Kyle Schwarber just keeps hitting. Honestly, if you’d told a Cubs fan back in 2015 that the stocky kid behind the plate would eventually become the leadoff-hitting, 50-homer-smashing face of the Phillies in 2026, they’d have probably laughed at you. But here we are.
His 2025 season was a monster. He didn't just play well; he redefined what a power hitter looks like in the modern era. He hit 56 home runs. He drove in 132 runs. Most importantly for collectors, he became the 21st player in MLB history to hit four home runs in a single game on August 28, 2025. That one night sent the Kyle Schwarber baseball card market into a frenzy that hasn't really settled down since.
Prices are weird right now. They're up, but there is still some value if you know where to look.
The First Bowman Problem: Why 2014 is Everything
If you're serious about this, you've gotta start with the 2014 Bowman Draft. This is his "1st Bowman" card. It’s the one where he’s still wearing the Chicago Cubs catcher's gear—a look that feels like a total fever dream today.
Basically, the 2014 Bowman Chrome Draft #CDP2 is the gold standard.
A PSA 10 of the base Chrome version used to be a $20 card. Not anymore. After that 50-homer campaign in 2025, you’re looking at $40 to $55 for a Gem Mint slab. If you want the autograph version (#BCA-KS), get ready to open your wallet. The Blue Refractors numbered to /150 are regularly clearing $2,500 in high grades.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
What to watch for:
- The 2014 Bowman Silver Ice: This is a sleeper. It’s not an auto, but it looks incredible. PGI 10s have been spotted for over $1,000, but raw copies still pop up at shows for way less because people confuse them with base parallels.
- The Dual Autos: There’s a 2014 Bowman Draft Dual Autograph with Jake Stinnett. It’s a bit of a "forgotten" card because Stinnett didn't have the same career arc, but for a Schwarber completionist, it's a steal at around $100-$125.
2016: The Official Rookie Year Madness
The "RC" logo matters to a lot of people. While the 2014 cards are his first professional appearances, 2016 is when Topps officially labeled him a rookie.
The 2016 Topps Chrome #166 is the big one here.
Interestingly, there are a few variations. The vertical refractor is actually quite rare in high grades. There are only about 90-some PSA 10s of that specific card in existence. Compare that to the thousands of copies you see for players like Shohei Ohtani or Aaron Judge, and you start to see why the scarcity is driving the price toward the $100 mark.
Then you have the 2016 Topps Now cards. These were printed to order back in the day. Card #631-A, which commemorates his legendary return in the 2016 World Series, is an all-time classic. If you find one in a CGC 9 or higher, it’s a $200 bill easily.
He didn't just play in that World Series; he was the heartbeat of it.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
The "Schwarbomb" Era: 2025 and 2026 Highlights
Last year's cards are already becoming iconic because of the stats he put up. The 2025 Topps Chrome Power Players Green Refractor /99 is a fan favorite in Philly. They've been selling for about $20 ungraded, but the PSA 10s are hitting $115.
It's sorta funny because collectors used to ignore "veteran" cards. But when a guy is hitting 50+ homers a year and chasing 500 career home runs, the rules change.
Recent Sales Data (Early 2026 Trends)
| Card Type | Estimated Grade | Recent Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2014 Bowman Chrome #CDP2 | PSA 10 | $194.50 |
| 2025 Topps #141 Base | PSA 10 | $35.44 |
| 2025 Topps Heritage Gold Chrome /50 | Ungraded | $14.88 |
| 2016 Topps Now World Series Auto /199 | BGS 9.5 | $2,827.99 |
The 2025 Topps Diamond Icons are the "luxury" play. If you've got the cash, the /10 Silver PolychromatINK autos are stunning, but they rarely hit the open market. Usually, they trade in private Facebook groups or at high-end auctions.
Is he a Hall of Famer?
That’s the $10,000 question. Honestly, it depends on how long his back holds up.
He’s 33 years old as of March 2026. He’s sitting at 340 career home runs. If he hits 30 homers a year for the next five years—which, let's be real, he can do in his sleep if he stays healthy—he hits 490. If he pushes to 500, his cards will go nuclear.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
500 home runs used to be an automatic ticket to Cooperstown. It's not a guarantee anymore, but for a guy with a World Series ring and the "big game" reputation Schwarber has? It’s a strong case.
What you should do now
Don't go chasing the 1/1 Superfractors unless you have a trust fund. It's too risky.
Instead, look for the 2016 Bowman Chrome #31. It’s a sleeper card. The PSA 10 population is incredibly low (around 41 copies total), and you can still find them for under $40 if you're patient.
Also, keep an eye on the 2025 Topps Now "Road to Opening Day" cards. The BGS 10s are starting to surface, and they represent the start of his most dominant season yet.
Grab a few raw copies of the 2014 1st Bowman. Spend the $20 to get them graded if they look sharp. Center them up, check the corners, and hope for a 10. That's the smartest way to play the Schwarber market without getting burned by the hype.
Check the "completed sales" on eBay every Tuesday. For some reason, that’s when the best deals on Philadelphia Phillies parallels seem to close. Don't ask me why; it's just the way the algorithm seems to shake out lately.