Kelly Mantle Drag Race: What Most People Get Wrong

You probably remember the bacon. If you watched Season 6 of RuPaul’s Drag Race back in 2014, that’s the image burned into your brain: a talented, seasoned actress standing on the main stage in a dress that looked less like high fashion and more like a breakfast side dish. It was a shock. Honestly, it remains one of the biggest "what happened?" moments in the show's history. Kelly Mantle walked into that workroom with a resume longer than most of the judges' careers, only to be the first one sent packing.

But here’s the thing. Judging Kelly Mantle solely on her two-episode stint is like judging a five-star restaurant based on a single piece of burnt toast. There is so much more to her story than a failed sewing challenge. From making Oscar history to being the "switch-hitter" of a famous baseball dynasty, Kelly is a bit of a legend in her own right.

Why the Kelly Mantle Drag Race Elimination Still Stings

When the cast for Season 6 was announced, the "Fantles" (her die-hard fans) were convinced she was Top 3 material. You have to understand the context. This wasn't just another queen; this was a woman who had already appeared on NYPD Blue, CSI, and Curb Your Enthusiasm. She was a graduate of the Second City in Chicago and had a BFA in Theatre from the University of Oklahoma. She was a ringer.

Then came the split premiere.

The producers decided to divide the 14 queens into two groups of seven. Kelly was in the first group. The challenge? "TV-Inspired" sewing. Kelly tried to go for a Downton Abbey vibe, but the fabric she chose—and her admitted lack of sewing skills—led to the infamous "bacon dress" critique from Michelle Visage.

She landed in the bottom two against Vivacious. They lip-synced to Madonna’s "Express Yourself." Kelly gave it her all, but the judges weren't feeling the look or the energy. Just like that, the queen everyone expected to win was gone. It felt wrong. It felt like the show missed out on months of top-tier comedy because of one bad skirt.

Basically, the "bacon" look became a meme before memes were even a full-time currency in the Drag Race fandom. Kelly, being the professional she is, leaned into it. She even released a song called "Eliminated" and sold the dress for over $2,000. That’s how you handle a loss.

The Mickey Mantle Connection and Growing Up in Oklahoma

One of the most frequent questions people ask is whether Kelly is actually related to baseball legend Mickey Mantle. Yes, she is. Mickey was her uncle. Growing up in Oklahoma as the nephew of a New York Yankees icon isn't exactly the standard "origin story" for a drag superstar.

Kelly often jokes that "switch-hitting" runs in the family. It's a clever nod to her gender-fluid identity and her uncle’s famous batting style. But growing up in a sports-heavy environment also gave her a unique perspective on competition. She treats drag like an elite sport—the preparation, the stamina, the "game day" nerves.

Breaking Barriers at the Oscars

While the "Kelly Mantle Drag Race" search terms usually lead to clips of her elimination, her most significant career milestone happened in 2016. She starred as Sheila in the film Confessions of a Womanizer.

The producers did something unprecedented: they submitted her for consideration in both the Best Supporting Actor and Best Supporting Actress categories. The Academy actually approved it.

This was a massive deal. It made her the first openly non-binary/gender-fluid person to be eligible for both gendered categories at the Oscars. It sparked a huge conversation in Hollywood about how we categorize performers. Even if she didn't get the final nomination, the door was officially kicked open.

✨ Don't miss: Funny things to say on a prank call that won't get you in trouble

Life After the Main Stage: The All Stars Question

Will she ever go back? It’s the question that haunts every Reddit thread and Twitter (X) mention. Kelly has been asked to return for All Stars multiple times. Her answer is usually some variation of "only if they promise to send me home first again."

She’s joking—sorta.

The reality is that Kelly doesn't need the show to stay relevant. She’s been busy touring the world with Trixie Mattel and Katya Zamolodchikova on their Trixie and Katya Live tour. She also plays Sheila (different Sheila, same vibe) on the cult-favorite series The Browns alongside Tammie Brown. If you haven't seen her "Rose's Turn" performance from the Trixie and Katya tour, go find it on YouTube. It proves exactly why she was wasted on a sewing challenge.

Beyond the Wig: Advocacy and Identity

Lately, Kelly has been using her platform for more than just comedy. She’s heavily involved with organizations like Freedom Oklahoma, which supports 2SLGBTQIA+ communities, specifically focusing on Indigenous and Two-Spirit people. Being of Cherokee descent herself, this work is personal.

She recently helped develop a short film called "Threads Together" about the power of community in Oklahoma. It’s a side of her that fans didn't get to see on the show—the thoughtful, advocate-driven side.

👉 See also: The Lois Lane Amy Adams Problem: Why the DCEU Got Her So Wrong (and Right)

What We Can Learn From the Bacon Dress

Looking back at the whole Kelly Mantle Drag Race saga, there are actually some pretty solid takeaways for anyone trying to make it in a competitive field:

• Lean into the "Failure": Most people would have hidden that bacon dress in the back of a closet. Kelly sold it for two grand and made a music video. Turn your flops into features.
• Resume vs. Reality: You can have all the credits in the world, but you still have to show up for the task at hand. Kelly was a better actress than almost anyone there, but she couldn't sew a straight line that day.
• Diversify your "Brand": Kelly is an actor, singer, songwriter, and comedian. When one door (Drag Race) closed, ten others were already open because she hadn't put all her eggs in one basket.
• Know Your Worth: She doesn't feel the need to beg for an All Stars spot. She knows her talent speaks for itself, whether she's on a reality show or a soundstage in Hollywood.

If you’re a newer fan who only knows the memes, do yourself a favor and look into her actual discography or her guest spots on 90s and 2000s TV. The "bacon queen" is actually one of the most sophisticated artists to ever step foot in the werkroom.

To really get the full Kelly Mantle experience, start by watching her podcast The Kelly Mantle Show or her episodes of The Browns. It’s where her specific brand of chaotic, high-brow humor really gets to shine without the constraints of a 60-minute competition format.