Choosing a gym is a massive pain. Honestly, it’s one of those decisions that feels permanent even though it isn't. You walk into a lobby, the smell of industrial cleaner hits you, and some salesperson starts talking about "initiation fees" and "annual club enhancements." It’s exhausting. Most people end up just picking the one closest to their house. But if you’re torn between LA Fitness and 24 Hour Fitness, there are some real, gritty differences in how they operate that go beyond just which one has the shinier treadmills.
Let's be real. Both of these giants have faced massive shifts recently. We’ve seen 24 Hour Fitness emerge from a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing in 2020, which resulted in them shuttering over 100 locations. Meanwhile, LA Fitness has been busy rebranding some of its premium spots to "Esporta Fitness" to compete with high-volume, low-cost gyms like Planet Fitness. It’s a messy landscape.
The Vibe Check: LA Fitness and the Corporate Standard
LA Fitness feels like the "safe" choice for a lot of people. It’s predictable. When you walk into an LA Fitness, you generally know what you're getting: a massive floor of cardio machines, a dedicated free weight area that is almost always crowded on Monday nights, and a pool.
They’ve stuck to a very specific aesthetic. It’s functional. It’s clean-ish. It doesn’t try to be a boutique CrossFit box.
One thing that genuinely sets LA Fitness apart is their consistency with amenities. Most of their locations include a basketball court and a sauna. If you’re a hoop enthusiast, LA Fitness is basically the gold standard for big-box gyms. The pickup games can get intense. You’ll see guys playing like it’s the Game 7 of the NBA Finals at 2 PM on a Tuesday.
Why the Esporta Rebrand Matters
You might have noticed your local LA Fitness suddenly changed its sign to Esporta. This wasn't a change in ownership; it was a tactical pivot. LA Fitness noticed they were losing the "budget" crowd. By rebranding certain locations, they can offer memberships for as low as $9.99 or $25 a month, while keeping the "Signature" LA Fitness clubs at a higher price point. It’s a smart business move, but it’s confusing for the average person just trying to do some bicep curls. If you find an Esporta, you’re basically getting an LA Fitness skeleton at a discount price.
✨ Don't miss: Fruits that are good to lose weight: What you’re actually missing
24 Hour Fitness: The Comeback Kid?
Now, 24 Hour Fitness is a different beast. For a long time, the name was literal. You could go at 3 AM and find a dedicated group of night owls hitting PRs. However, since the pandemic and their subsequent restructuring, the "24 Hour" part isn't always true anymore.
Check your local listings. Many locations now close at midnight or 11 PM. It’s a bit of a letdown if you’re a shift worker.
But here is where 24 Hour Fitness actually wins: the equipment variety. In many locations, they have leaned harder into the "performance" side of fitness. You’re more likely to find Olympic lifting platforms and bumper plates at a 24 Hour Fitness (specifically their Super Sport or Ultra Sport tiers) than at a standard LA Fitness.
Understanding the Tiers
24 Hour Fitness uses a tiered system that can be incredibly annoying to navigate.
- Active: The basic level. Usually older equipment.
- Sport: A step up, usually has more amenities.
- Super Sport: The sweet spot for most. Better machines, newer facilities.
- Ultra Sport: The "fancy" ones. Think day spas and high-end perks.
If you have a "Sport" membership, you can't just walk into a "Super Sport" club. They’ll stop you at the front desk. It’s a tiered access model that feels a bit like airline boarding groups. LA Fitness is generally more straightforward—you either have a single-club membership or a multi-club membership.
🔗 Read more: Resistance Bands Workout: Why Your Gym Memberships Are Feeling Extra Expensive Lately
The Cost of Doing Business
Let's talk money because that's usually the deciding factor.
LA Fitness typically hovers around $35 to $50 per month. They love their initiation fees. You might see a $99 startup fee that magically disappears if you talk to the right manager or sign up during a New Year’s promotion. Their annual fee—usually around $50—is a standard "club enhancement fee." It’s basically a tax for staying a member.
24 Hour Fitness is a bit more volatile with pricing. You can find deals on Costco (historically, though these have become rarer) or through workplace wellness programs. Their monthly rates vary wildly by region. In high-cost areas like San Francisco or New York, you might pay $60+. In smaller markets, it’s closer to $30.
Honestly, the "hidden" costs are what get people. Always ask about the cancellation policy. Both gyms have a reputation for making it slightly difficult to quit. You often have to mail a physical letter or show up in person during "manager hours" which, coincidentally, are only when you’re at work.
Amenities: Pools, Saunas, and Basketball
If you’re a swimmer, LA Fitness is your best bet. Almost every location has a three-lane, 25-yard lap pool. It’s not the Olympics, but it gets the job done. 24 Hour Fitness has pools too, but they are much more hit-or-miss depending on the age of the club.
💡 You might also like: Core Fitness Adjustable Dumbbell Weight Set: Why These Specific Weights Are Still Topping the Charts
- Saunas: Both have them. LA Fitness saunas are usually cedar-lined and dry.
- Childcare: Both offer it (Kids Klub at LA), but it’s an extra monthly add-on. Don't expect it to be included in your base rate.
- Group Classes: Both provide Yoga, HIIT, and Zumba. 24 Hour Fitness has a slight edge here with their "GX24" programming, which tends to feel a bit more modern.
The "Dirty" Secret of Peak Hours
Here is the truth: both gyms are a nightmare between 5:00 PM and 7:30 PM.
It doesn't matter how many squat racks they have. You will be waiting. If you value your time, you have to look at the "crowd meter" on Google Maps before you go. LA Fitness tends to attract a slightly more "corporate" crowd, while 24 Hour Fitness often feels a bit more "hardcore" or "lifter-centric." This isn't a hard rule, but it's a common observation from people who have held memberships at both.
Which One Should You Choose?
It really comes down to your specific "Must-Haves."
Go with LA Fitness if you want a basketball court and a pool as a standard guarantee. It’s also the better choice if you travel within the US frequently, as their footprint is massive and fairly uniform. You won't be surprised by the layout.
Choose 24 Hour Fitness if you are more into powerlifting or functional training. Their "Super Sport" clubs often have better turf areas and racks. Also, if you’re a night owl (and your local one is actually open 24/7), it’s the only game in town.
Actionable Steps for Your Search
Don't just sign up online. That's a rookie move.
- Get a Guest Pass: Both gyms offer 3-day or 7-day passes. Use them. Go at the exact time you plan on working out. If you can’t get a bench at 6 PM on a Monday, you’ll hate your life in three weeks.
- Check the "Last Renovated" Date: Ask the front desk when they last got new plates or treadmills. If it was 2015, the machines will be squeaky and the cables will be frayed.
- Negotiate the Initiation Fee: These are almost always negotiable. Tell them you're considering the gym down the street and watch the "processing fee" vanish.
- Read the Fine Print on Annual Fees: Know exactly which month that $50 extra charge is going to hit your bank account so you aren't surprised.
- Audit the Locker Rooms: This is where you see the real maintenance of a club. If the showers are gross during a tour, they’ll be gross when you’re a member.
In the end, the "best" gym is the one you actually go to. If 24 Hour Fitness is five minutes closer to your house than LA Fitness, choose 24 Hour Fitness. The friction of a long commute kills more fitness goals than a lack of specialized equipment ever will.