You’ve probably seen the thumbnails. Usually, it's a grainy, sepia-toned image of a family sitting on a porch, but their skin is a jarring, Smurf-like shade of indigo. Maybe you scrolled past thinking it was some creepypasta or a leftover prop from an old sci-fi flick. Honestly, the internet is so full of edited junk that it’s hard to tell what’s actually history and what’s just someone playing with a saturation slider.
But here’s the thing: the blue people were real.
They weren't aliens, and they weren't wearing body paint. They were the Fugates, a family living in the jagged, isolated hills of Troublesome Creek, Kentucky. For over a century, they lived, farmed, and raised kids while carrying a skin tone that looked like it belonged in a comic book.
The Truth About Kentucky Blue People Pictures
If you're looking for authentic kentucky blue people pictures, you’re going to run into a bit of a wall. Most of the "blue" photos floating around social media are modern digital recreations or colorized versions of black-and-white family portraits.
Why? Because for the bulk of the Fugate family's history—spanning from the 1820s through the mid-20th century—color photography was either non-existent or a luxury they didn't have. Most of the real historical photos are standard grayscale. You see the deep, dark tones in their skin that look "off" compared to their neighbors, but you don't see the actual blue.
🔗 Read more: Blue Tabby Maine Coon: What Most People Get Wrong About This Striking Coat
There are, however, a few genuine color photos from the 1960s and 70s. These were taken around the time Dr. Madison Cawein, a hematologist from the University of Kentucky, finally figured out what was going on. One of the most famous images isn't actually a photo at all, but a painting by Walt Spitzmiller that was used to illustrate a 1982 article in Science 82 magazine. People often mistake it for a real photograph because of how hauntingly realistic it is.
The real "visual" evidence usually comes from descriptions by locals and doctors. They described the family as being "bluer’n hell" or having skin the color of a "bruised plum."
Why Were They Actually Blue?
It sounds like a tall tale, but the science is actually pretty straightforward. It’s a condition called methemoglobinemia.
Basically, we all have a little bit of methemoglobin in our blood. It’s a version of hemoglobin that can’t carry oxygen. Usually, our bodies have an enzyme (diaphorase) that flips it back into the "red" oxygen-carrying version.
💡 You might also like: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
The Fugates were born without that enzyme.
Because their blood wasn't properly oxygenated, it didn't look bright red; it looked chocolate brown. When that brown blood flows through the veins of someone with very fair skin, it shows up as a startling shade of blue or purple.
It all started with Martin Fugate, a French orphan who settled in Kentucky in 1820. By a crazy stroke of bad luck, he carried a recessive gene for this condition. Even crazier? He married Elizabeth Smith, a local woman who also happened to carry the exact same rare gene.
Since they lived in total isolation—we're talking no roads, no trains, just dense Appalachian woods—the family ended up marrying into other local clans like the Combes, Smiths, and Stacys. The gene pool stayed small, and the "blue" trait kept popping up for six generations.
📖 Related: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
Benjamin Stacy: The Last of the "Blues"
The story usually peaks with a baby named Benjamin Stacy, born in 1975. When he came out, he wasn't just blue; he was nearly purple. Doctors were terrified and rushed him to the University of Kentucky Medical Center for a blood transfusion.
Luckily, his grandmother piped up and told them about the "Blue Fugates" of Troublesome Creek. It turns out Benjy had just inherited one copy of the gene. As he grew up, his skin faded to a normal tone, though his lips and fingernails would still turn blue whenever he got cold or really angry.
What Most People Get Wrong
- It wasn't silver poisoning. A lot of people confuse the Fugates with Paul Karason, the "Blue Man" who turned blue from drinking colloidal silver (a condition called argyria). The Fugates were strictly genetic.
- They weren't "sick." Despite their appearance, most of the blue family members lived long, healthy lives. Many made it well into their 80s and 90s.
- They weren't "monsters." While they were shy and stayed away from the public to avoid being stared at, they were just regular mountain folks who farmed and looked after each other.
How to Tell if a Picture is Real
If you’re digging through archives or Google Images, keep these tips in mind to spot the fakes:
- Check the Saturation: If the skin looks neon or glowing, it’s a modern edit. The real color was more of a muted, dusky indigo or a grayish-blue.
- Look for the Source: Authentic images usually trace back to medical journals from the 1960s or the Science 82 archives.
- Identify the Setting: Most real Fugate photos show them in everyday Appalachian settings—porches, fields, or log cabins—not in a studio.
If you want to see the real legacy of the Fugates today, you won't find many blue people left. As the region became less isolated in the 1940s and 50s, the family branched out, the gene pool widened, and the recessive trait mostly went dormant.
The best way to understand them now is to look at the medical charts and the few legitimate color-balanced photos from the Cawein era. They remind us that sometimes, the "weirdest" parts of history are just a matter of a few missing enzymes and a very secluded mountain home.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Search for the Science 82 "Blue People of Troublesome Creek" article to see the most accurate visual representations used by researchers.
- Read Dr. Madison Cawein’s original 1964 report, "Hereditary Diaphorase Deficiency and Methemoglobinemia," if you want the deep technical breakdown of the blood chemistry.
- Visit the Hazard, Kentucky local archives or the University of Kentucky library digital collections for authentic family records that haven't been "memified."