You've probably heard the term "dynasty" thrown around a lot lately. In football, that word usually gets reserved for the guys wearing red and gold in Missouri. But if you look at the last three Super Bowl winners, the story isn't just about one team dominating. It’s actually a wild narrative of a "three-peat" that vanished in the New Orleans humidity and a backup-turned-hero who finally got his revenge.
Honestly, the NFL is just different now. We saw the Kansas City Chiefs claw through overtime in Vegas and edge out a thriller in the desert, only to hit a brick wall in 2025. People keep talking about Patrick Mahomes as the undisputed GOAT, but the history books from the last three years tell a much more complicated story. It’s a story about "Corn Dog" plays, controversial holding calls, and Jalen Hurts finally silencing every single critic he ever had.
The Night the Three-Peat Died: Super Bowl LIX
Everyone expected the history books to be rewritten on February 9, 2025. The Chiefs were on the verge of the first-ever three-peat in the Super Bowl era. Instead, the Philadelphia Eagles didn't just win; they dismantled them.
The score was a lopsided 40-22.
Jalen Hurts was basically a machine that night in New Orleans. He threw for two touchdowns and ran for another, tallying 221 yards in the air and 72 on the ground. It was total vindication. Remember how much heat Nick Sirianni took all season for "lack of cohesion"? Well, none of that mattered when the confetti started falling.
The Eagles defense was the real story, though. They sacked Mahomes six times. Six. They forced three turnovers, including a Cooper DeJean pick-six that made the Superdome shake. By the time the fourth quarter rolled around, it wasn't a game anymore. It was a statement. The last three Super Bowl winners list finally had a new name at the top, and it wasn't the one everyone predicted.
🔗 Read more: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
That Wild Overtime in Vegas: Super Bowl LVIII
If 2025 was a blowout, 2024 was a heart-stopper. Super Bowl LVIII at Allegiant Stadium was only the second overtime game in the history of the big dance. The Chiefs beat the San Francisco 49ers 25-22, and it felt like destiny.
Kyle Shanahan is a genius, but he just can't seem to close the door on Mahomes. The 49ers actually led 10-3 at halftime. They had the Chiefs on the ropes. But Kansas City has this weird ability to just... not die.
The "Tom and Jerry" Play
With seconds left in overtime, Mahomes found Mecole Hardman for a 3-yard touchdown. They called the play "Tom and Jerry." It was a classic Andy Reid design—misdirection that left Hardman wide open in the flat. Hardman actually admitted later he didn't even realize the game was over when he caught it. He was just running.
- Final Score: Chiefs 25, 49ers 22
- MVP: Patrick Mahomes (333 yards, 2 TDs)
- The Vibe: Pure heartbreak for Brock Purdy and a coronation for the KC dynasty.
People argue about the overtime rules constantly. The 49ers took the ball first and settled for a field goal. In the new format, the Chiefs knew exactly what they needed. They used every inch of that knowledge to march 75 yards down the field.
The Desert Duel and the Holding Call: Super Bowl LVII
To understand the context of the last three Super Bowl winners, you have to go back to February 12, 2023. This was the first time the Chiefs and Eagles met on the biggest stage, and it was a masterpiece of offensive football. 38-35.
💡 You might also like: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
Jalen Hurts actually played better than Mahomes that day, statistically speaking. He put up four touchdowns. But the game turned on two things: a Kadarius Toney punt return that felt like it lasted twenty minutes and a defensive holding call on James Bradberry.
"It was a holding. I pulled his jersey. I was hoping they would let it slide." — James Bradberry
A lot of fans were furious. They wanted to see the Eagles get one last shot at a game-tying drive. Instead, Harrison Butker chipped in a 27-yard field goal with eight seconds left, and that was that. It was the night the "Corn Dog" play became famous—the same shovel-pass/motion look that the Chiefs used to score twice in the second half.
Why These Three Games Changed Everything
We aren't just looking at scores here. We’re looking at a shift in how the game is played. The Tush Push became a national debate during this stretch. The "Elite QB" tier narrowed down to basically Mahomes and Hurts.
The last three Super Bowl winners represent the peak of the modern NFL's offensive explosion. In Super Bowl LVII, we saw 73 total points. In LIX, the Eagles hung 40 on a legendary defense.
📖 Related: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
What You Can Learn from the Tape
If you're looking to understand the game at a deeper level, pay attention to the red zone. The Chiefs won two of these three titles because of "eye candy"—motion and misdirection that confuses linebackers. The Eagles won their most recent title by abandoning the fancy stuff and just punching the Chiefs in the mouth with a physical pass rush.
Actionable Insights for the Season Ahead:
- Watch the Trenches: The last three years proved that even an elite QB like Mahomes can’t win if he’s sacked six times. Success starts with the O-line.
- Clock Management is King: Both the 2023 and 2024 games were decided by who had the ball last or how they managed the final two minutes.
- The "Three-Peat" Curse: History shows it is nearly impossible to stay at the top for three straight years. Fatigue, both physical and mental, is a real factor.
Looking back, the era of the last three Super Bowl winners will be remembered as the time the Eagles and Chiefs engaged in a high-stakes chess match across the country. One team won the battle of longevity, but the other got the final word in New Orleans.
Check the injury reports for the upcoming training camps and keep an eye on the salary cap. The Eagles are currently sitting on a young core that looks ready to start a run of their own, while the Chiefs have some aging veterans and big contracts to navigate before they can get back to the Superdome or wherever the next trophy is waiting.