If you were standing under the Twin Spires on May 3, 2025, you probably felt that weird, electric tension in the air. The track was sloppy. Rain had turned the Churchill Downs dirt into a soupy mess, and everyone was looking at the Kentucky Derby 2025 line up trying to figure out which horse actually liked getting mud in its face. Honestly, most of the money was on Journalism. He was the 3-1 favorite, a beast of a colt trained by Michael McCarthy who had basically dismantled the field in the Santa Anita Derby.
But horse racing is never that simple.
The Shocking Reality of the Kentucky Derby 2025 Line Up
People talk about "The Run for the Roses" like it’s a scripted movie. It isn't. By the time the gates opened for the 151st Kentucky Derby, the "official" line up had already been shredded. Two of the biggest names, Rodriguez and Grande, were scratched just days before the race. Rodriguez, Bob Baffert’s big hope for a record-breaking seventh win, was pulled due to a foot bruise.
That scratch changed everything. It allowed a horse named Baeza to sneak in from the also-eligible list.
Who actually made the gate?
When they finally loaded them in, the Kentucky Derby 2025 line up featured 20 runners (well, 19 after the late scratches). Here is how the big players looked at the start:
🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
- Journalism (3-1): The heavy favorite. He had the speed, the pedigree (by Curlin), and Umberto Rispoli in the irons.
- Sovereignty (7-1): Trained by the legendary Bill Mott. He’d finished second in the Florida Derby but looked like he wanted every bit of the 1 1/4 mile distance.
- Sandman (5-1): Mark Casse’s closer. People loved his win in the Arkansas Derby, but skeptics worried about the distance.
- Citizen Bull (13-1): The 2024 Juvenile champ. He had the "Baffert" factor, even if his prep races were a bit shaky.
- Luxor Cafe (8-1): The Japanese raider. After Forever Young nearly won in 2024, everyone was terrified of this horse.
How Sovereignty Stole the Show
The race itself was a chaotic blur of brown mud and neon silks. Citizen Bull took the early lead, which surprised exactly nobody. He set a decent pace, but you could see him starting to labor as they hit the far turn. That's when the "big two" made their move.
Journalism and Sovereignty hooked up at the top of the stretch. It was beautiful, really. Two world-class athletes refusing to give an inch. For a second, it looked like Journalism would pull away. He’s got that massive stride. But Sovereignty, owned by Godolphin, just found another gear in the final furlong.
Junior Alvarado kept him steady. They splashed across the wire 1 1/2 lengths clear.
The winning time? 2:02.31. Not the fastest ever, but on a sloppy track? It was a masterclass in stamina.
💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
The Longshot That Almost Ruined the Exacta
Let’s talk about Baeza. This horse wasn't even supposed to be in the race! He only got in because Rodriguez was scratched. At 13-1 (after some late betting action), he came flying from 15th place to grab third. If the race was 100 yards longer, he might have caught Journalism for second.
It’s a reminder that the bottom of the Kentucky Derby 2025 line up is often where the real value hides. If you played a trifecta with the "big" horses and ignored the also-eligible newcomer, you missed out on a $115 payout on a 50-cent bet.
Why the "Experts" Got Sandman Wrong
A lot of people lost money on Sandman. He went off as the third choice at 5-1. On paper, he was the perfect closer. But track conditions matter. The kickback on a sloppy Churchill track is like getting hit with wet concrete. Sandman hated it. He finished 7th, never really threatening the leaders.
Trainer Mark Casse is still looking for that elusive Derby win. It’s tough. You can have the best horse in the world, but if he doesn't like the surface, you're done before the first turn.
📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
What This Means for the Preakness and Beyond
Sovereignty’s win wasn't a fluke. Bill Mott is a patient trainer; he doesn't rush his horses. By the time Sovereignty hit Louisville, he was peaking.
The Kentucky Derby 2025 line up proved that the Japan Road to the Derby is a legitimate threat now. Luxor Cafe finished 12th, which sounds bad, but he was wide the whole way and hated the mud. Don't sleep on the Japanese horses in 2026. They are coming for the trophy, and they aren't going away.
If you’re looking at these horses for the rest of the Triple Crown or even the Breeders' Cup, keep an eye on Journalism. He lost, sure, but he fought like a tiger. On a fast, dry track? He’s probably the best horse in this crop.
Next Steps for Horse Racing Fans:
- Review the Pedigrees: Look into Sovereignty’s sire, Into Mischief. He’s becoming a dominant force in producing Derby winners (Authentic, Mandaloun, and now Sovereignty).
- Watch the Replay: Pay attention to the "trip" of East Avenue and Owen Almighty. They finished 8th and 5th respectively, but both had trouble at the start. They might be huge value bets in their next starts at shorter distances.
- Check the Health Reports: Keep tabs on Rodriguez. If that foot bruise heals quickly, he’ll be the horse to beat in the Preakness or the Belmont Stakes.