When the Atlanta Falcons turned in the card for Kyle Pitts at number four overall in 2021, they weren't just drafting a tight end. They were drafting a "Unicorn." At least, that was the label. He was 6'6", ran a 4.49, and had wingspan measurements that made scouts look twice. Fast forward to the start of 2026, and the conversation around him has shifted from "the next Tony Gonzalez" to one of the most polarizing statistical resumes in modern football.
People love to call him a bust. Honestly, it’s a bit lazy. If you actually look at the Kyle Pitts career stats, the story isn't about a lack of talent; it’s about a bizarre cocktail of coaching changes, bad luck with injuries, and some of the most inconsistent quarterback play in the league.
🔗 Read more: Calendario Chivas 2025: Cuándo Juegan, Dónde Verlos y Lo Que Nadie Te Dice del Rebaño
The Rookie Peak and the "Sophomore Slump"
Let's look at the numbers. They don't lie, but they do require context. Pitts hit the ground running in 2021, racking up 1,026 yards. He joined Mike Ditka as the only rookie tight ends to ever cross that 1,000-yard threshold. That’s elite company. Period.
Then 2022 happened.
The drop-off was staggering. He went from a thousand yards to just 356 in ten games before an MCL surgery ended his year. Fans were screaming. Fantasy managers were throwing remote controls. But if you watch the film from that year, Marcus Mariota was routinely sailing balls three feet over his head. You can't catch what you can't touch.
Breaking Down the Yearly Production
To see the trajectory, you have to look at the raw output across his first five seasons.
- 2021: 68 receptions, 1,026 yards, 1 TD. (The "Is he a WR?" year)
- 2022: 28 receptions, 356 yards, 2 TDs. (The injury-shortened mess)
- 2023: 53 receptions, 667 yards, 3 TDs. (The "Arthur Smith decoy" era)
- 2024: 47 receptions, 602 yards, 4 TDs. (Finding some rhythm)
- 2025: 88 receptions, 928 yards, 5 TDs. (The contract year explosion)
By the end of the 2025 season, Pitts had hauled in 284 career receptions for 3,579 yards. That averages out to about 12.6 yards per catch. For a tight end, that's a massive number. It’s higher than most possession receivers.
💡 You might also like: Montana Football Schedule 2025: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the Touchdown Numbers Feel "Off"
The biggest gripe fans have involves the end zone. Or the lack of it.
Pitts has 15 career touchdowns through five seasons. For comparison, some elite tight ends catch 10 in a single year. This "TD drought" became a meme in NFL circles. However, in 2025, we finally saw the Falcons treat him like a red-zone weapon rather than a glorified clear-out runner. He snagged five scores that year alone, including a monstrous three-TD game against Tampa Bay in Week 15.
It’s easy to blame the player, but the Falcons' offensive red-zone efficiency during the Arthur Smith years was... well, it was something. They often used Pitts as a decoy to open up lanes for the run game. Great for the team's record (sometimes), terrible for his highlight reel.
The 2025 Resurgence: A New Kyle Pitts?
Going into the 2025 season, there was a lot of "prove it" energy. He was entering his fifth-year option and needed to show he was still that guy from 2021. And honestly? He mostly did.
His 88 catches in 2025 were a career-high. He wasn't just catching deep balls anymore; he was working the middle of the field, getting those "dirty" yards that he used to shy away from. His catch rate jumped to 74.5%, a huge leap from the sub-50% nightmare of 2022.
The targets were there. 118 of them, to be exact. When a team gives a guy 118 targets, they trust him. The chemistry with Kirk Cousins—and later the transition in the offense—finally allowed the Kyle Pitts career stats to reflect the athleticism we saw at Florida.
Impact and Efficiency Metrics
Advanced stats paint an even more interesting picture. According to PFF, Pitts has consistently ranked near the top of the league in "Average Depth of Target" (ADOT) for his position.
Basically, he’s running routes that wide receivers run. Most tight ends live 5-7 yards past the line of scrimmage. Pitts lives 10-12 yards out. This means his catches are harder, the windows are tighter, and the impact on the defense is much higher because he stretches the secondary.
What Really Matters Moving Forward
Looking at where he stands now, Pitts is only 25 years old. That’s the crazy part. Most tight ends don't even hit their prime until 26 or 27. He’s already got nearly 3,600 yards in the bank.
If he stays healthy—and that's a big "if" given the hamstring and knee issues that have popped up—he's on pace to shatter almost every Falcons franchise record for the position. He's already only the second Falcons tight end to lead the team in receiving yards for multiple seasons.
📖 Related: Sunday Night Football Game Stats: What Really Happened with the Patriots and Chargers
The market for him as he enters free agency in 2026 is going to be fascinating. Does a team pay him like a top-tier WR, or do they look at the 15 career TDs and hesitate?
To get a real sense of his value, keep an eye on these specific indicators:
- Target Share: If he stays above 22%, he's a focal point.
- Red Zone Usage: Watch if he's being targeted inside the 10-yard line, not just used as a blocker.
- Yards After Catch (YAC): In 2025, he had 400 YAC. If that stays high, it means his explosiveness is fully back after the surgery.
The narrative that Kyle Pitts hasn't lived up to the hype is partially true if you only look at touchdowns. But if you look at the total yardage and the way he forces defensive coordinators to change their game plan, he's one of the most effective weapons in the league. The stats are finally starting to catch up to the talent.
Check his game logs from the end of last season—specifically that late-December stretch. That's the version of Pitts that justifies a massive contract.