wait for the right moment to see what's actually behind that ceramic snout. You won't regret it, even if the truth is a little depressing.
Next time you’re in the Hotel, take a long look at Eugénie. She deserves better than a fake brother, and you’re the only one who can settle that score. Just make sure you’ve upgraded your favorite blade first—he doesn't put up much of a fight, but the emotional payoff is worth the prep.