Augusta National is a place where time usually feels like it has stopped, but on that Sunday in April 2025, every second felt like a heavy weight. If you follow golf even casually, you know the stakes. Rory McIlroy, a decade deep into a major championship drought, was staring down the one trophy that has eluded him. The career Grand Slam. It was right there.
Then came the tie. The 72nd hole didn’t settle it. Instead, we got the last playoff at the Masters, a sudden-death showdown that pitted McIlroy against a rejuvenated Justin Rose.
Honestly, the atmosphere was suffocating. You could hear a pin drop on the 18th fairway. It wasn't just about a green jacket; it was about whether the most talented player of his generation would finally break the curse or if Rose, the 2017 playoff loser, would find redemption.
What Happened During the 2025 Masters Playoff?
Most people thought Rory had it in the bag during regulation. He was up, then he wasn't. Golf is cruel like that. When he and Rose both finished at 11-under par, the tournament moved to the aggregate-defying sudden-death format.
They started at the 18th. This is the standard procedure at Augusta. If you're tied after 72 holes, you go back to the 18th tee. If that doesn't fix it, you go to the 10th. They keep looping 18 and 10 until someone blinks.
Rose looked calm. He’d been here before in 2017 against Sergio Garcia. McIlroy, meanwhile, looked like a man trying to outrun his own shadow. But something shifted when they stepped onto that 18th tee for the second time that hour.
Rory hammered a drive. It was long—pure Rory. Rose, who had played beautifully all day, found the right side of the fairway but left himself a trickier angle. The real magic, though, was McIlroy's approach shot. He stuck an iron to about five feet. The crowd didn't just cheer; they roared in a way that felt like a collective release of ten years of frustration.
The Winning Moment
Rose couldn't convert his birdie look. He missed, leaving the stage entirely to the Northern Irishman. When McIlroy sunk that putt, he didn't do the wild celebrations we see from younger players. He just sort of slumped his shoulders, hugged his caddie Harry Diamond, and cried.
🔗 Read more: Why Cool Fantasy Football Names Are Actually Your Secret Winning Strategy
It was the first Masters playoff since 2017. For eight years, we hadn't seen extra holes at Augusta. The drought ended with the biggest story in the sport.
Why Masters Playoffs are Different (and Rare)
You might wonder why we don't see more of these. Augusta National is designed for drama, but the course usually identifies a clear winner in the final four holes. The "Amen Corner" stretch (11, 12, and 13) usually acts as a filter.
When a tie does happen, the rules are specific. Since 1976, the Masters has used the sudden-death format. Before that? It was a full 18-hole Monday playoff. Imagine the nerves of having to sleep on a tie and play a whole new round. No thanks.
Here is how the modern playoff works:
- The Holes: They play the 18th (Holly) and the 10th (Camellia).
- The Order: It’s a loop. 18, then 10, then back to 18.
- The Selection: These holes are chosen because they are close to the clubhouse. It’s basically for the fans and the TV cameras.
Prior to 2025, the last playoff at the Masters happened in 2017. That was the year Sergio Garcia finally got the monkey off his back. He beat Justin Rose on the first playoff hole. It's kind of wild that Rose has been the "bridesmaid" in the last two Masters playoffs. The guy is a legend, but the extra holes at Augusta haven't been kind to him.
Comparing Recent Sudden-Death Dramas
If you look back at the history, these playoffs produce the most iconic shots in golf history. Think about 2012. Bubba Watson.
Bubba was in a playoff with Louis Oosthuizen. He hooked a wedge from the deep pine straw on the 10th hole—a shot that literally curved at a right angle—to land on the green. It shouldn't have been physically possible. But that's the thing about a Masters playoff; the pressure makes players do impossible things.
Then you have 2013. Adam Scott vs. Angel Cabrera. It was pouring rain. Scott birdied the second playoff hole (the 10th) in near-darkness to become the first Australian to wear the green jacket.
The 2025 playoff felt more like the 2017 one. It was a battle of attrition. It wasn't about a "miracle shot" like Bubba’s; it was about who could keep their heart rate under 100 BPM while the entire world watched.
Addressing the "Monday Playoff" Myth
Some older fans still talk about the 18-hole playoffs. They aren't coming back. The last one was in 1970 when Billy Casper beat Gene Littler.
The Masters committee realized that sudden death is just better television. It’s instant gratification. Also, from a logistics standpoint, trying to keep the patrons and security on-site for an extra day is a nightmare.
Sudden death starts immediately after the final group finishes. No warm-up. No resetting. You just go back to the tee. That's why we see so many tired swings in these moments.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you’re watching the Masters and it looks like a playoff is looming, keep these things in mind:
- Watch the 10th Hole: If the playoff goes past the 18th, the 10th is a brutal par-4 that plays downhill. It’s one of the hardest holes on the course. Usually, a par wins it there.
- Experience Matters... Sort Of: Justin Rose had playoff experience, but he lost both times. Sometimes the "hunger" of a first-time winner (like Rory or Sergio) overrides the tactical advantage of having been there before.
- The Tee Shot on 18: The 18th tee shot is a narrow chute. If a player misses the fairway here in a playoff, they are almost certainly looking at a bogey. At this level, that's a death sentence.
- The "Honorary Starter" Vibe: Notice how the atmosphere changes. In regulation, the gallery is spread across 18 holes. In a playoff, 50,000 people are crammed into two corridors. It changes the acoustics and the pressure.
The 2025 finish reminded us why we love this game. Rory McIlroy winning the last playoff at the Masters wasn't just a statistical entry in a record book. It was the closing of a chapter that started in 2011 when he collapsed on the back nine.
Next time you see the leaders tied on the 17th hole on Sunday, don't look away. You're likely about to witness a piece of history that will be replayed for the next fifty years.
📖 Related: Republic of Ireland football squad: What Most People Get Wrong
To truly appreciate the intensity of these finishes, pay close attention to the players' putting routines during the playoff. Notice how much longer they take to read the line compared to the 72nd hole. The margin for error is zero, and the weight of the green jacket makes even a three-footer look like a mile.