If you spent any time watching Bravo between 2014 and 2017, you definitely remember the guy with the military posture and the complicated love life. Kelley Johnson wasn't just another deckhand looking for a tan. He was a former Marine who brought a very specific, sometimes intense energy to the Ohana and later the Valor. Honestly, most fans were split on him. You either loved his "big brother" protective energy or you were yelling at your TV during his messy pursuit of Jennice Ontiveros.
But then, he just... stopped. After Season 4, Kelley from Below Deck basically vanished from the reality TV ecosystem. No spin-offs, no "All-Stars" appearances, and very little drama in the tabloids. It makes you wonder: what actually happens to a guy like that when the cameras stop rolling and the "Stud of the Sea" isn't there to give him a radio lecture?
The Reality Check of Season 2
Kelley’s first lap on Below Deck during Season 2 was, to put it mildly, a bit of a rollercoaster. He came on with his sister, Amy Johnson, which is a brave move for anyone. Imagine your sister watching you try to flirt with a coworker while you’re both living in a floating tin can. It was awkward.
His relationship with Jennice Ontiveros became the central plot point, and not always in a good way. They had that "will-they-won't-they" vibe that eventually turned into a "they-definitely-did-but-now-it’s-weird" vibe. When the season ended and the cameras went dark, the relationship fizzled out almost immediately. Kelley later admitted that watching himself back was a massive wake-up call. He didn't like the guy he saw on screen—the emotional outbursts, the lack of focus. He felt like he’d let Captain Lee down.
Most reality stars lean into the villain edit or the "heartbreaker" persona. Kelley did the opposite. He went away, worked on himself, and actually stayed in the maritime industry. He didn't just go to Los Angeles to try and become an actor.
🔗 Read more: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Redemption and the Captain Lee Bond
When he returned for Season 4, it was as a Bosun. That’s a huge jump in responsibility. You aren’t just scrubbing the hull anymore; you’re managing a team of green deckhands who usually have more ego than experience.
It wasn't a perfect season. We all remember the "Senior Deckhand" Trevor situation. That was a disaster from day one. Kelley struggled with the leadership aspect, and Captain Lee Rosbach didn't hold back. There were plenty of moments where Lee basically told him to man up and lead. But here's the thing about Kelley from Below Deck: he actually cared. You could see the stress in his face. He wasn't there for the "clout." He genuinely wanted to be a good mariner.
By the end of that season, even though he had his moments of frustration, he earned a level of respect from Lee that few others have. Lee has since said in interviews that he’d work with Kelley again. In the world of Below Deck, where the Captain usually wants to fire half the crew by charter three, that’s a massive win.
What is Kelley Johnson Doing Now?
So, where is he in 2026? He didn't stay a reality TV star, but he did stay a Captain.
💡 You might also like: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Kelley moved to Fort Lauderdale, which is basically the Mecca for yachties, and he leaned hard into his professional maritime career. He’s currently a captain of a 68-foot vessel called Ship of Fools. It’s a very different life than the 150-foot superyachts you see on Bravo. It’s more personal, less "white glove," and probably way less stressful without a production crew following you into the head.
But his real passion shifted toward the lens. If you look at his work today, he’s a professional photographer and videographer. He’s actually really good at it. He captures a lot of ocean life, travel content, and—surprisingly—he’s used his platform to talk about things that actually matter.
- Mental Health Advocacy: For a while, Kelley ran a YouTube channel called The Military Guy. He was super open about his struggles with anxiety and the transition from the Marine Corps to civilian life.
- Family Life: He’s settled down. He’s married to Nicole Viljoen Johnson, and they seem to live a pretty quiet, outdoor-centric life.
- The Sister Bond: He and Amy are still incredibly close. He even photographed her wedding back in 2020. They did a brief stint on Galley Talk together, which was a nice nostalgia hit for fans, but they haven't made a full-time return to the screen.
Why He Won't Come Back to Bravo
People always ask if Kelley from Below Deck will ever return as a "legacy" cast member. Honestly? It’s unlikely. He’s found a balance that reality TV usually destroys.
Being a Bosun or a Captain on a show like Below Deck means you’re signing up to have your mistakes magnified for millions of people. Kelley has already "done the work" and gotten his redemption arc. He proved he could do the job, he patched things up with Lee, and he found a career that doesn't involve being edited for maximum drama.
📖 Related: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
What You Can Learn From Kelley’s Transition
If you're a fan of the show or even just someone looking to pivot careers, Kelley’s trajectory is actually a pretty solid blueprint.
- Use the platform, don't let it use you. He used the show to build a network in the yachting world, but he didn't try to stay "famous" for the sake of it.
- Lean into your skills. He took his military discipline and applied it to getting his Captain's license.
- Find a side hustle. His photography isn't just a hobby; it’s a legitimate business that allows him to express a creative side he couldn't show while he was scrubbing the deck.
If you want to keep up with what he’s doing, your best bet is Instagram. He posts a lot of stunning drone shots and ocean photography. It’s a far cry from the tequila-fueled nights at the crew bar, and frankly, he looks a lot happier for it.
The era of Kelley from Below Deck as a "reality hunk" is over. Now, he's just a guy who loves the water and knows how to frame a sunset. And in the chaotic world of the Below Deck alumni, that’s probably the biggest success story of them all.
Check out his photography portfolio if you want to see what life looks like when you trade the drama for a high-end camera lens. It’s worth the scroll.
Actionable Insight: If you’re looking to break into the yachting industry like Kelley did, don't just look at the reality TV side. Start by getting your STCW certification and moving to a hub like Fort Lauderdale or Antibes. The real work happens when the cameras are off, and as Kelley proved, that's where the real career is built.