You know the feeling. You’re standing in front of the bathroom mirror, one wing looks like it was drawn by a Renaissance master, and the other looks like a jagged mess because your pen suddenly decided to go on strike. If you’ve ever owned a Kat Von D Tattoo Liner, you’ve lived this drama. It is arguably the most famous eyeliner in the world. It’s the one that survived a literal car crash in that viral 2018 review. Yet, for all its fame, people are still constantly arguing about whether it’s actually the "GOAT" or just a dried-out disappointment in a fancy tube.
Honestly, the conversation around this liner is a bit of a mess right now. Part of that is because the brand isn't even owned by Kat Von D anymore. Since 2020, Katherine von Drachenberg has been completely out of the picture. The brand was sold to Kendo (an LVMH incubator) and rebranded as KVD Beauty. Then, more recently in 2025, it changed hands again, moving over to Belle Beauty/Windsong.
So when you buy a tube today, you aren't buying the exact same thing you bought in 2015.
The brush tip vs. felt tip confusion
The biggest thing most people get wrong about this liner is why they like it. They think it’s the "ink." It isn't. It’s the bristles. Most liquid eyeliners use a felt tip—essentially a tiny, stiff marker. Those fray. They get "fuzzy" after three uses.
The Kat Von D Tattoo Liner uses a brush tip made of 325 individual vegan bristles.
🔗 Read more: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
This matters because it mimics a real paintbrush. It’s incredibly flexible. If you want a line as thin as a piece of hair, you just barely touch it to your skin. If you want a thick, Amy Winehouse-style wing, you press down, and the bristles fan out. It gives you a level of control that a stiff felt tip simply can't match.
But here is the catch. Because it’s a brush, it’s a delivery system for a very specific, thin formula. If you’ve used the Ink Liner from the same brand, you probably hated it compared to the Tattoo Liner. Why? Because the Ink Liner used a felt tip. It’s a completely different experience.
Why your liner keeps drying out (it’s probably your fault)
We’ve all seen the reviews. "I used it twice and it’s bone dry!"
It’s the number one complaint. But here’s the truth: the liner usually isn't empty. It’s clogged. When you apply eyeliner over eyeshadow—especially shimmery or glittery ones—those tiny particles get sucked up into the bristles. They act like a dam, blocking the ink from reaching the tip.
💡 You might also like: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
How to actually save a "dead" pen
- The Wipe: Take a damp paper towel (or one with a tiny bit of micellar water) and firmly wipe the bristles. You’ll see a bunch of gunk come off.
- The Gravity Trick: Stop storing your makeup bag flat. This liner needs to be stored tip-down. You want gravity to keep that ink soaked into the brush.
- The Shake: There’s a tiny ball bearing inside. Shake it like you're mixing a cocktail. If you don't hear that "clack-clack" sound, the ink is settled and won't flow.
The formula controversy: Did it actually change?
Social media is convinced the formula was ruined after the rebrand. Is it true? KVD Beauty actually did announce a reformulation in late 2024/early 2025, claiming it was "clinically improved" for better flow and deeper pigment.
The reality is nuanced. Some long-time fans claim the new version is "stickier" or harder to remove. Others say the "Trooper Black" shade is finally as dark as it used to be. For a while, there was a legitimate issue where the black looked more like a dark charcoal grey. The current version in the luxe aluminum pen is definitely more "inky," but that means it also dries faster.
If you have oily eyelids, this is a godsend. If you have dry, textured lids, it might feel like it's "tugging" more than it used to.
How it stacks up against the 2026 competition
In the current market, the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner isn't the only player anymore. It’s facing heavy pressure from brands like NYX and Rare Beauty.
📖 Related: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
- NYX Epic Ink: This is the "dupe" everyone talks about. It’s half the price. It’s also very wet. If you aren't careful, the NYX version can "bleed" into the fine lines around your eyes. The KVD formula stays where you put it.
- Stila Stay All Day: This is the old rival. Stila uses a felt tip. It's more beginner-friendly because it's stiffer, but it doesn't give you that needle-sharp point that KVD does.
- Rare Beauty: Selena Gomez’s liner is very similar to KVD because it also uses a brush tip. However, it’s a bit more "flexible," which can actually make it harder for beginners to keep a steady hand.
The "Tattoo" part of the name
Don't let the name fool you. It isn't a literal tattoo. It’s waterproof, yes, but it isn't "nuclear-blast proof." If you have a habit of rubbing your eyes, it will flake. That’s the trade-off for a formula that dries down to a matte finish rather than a shiny, plastic-look finish.
The "Tattoo" branding really refers to the precision. It’s for the people who want to draw tiny details, like faux freckles or inner-corner "cat" points.
Actionable steps for your next wing
If you’re going to drop the money on a new tube, do it right. First, check the packaging. Ensure you’re getting the Tattoo Liner (brush tip) and not a pencil or a felt-tip variant unless that's specifically what you want.
Before you apply, make sure your eyelids are dry. Even a little bit of leftover moisturizer can act as a barrier that prevents the liner from "locking" onto your skin. If you’re doing a complex look, apply your shadow first, then use a clean tissue to wipe the liner tip every few strokes to prevent clogging.
Finally, when you're done, click that cap until you hear it snap. If you don't hear the snap, you’re basically throwing your money in the trash because it will dry out by morning.
Store it in a cup on your vanity, tip-down. It's the only way to ensure that the last drop of ink is as pigmented as the first.