You’re driving through Springboro, Ohio, past the typical suburban sprawl, and then you see it. That massive sign. It’s been there since 1975, a literal beacon for anyone who prefers their Broadway hits served alongside a side of signature sweet potato soufflé. Honestly, La Comedia Dinner Theatre is one of those places that shouldn't work in the age of Netflix and TikTok, yet it does. It thrives. It’s one of the largest professional dinner theaters in the entire country, and if you think it’s just for the retirement home crowd, you’re missing out on some of the tightest production values in the Midwest.
People come for the "Taste of Broadway." That’s the slogan. But really, they come for the ritual. There is something fundamentally human about sitting at a shared table, eating a heavy buffet meal, and then watching a live orchestra (or high-quality tracks, depending on the show) kick into gear while actors who actually have Equity-level talent belt out Sondheim or Rodgers and Hammerstein. It’s nostalgic, sure. But it’s also remarkably consistent.
The Buffet is Basically a Character Itself
Let’s talk about the food. You can’t mention La Comedia Dinner Theatre without talking about the buffet. It’s not a fancy, "deconstructed" small-plate situation. It’s a spread. We’re talking fried chicken that has a local cult following and that famous sweet potato soufflé that people try to recreate in their own kitchens every Thanksgiving. Most folks don't realize that the buffet transitions based on the show's theme, though the staples stay put because, frankly, there would be a riot if the chicken disappeared.
The logistics are wild. Imagine feeding hundreds of people in a synchronized window before a curtain rises. The kitchen staff are the unsung heroes here. They manage a rotating menu that often features "flavor of the month" items tied to whatever is on stage. If it’s Fiddler on the Roof, expect some nods to that; if it's a tropical-themed musical, the salad bar might get a bit more adventurous.
Most first-timers are surprised by the efficiency. You aren't lingering for hours waiting for a check. You eat, the tables are cleared with surgical precision, and suddenly the lights dim. It’s a well-oiled machine that has been refined over five decades.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Why the Talent Level is Higher Than You Think
There’s a common misconception that regional dinner theater is where careers go to graze. That’s just wrong. La Comedia actually holds auditions in New York City. They bring in performers who are trying to build their reels or veteran actors who just want a steady gig in a place where the cost of living doesn't eat their entire paycheck. You’re often watching people who have performed on national tours or have legitimate Broadway credits.
The Production Grind
- The stage is a "thrust" style, meaning the audience is on three sides.
- Performers have to be "on" 360 degrees.
- The tech booth is tucked away, but the sound quality in that room is surprisingly crisp for a space filled with upholstered chairs and carpet.
Because the theater is a producer-led house, they have their own costume shop and scene shop. They aren't just unboxing a pre-packaged show. They build the world. When you see a show like Phantom or Mary Poppins at La Comedia, the flying effects and the set pieces are engineered specifically for that Springboro stage. It’s a massive investment of labor that most people take for granted while they’re finishing their dessert.
The Business of Keeping the Lights On
It hasn't always been easy. The dinner theater industry took a massive hit in the 90s and early 2000s. Many of the great houses across the United States folded. La Comedia survived because they stayed family-owned and fiercely local. The Adkins family has kept the wheels turning, navigating the lean years by leaning into the "event" status of the venue.
It’s a destination. People bus in from Indiana, Kentucky, and all over Ohio. If you look at the parking lot on a matinee Wednesday, it’s a sea of motorcoaches. That’s a specific kind of business model that requires intense coordination with tour operators. But they’ve also successfully started courting younger families with their "Children’s Theatre" series. It’s a smart play. Get the kids in for Seussical or The Little Mermaid, and you’ve potentially secured a subscriber for the next thirty years.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
What Most People Get Wrong About the Experience
You might think it’s formal. It’s not. While you’ll see some people in their Sunday best, you’ll see just as many in nice jeans and a sweater. It’s approachable.
Another myth? That the "dinner" part distracts from the "theater" part. In reality, the two are strictly separated. You aren't clinking silverware while someone is singing a ballad. The service stops, the lights go down, and the focus is 100% on the stage. It’s a mark of respect for the craft that many modern "movie-and-a-meal" theaters haven't quite mastered.
Choosing the Right Seat
If you're planning a trip, seat selection matters. Because of the thrust stage, the "sides" offer a very different perspective than the center.
- Center Sections: Best for seeing the full choreography and lighting design.
- Side Wings: Great for seeing the actors' expressions up close, but you might occasionally see the "back" of a formation.
- The "Pit": Being right up against the stage is an experience, but be prepared—you’re very much in the line of sight for any fourth-wall-breaking moments.
Looking Ahead: The 2025-2026 Season and Beyond
The theater continues to mix safe bets with occasional risks. You’ll always see the heavy hitters—The Sound of Music, Guys and Dolls, Grease. They know what pays the bills. However, they’ve started sprinkling in more contemporary hits and jukebox musicals that appeal to the Gen X and Boomer crossover.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The technical demands are increasing too. As audiences get used to high-def everything, La Comedia has had to upgrade their lighting rigs and digital soundscapes. It’s a constant arms race to stay "professional" in the eyes of an audience that can see a Broadway-caliber show on their phone. But you can't smell the fried chicken through a screen. You can't feel the floor vibrate when the ensemble does a synchronized tap routine.
Making the Most of Your Visit
If you’re heading to La Comedia, show up early. The gift shop is a time capsule of theater memorabilia and local crafts that is worth a ten-minute wander. Also, check the menu ahead of time online; they usually post the seasonal specials so you can plan your buffet strategy.
Pro Tip: Don't skip the salad bar just because you want to save room for the mains. Their house dressings are legitimately good. And yes, take the loaf of bread they offer. You’ll want it.
Actionable Steps for Your Trip:
- Book Early: For popular holiday shows or big-name musicals, they sell out months in advance. Weekend evenings are the hardest tickets to get.
- Group Rates: If you have more than 15 people, call the box office directly. The discounts are substantial and they’re great at seating groups together.
- Check the Age Limit: While they love kids, most mainstage shows aren't recommended for children under six. The Children’s Theatre productions are the better bet for the toddlers.
- Dietary Restrictions: If you’re gluten-free or vegan, tell the server immediately. The buffet is heavy on dairy and gluten, but the kitchen can usually whip up a specific plate if they have a heads-up.
La Comedia is a survivor. It’s a slice of Americana that feels both dated and timeless at the same time. Whether you’re there for the kitsch, the chicken, or the high-note belt in the second act, it remains a pillar of the Ohio arts scene for a reason.