If you sail into Loch Scresort on a rainy Tuesday, the first thing you notice isn't the jagged peaks of the Rum Cuillin. It’s a red sandstone anomaly sticking out of the trees like a misplaced piece of the British Empire. That’s Kinloch Castle. It sits on the Isle of Rum looking entirely too grand for a place that currently has more deer than permanent human residents. Honestly, it’s a bit of a heartbreaker.
Most people expect a rugged Scottish fortress when they hear "castle." Kinloch isn't that. It’s a monument to the staggering wealth of the Bullough family, specifically Sir George Bullough, who inherited a textile machinery empire and decided that a remote Hebridean island was the perfect spot for a high-tech party pad. Construction finished around 1900. Back then, it was the height of luxury. It had electricity when most of London was still squinting by candlelight. It had a plumbing system that would make a modern contractor weep with envy. Now? It's a massive, expensive headache for NatureScot, the government body that manages the island.
The place is literally rotting.
What’s Actually Inside Kinloch Castle?
Walking through the doors—if you’re lucky enough to get a guided tour these days—is like stepping into a 1901 fever dream. You’ve got the Orchestrelle, this massive, self-playing organ that was basically the Spotify of the Edwardian era. It’s still there. It still works, mostly. The walls are covered in "trophies" from George’s travels, including some truly questionable taxidermy and Japanese art that cost more than most people earned in a lifetime.
The "Kinnish" sandstone used for the exterior was shipped in from Annan in Dumfriesshire. Every single block. Think about the logistics of that for a second. In the late 1890s, they were hauling tons of red rock onto a roadless island in the Inner Hebrides just because the local grey stone wasn't "pretty" enough. That’s the kind of ego we’re dealing with here.
It wasn't just a house. It was a playground.
The dining room still smells faintly of old cigar smoke and dampness. You can almost see the ghosts of the "Rumites," the wealthy friends of the Bulloughs who would spend their summers deer stalking and drinking fine sherry. George even had a heated turtle tank. Yes, a turtle tank. On a windswept island off the west coast of Scotland. It’s ridiculous. It’s also fascinating. But the damp is winning. Dry rot is eating the floorboards, and the roof is a constant battle against the relentless Scottish rain.
📖 Related: Seeing Universal Studios Orlando from Above: What the Maps Don't Tell You
The Problem With Owning an Island Palace
Why doesn't someone just fix it? People ask this all the time. "Just turn it into a luxury hotel!" they say.
It’s not that simple. Not even close.
First, the Isle of Rum is a National Nature Reserve. The whole island is a site of special scientific interest (SSSI). You can't just roll in with a fleet of cement mixers without disturbing the Manx shearwaters or the red deer research projects that have been running since the 1950s. The island’s infrastructure is tiny. The village of Kinloch has maybe 30 or 40 people. There's one shop. One school. The power comes from a small hydro-electric scheme that struggles to keep up with modern demands.
Then there's the cost.
Estimates for a full restoration of Kinloch Castle have floated between £15 million and £20 million for years. That’s just to get it stable. To make it a viable hotel? You’re looking at double that. Investors look at the logistics—the ferry cancellations, the lack of a local workforce, the strict conservation laws—and they run for the hills. Or the Cuillins, in this case.
The Failed Buyouts
There’s been drama. Plenty of it. A few years ago, a millionaire named Jeremy Hosking was in talks to buy the castle through a charitable trust. It looked like a done deal. The community was divided. Some saw it as a lifeline for the island's economy; others feared a return to the days of "landlordism" where a single person dictates the fate of the locals.
👉 See also: How Long Ago Did the Titanic Sink? The Real Timeline of History's Most Famous Shipwreck
The deal eventually collapsed.
The Scottish Government intervened, citing concerns about the long-term viability and the impact on the community. So, the castle sits in limbo. NatureScot spends roughly £50,000 a year just on basic maintenance—patching holes, emptying dehumidifiers, and making sure the roof doesn't fly off in a gale. It’s a holding pattern. They’re basically keeping the building on life support while they figure out if it’s worth saving or if they should let nature take it back.
Is It Even Worth Visiting?
Short answer: Absolutely. Long answer: Only if you don't mind getting your boots muddy.
The Isle of Rum is spectacular. Even if you can’t stay in the castle (the hostel that used to operate in the back wing is long closed), the grounds are haunting. You can hike up to the Bullough Mausoleum at Harris, which is a Greek-style temple sitting on a lonely beach on the other side of the island. It’s surreal. You’re walking through wild, rugged terrain and suddenly—bam—a neoclassical tomb.
- Getting there: You take the CalMac ferry from Mallaig. It’s a stunning two-hour trip.
- The Midge Situation: If you go in July, God help you. The Rum midges are a legendary breed of tiny vampires.
- Wildlife: You will see red deer. They wander through the village like they own the place. You might see golden eagles. You will definitely see seals.
The castle itself is currently closed to the general public for walk-ins due to safety concerns, but you can still admire the sheer madness of its architecture from the perimeter. Seeing that red sandstone against the dark green of the trees and the grey of the mountains is a visual you won't forget. It’s the definition of "faded glory."
The Real Cost of Heritage
We have this habit of wanting to save everything. But Kinloch Castle poses a tough question: should we?
✨ Don't miss: Why the Newport Back Bay Science Center is the Best Kept Secret in Orange County
Is it a vital piece of Scottish history? Or is it a monument to Victorian excess that has no place in a modern, sustainable community? If you talk to the islanders, you’ll get fifty different answers. Some miss the jobs the castle provided. Others love the peace and quiet that came when the tourists stopped flooding the hallways.
The reality is that the Isle of Rum is moving on. The community is working on new housing, sustainable energy, and small-scale tourism that doesn't rely on a crumbling mansion. They are building a future that isn't dictated by the ghost of Sir George Bullough.
Yet, there’s no denying that without that red castle, Rum would feel a little less like Rum. It’s a weird, beautiful, problematic anchor to the past.
How to Help (or Just See It)
If you're genuinely interested in the fate of the building, the Kinloch Castle Friends Association (KCFA) is the group to follow. They’ve been fighting to save the interior and the Orchestrelle for decades. They know the names of every fireplace and the history of every silk wall hanging.
If you just want to experience the island, book a bunk at the Rum Bunkhouse or camp at the Loch Scresort campsites. Bring a waterproof jacket. Bring a camera. Leave the "it'll be a quick trip" attitude at the pier in Mallaig. Rum operates on island time, which is basically "whenever the ferry can get here and the rain stops."
Actionable Steps for the Curious Traveler
- Check the Ferry Schedule Twice: The Small Isles ferry (MV Lochnevis) is weather-dependent. Do not book a non-refundable flight out of Glasgow the same day you’re meant to leave Rum.
- Support Local: Buy your supplies at the island shop. It’s small, but it’s the heartbeat of the community.
- Respect the Deer: It’s a research island. Don’t feed them, and don’t get too close for a selfie. They’re wild animals, not pets.
- Join the KCFA: If you think the castle is worth saving, a small membership fee goes toward advocacy and minor repairs.
- Pack Out Your Trash: There is no "away" on an island. If you bring a plastic bottle, take it back to the mainland with you.
The story of the Isle of Rum and its red sandstone castle isn't over. It’s just in a very long, very damp middle chapter. Whether it becomes a ruin like so many other Highland estates or finds a billionaire savior with a heart of gold remains to be seen. For now, it remains one of the strangest, most evocative places in Scotland. Go see it before the rot wins.