If you walked into a pub in West Yorkshire or a chippy in L4 and mentioned the 1964 "Battle of Goodison Park," you’d probably get two very different stories. To one side, it was the day "Dirty Leeds" earned their name. To the other, it was the moment the establishment realized Daniel Farke’s ancestors (spiritually speaking) weren't going to be bullied. Fast forward to January 2026, and honestly, the Leeds United vs Everton fixture hasn’t lost a single drop of that acidic intensity. It’s a game that feels like a collision of two tectonic plates—both massive, both historic, and both currently fighting like hell to prove they still belong at the top table.
Earlier this season, back in August 2025, Elland Road was practically vibrating. It was Leeds’ big return to the Premier League, and they managed to grind out a 1-0 win thanks to a Lukas Nmecha penalty in the 84th minute. James Tarkowski was fuming about that handball call for weeks. Can you blame him? It was one of those "natural position" debates that keeps VAR officials awake at night. But that’s just how this fixture goes. It's never simple. It’s always a bit messy.
The Grudge Match: Leeds United vs Everton in 2026
We’re heading into the reverse fixture at the Hill Dickinson Stadium on January 26, and the stakes have shifted. Everton is sitting comfortably-ish in 12th, while Leeds is hovering around 16th, desperately trying to keep their heads above the relegation swamp. If you look at the stats, it's a toss-up. Everton has actually struggled at home recently, dropping a weird 4-2 game to Brentford not too long ago. Meanwhile, Leeds has been the "draw kings" of the winter, picking up points against Manchester United and Liverpool but failing to actually kill games off.
People forget how deep this goes. We're talking over 100 years of history. Leeds won the very first meeting 1-0 in 1924, and they still hold a slight edge in the overall head-to-head record (54 wins to Everton’s 36). But those numbers don't tell you about the noise. Or the tackles.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
Why the "Dirty Leeds" Tag Still Lingers
Let’s talk about that 1964 game for a second because it’s the DNA of this rivalry. The referee actually ordered both teams off the pitch for five minutes just to let the fans and players cool down. Think about that. In a modern era where players get a yellow card for waving an imaginary card, a total "cool-off" period seems like something from a different planet.
- The Catalyst: Johnny Giles left stud marks on Sandy Brown’s chest.
- The Reaction: Brown punched him. Red card. Four minutes in.
- The Chaos: Fans started pelting the Leeds keeper, Gary Sprake, with coins.
Everton fans haven't forgotten the "robust" approach of the Revie era, and Leeds fans wear that notoriety like a badge of honor. When these two meet, that old-school friction always bubbles back up. It’s why you’ll see players like Wilfried Gnonto and James Garner getting into each other's faces within the first ten minutes. It's built into the schedule.
Tactical Chess: Farke vs the Toffees
Daniel Farke has Leeds playing a very specific brand of "on-the-ground" football. They want the ball. They want to dominate territory. In the August win, they had 55% possession, which is rare for a newly promoted side against an established Premier League team. But they have a massive weakness: defending through balls. If you watch their recent 4-3 loss to Newcastle, they looked like they were running through sand whenever a winger got behind them.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
Everton, under their current setup, is basically the polar opposite. They love a long ball. They want to cross the living daylights out of the ball and win aerial duels. With players like Beto and Iliman Ndiaye, they have the physical profile to bully a Leeds defense that occasionally forgets how to mark at set pieces.
Key Personnel Absences for January
Injuries are kind of ruining the vibe for the upcoming clash. Everton is missing some heavy hitters.
Jarrad Branthwaite is out, which is a massive blow to their defensive stability.
Michael Keane is suspended.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall is sidelined.
On the Leeds side, they’re missing Daniel James and Jayden Bogle. James’ pace is usually their "get out of jail free" card on the counter-attack, so Farke is going to have to get creative. Maybe we see more of Largie Ramazani or Brenden Aaronson trying to pick locks in the final third.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
There’s this narrative that Everton is the "stable" club and Leeds is the "chaotic" one. Honestly? Looking at the 2025/26 season, it’s the other way around. Leeds has a very consistent starting eleven and a clear tactical identity. You know what you’re getting. Everton has been a bit of a rollercoaster. They can beat Manchester United 1-0 away and then lose 4-1 at home to Newcastle.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
The "Big Club" ego also plays a part. Both fanbases believe they belong in the European conversation. When they face each other, it’s a reality check. It’s a battle of who has fallen further and who is climbing back faster.
Actionable Insights for the Upcoming Game
If you're following the Leeds United vs Everton saga this month, here is what actually matters for the result:
- Watch the First 15 Minutes: Leeds tends to start fast at home but is more cautious away. If Everton doesn't score early, the Hill Dickinson Stadium crowd gets restless, and that’s when Leeds pounces.
- Monitor the Referee: Given the history of cards in this fixture (Tim Iroegbunam and Carlos Alcaraz both saw yellow in the last meeting), expect a high foul count. If the ref is "letting things go," Leeds usually wins the physical battle.
- The Nmecha Factor: Lukas Nmecha has been averaging the most shots on target for Leeds. Everton’s makeshift defense (minus Branthwaite) will struggle to track his movement between the lines.
- Betting on the Draw: Leeds has drawn 7 of their 21 games so far this season. A 1-1 or 0-0 is statistically much more likely than a blowout, regardless of what the "Dirty Leeds" history suggests.
The January 26th kickoff isn't just another Monday night game. It's a survival pivot. For Everton, a win puts them in the top half and kills any lingering relegation whispers. For Leeds, it’s about proving that the August win wasn't a fluke and that they can actually survive the Premier League meat grinder. Grab a drink, keep an eye on the VAR monitor, and expect a few flying tackles. That's just Leeds and Everton for you.
Next Steps for Fans:
Check the official injury reports 24 hours before kickoff, as Jarrad Branthwaite’s potential late fitness test could completely change the defensive dynamic for the Toffees. If you're attending the game, allow extra time for the increased security presence that usually accompanies this high-voltage Northern rivalry.