The internet is a weird place. One day you’re scrolling through TikTok or YouTube, and suddenly a thumbnail pops up claiming a massive breakthrough in a cold case. You see the name. You see the "Breaking News" banner. You see the face of Karlie Guse.
It’s been over seven years since the 16-year-old vanished from her home in Chalfant Valley, California. The desert doesn't give up secrets easily. So, when people see headlines suggesting Karlie Guse found by YouTuber, they click. They want it to be true. We all do.
But honestly? She hasn't been found. Not by a YouTuber, not by the FBI, and not by the local sheriff.
As of January 2026, Karlie Guse remains a missing person. The "found" videos are almost always clickbait or a massive misunderstanding of a "found" Jane Doe who turned out to be someone else. It's frustrating. It's heartbreaking for the family. And it’s exactly why we need to look at what’s actually happening with this case right now.
The Reality Behind the YouTuber Claims
Why does this specific rumor—that a YouTuber found her—keep coming back?
Usually, it's because of "digital sleuths" who cover cold cases. They might find a person living on the streets in another state who looks like an age-progressed version of Karlie. They film it, post it with a dramatic title, and the algorithm does the rest.
In some instances, YouTubers have visited the Bishop area to do their own "investigations." They fly drones over the desert or interview locals at the Benton Station café. They might find a piece of clothing or a "clue," but nothing has ever been DNA-linked to Karlie.
The most recent flurry of "found" rumors likely stems from a few high-profile Jane Doe identifications in late 2025 and early 2026. Whenever a body is identified after decades, people start speculating about other missing girls. But the Mono County Sheriff’s Office hasn't changed her status. She is still missing.
✨ Don't miss: New York Total Snowfall: What Most People Get Wrong
What Actually Happened on October 13, 2018?
To understand why people are so obsessed with finding her, you have to look at how she disappeared. It’s haunting.
Karlie was 16. She went to a party, reportedly smoked some marijuana that her family suspects was laced with something else, and came home in a state of total paranoia. Her stepmother, Melissa Guse, recorded her that night. You can hear Karlie's voice—it’s shaky, terrified. She talked about "the devil's lettuce" and was scared to sleep.
Melissa stayed with her until the early morning. She says she dozed off around 5:48 a.m. When she woke up a little later, Karlie was gone.
No phone. No shoes. Just a 16-year-old girl walking into the high desert in her pajamas.
The Witnesses
This is the part that drives investigators crazy. She wasn't just "gone." People saw her.
- A neighbor saw her standing in the driveway, looking at the sky.
- Three separate witnesses saw her walking toward Highway 6.
- One witness even said she was holding a piece of paper.
Then? Nothing. She reached the highway and essentially evaporated.
The Theories That Refuse to Die
When a case goes cold, the vacuum is filled with theories. Some are grounded in logic; others are born in the dark corners of Reddit.
1. The "Walked Into the Desert" Theory
The high desert is brutal. If Karlie was disoriented and wandered off the road, the elements could have overcome her quickly. But search crews combed that area with dogs, helicopters, and hundreds of volunteers. They found nothing. No remains, no fabric, no scent.
2. The Abduction Theory
This is what many fear. Highway 6 is a long, lonely stretch of road that leads into Nevada. If she was standing by the side of the road in a delusional state, she was the perfect target for a predator. The FBI has investigated tips from as far away as Tonopah, Nevada, but the trail always goes cold.
3. The Family Suspicion
Early on, a lot of heat was put on Zac and Melissa Guse. Karlie’s biological mother, Lindsay Fairley, has been very vocal about her doubts regarding their story. However, both Zac and Melissa passed polygraph tests. Law enforcement has stated they are not suspects.
Where the Case Stands in 2026
The FBI and the Mono County Sheriff are still on this. In fact, just this month, new "Victim Specialist" videos were released to keep her face in the public eye.
There was a moment of hope in 2023 when a recovering drug user claimed he saw Karlie at a party in 2021. Tips like that are why the family refuses to give up. Zac Guse has said he "wants to let the light in." They still have her room ready. They still wait for the phone to ring.
But we have to be careful with the Karlie Guse found by YouTuber narrative. False hope is a different kind of pain. When creators use her name for views without having actual facts, it muddies the water. It makes it harder for real tips to reach the authorities.
How to Actually Help Find Karlie Guse
If you want to do more than just watch videos, here is the actual, practical way to contribute to this case.
First, stop sharing "breaking news" videos that don't link to an official police statement. If she is found, it will be announced by the Mono County Sheriff or the FBI, not a random thumbnail with red arrows.
Second, look at the age-progression photos. Karlie would be 23 years old now. Her hair was dark blonde, her eyes are blue, and she has a pierced left nostril. She might look very different today than she did in 2018.
If you have a legitimate tip—something you saw or heard—don't post it on a YouTube comment thread. Send it here:
- Mono County Sheriff’s Office: 760-932-5678 or karliegusetips@monosheriff.org
- FBI Sacramento: 916-746-7000
- National Center for Missing & Exploited Children: 1-800-THE-LOST
We all want the headline to be true. We want to see Karlie Guse home. Until then, the best thing we can do is keep the facts straight and keep her name in the conversation for the right reasons.
Next Steps for Readers:
Check the official FBI Missing Persons flyer for Karlie's most recent age-progressed photo. Share that specific image on your social media feeds instead of speculative video content. If you live in or travel through the Nevada/California border region along Highway 6, keep the contact information for the Mono County Sheriff saved in your phone. Every bit of awareness counts, but only if it's based on the truth.