Watching the Knicks and the Cavs go at it lately feels like watching two heavyweight boxers who just really, really dislike each other. It's not just about the points on the board. Honestly, it’s about the fact that both these teams think they own the Eastern Conference's future.
Ever since New York basically bullied Cleveland out of the 2023 playoffs, every single regular-season meeting has carried this weird, tense energy. You can see it in how Donovan Mitchell attacks the rim or how Jalen Brunson manipulates the pick-and-roll.
They aren't just playing basketball. They’re making a point.
The Reality of the Knicks vs Cleveland Cavaliers Rivalry
Most fans look at the Knicks vs Cleveland Cavaliers matchup and see a battle of star guards. Sure, Brunson and Mitchell are the headliners. But if you actually watch the tape from the last few games, specifically that Christmas Day thriller where New York edged it out 126-124, you’ll see the game is won in the "empty" spaces.
Philadelphia recently gave the rest of the league a blueprint on how to mess with the Knicks' defense. They used a Tyrese Maxey and Joel Embiid empty-side pick-and-roll seven times in a row. It was brutal. Cleveland took notes. When you have a guy like Evan Mobley—who is basically a 7-foot pterodactyl with a handle—you can replicate that.
Mobley has been much better lately on face-up opportunities. He’s not just a lob threat anymore. If the Cavs can isolate him against New York's bigs in space, it changes the entire geometry of the floor.
Stats That Actually Matter
Let’s look at the numbers because they tell a story people usually ignore.
- Donovan Mitchell has averaged roughly 26.7 points and 5.8 assists against Brunson over the last couple of seasons. He's efficient, too, rocking a True Shooting percentage of 63%.
- Jalen Brunson, on the other hand, is the engine. He’s putting up about 28.9 points per game in these head-to-heads.
- Evan Mobley is the defensive anchor, averaging nearly 2 blocks and 9 rebounds while shooting over 50% from the field.
The Knicks recently added Karl-Anthony Towns into this mix, which is a total wildcard. Towns is a unicorn. He’s a center who can shoot 40% from deep, which forces Cleveland’s Jarrett Allen or Mobley to leave the paint. That opens up lanes for Brunson to do his mid-range magic. It’s a chess match.
Why the Cavs Have the Edge (Sort Of)
Even though the Knicks won the big playoff series a few years back, the Cavs have actually won five of the last eight regular-season meetings. They match up well. Cleveland has size that most teams simply can't handle.
Darius Garland is the X-factor here. When Garland is "on" and distributing the ball, it takes the pressure off Mitchell. In their April 2025 win, Garland dropped 26 points and 13 assists. That’s a double-double that kills you because it means everyone else is getting easy buckets.
New York's defense is physical. It’s gritty. Tom Thibodeau probably watches defensive rotations in his sleep. But they struggle with elite speed. If the Cavs backcourt of Mitchell and Garland gets into the paint at will, the Knicks' help defense has to rotate, leaving shooters like Max Strus open on the perimeter.
The Towns vs Mobley Factor
Watching Karl-Anthony Towns go up against Evan Mobley is a fascinating study in modern basketball. Towns is stronger. He’s got that veteran "old man" game mixed with elite shooting. Mobley is the future. He’s faster, more agile, and his defensive recovery is insane.
In a recent January matchup, Towns put up 20 points and 11 rebounds, but he struggled with Mobley’s length on the perimeter. Mobley, meanwhile, is starting to hit that three-pointer more consistently. If Mobley becomes a reliable threat from deep, you can't just park a big man in the lane to stop Mitchell.
✨ Don't miss: Why Paris vs Arsenal 2025 Still Bothers Me
It’s a nightmare for defensive coordinators.
What to Watch for in the Next Game
If you're betting on or just watching the next Knicks vs Cleveland Cavaliers game, keep an eye on the transition points.
The Knicks want to slow you down. They want a mud fight. Cleveland wants to run. If the Cavs get 20+ fast-break points, they usually win. If the game slows down and becomes a half-court grind, Brunson usually finds a way to win it for New York in the final three minutes.
Look at the rebounding battle, too. The Knicks pride themselves on offensive rebounding. Josh Hart is a menace on the glass despite being a guard. If Cleveland can't secure the defensive boards, New York will just second-chance-point them to death.
Actionable Strategy for Fans and Analysts
If you're following this rivalry closely, stop just looking at the final score.
- Watch the "Empty Side" P&R: See if Cleveland tries to isolate Mobley or Mitchell on one side of the floor to exploit the Knicks' help rotations.
- Monitor the KAT Shooting: If Karl-Anthony Towns hits two early threes, watch how Jarrett Allen reacts. If he starts cheating out toward the perimeter, the lane is wide open for Brunson.
- The Bench Depth: The Knicks' bench has been a bit thin lately. If the Cavs' second unit can push a lead while Brunson rests, the game is over.
The Knicks vs Cleveland Cavaliers matchup is essentially a preview of the Eastern Conference Finals. These two teams aren't going anywhere. Every game is a learning experience for the playoffs.
To stay ahead of the curve, track the minutes of OG Anunoby. He is the guy tasked with stopping Mitchell. If OG gets into foul trouble early, the Knicks are in massive trouble. Mitchell will feast.
Check the injury reports specifically for bench depth before the next tip-off, as that's where the fatigue usually shows in the fourth quarter.