Most people remember Karen Carpenter for that voice—that low, honey-thick contralto that could make a grocery list sound like a heartbreak. But if you only know her as the lady who sang "Close to You," you’re basically missing the coolest part of her DNA. Karen didn't want to be a singer. She wanted to hit things. Specifically, she wanted to be a world-class jazz drummer, and honestly, she actually pulled it off before the industry forced her to stand center stage and "look pretty."
There is this one specific Karen Carpenter drumming solo from 1976 that still makes the rounds on TikTok and YouTube today. It’s from the Carpenters' first TV special. In it, she’s not just keeping time; she is absolutely ripping through a medley of "Strike Up the Band" and "'S Wonderful." Watching her hands move is a trip. She’s using traditional grip—the way the old-school jazz guys like Buddy Rich did—and her speed is just clinical. It’s the kind of technical proficiency that makes "hobbyist" drummers want to sell their kits and take up knitting.
The Drummer Who Sang (Not the Other Way Around)
Karen famously referred to herself as a "drummer who sang." It wasn't just a cute tag line. When the Carpenters first signed to A&M Records, she was the one behind the kit, even for the lead vocals. Imagine the lung capacity required to maintain a rock-solid pocket while hitting those crystal-clear notes. Most modern artists can't even walk and sing at the same time without a backing track, but Karen was out here doing polyrhythmic fills while delivering perfect pitch.
The tragedy of her career, at least from a musician's perspective, is that she was too good at singing. Her brother Richard and their management realized that the public wanted to see her face, not her cymbals. They eventually pushed her out from behind the drums to be the "frontwoman." She hated it. She reportedly felt exposed and uncomfortable without her "walls" (the drum kit) around her. That 1976 Karen Carpenter drumming solo was one of the few times she got to reclaim her identity on a massive scale.
Why John Bonham Was Actually Salty
You’ve probably heard the urban legend about the 1975 Playboy music poll. It’s not a legend—it actually happened. In 1975, the readers of Playboy voted Karen Carpenter the Best Drummer of the Year. She beat out Led Zeppelin’s John Bonham. She beat out The Who's Keith Moon.
💡 You might also like: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Bonham, famously a "power thumper," was reportedly livid. He allegedly made comments about how Karen wouldn't last five minutes on a Zeppelin track. But here’s the thing: Bonzo was right about the power, but he was dead wrong about the technique. Karen was trained in the school of Joe Morello and Buddy Rich. Her ghost notes, her rudiments, and her sheer "time-keeping" were, quite frankly, more precise than the rock legends of her era.
Buddy Rich himself—a man notoriously difficult to impress and who generally hated pop music—was a massive fan. He didn't just tolerate her; he praised her. When the greatest jazz drummer to ever live says you've got chops, the debate is over.
The Gear That Made the Sound
Karen wasn't just using whatever was lying around the studio. She was a Ludwig girl through and through.
- The Kit: 1965 Ludwig Super Classic in Champagne Sparkle.
- The Snare: Ludwig 5x14 Super-Sensitive (her absolute favorite).
- The Cymbals: Zildjian.
- The Technique: Heavily focused on traditional grip, which allowed for that snappy, jazz-influenced rebound that defined her solo sections.
Breaking Down the 1976 Virtuoso Performance
If you go back and watch that '76 special, the Karen Carpenter drumming solo is structured like a high-wire act. She starts with these crisp, marching-band style rolls on the snare before transitioning into a full-kit workout. The camera work is a bit "70s variety show," but if you watch her feet, you’ll see she had a killer right foot on the bass drum.
📖 Related: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
She was playing in a "box" style—very economical movements, no wasted energy. That’s the mark of a pro. While rock drummers were flailing their arms for show, Karen was keeping her elbows in and letting her wrists do the heavy lifting. It’s why she could play for hours without tiring, even when she was physically struggling with her health behind the scenes.
The Hal Blaine Connection
We can't talk about Karen's drumming without mentioning Hal Blaine, the legendary Wrecking Crew drummer who played on basically every hit song in the 60s and 70s. Hal played on many of the Carpenters' studio tracks because, as he put it, "playing in the studio is a different science than playing live."
Hal wasn't there because Karen couldn't play; he was there because they wanted a specific "radio sound" that only Hal’s "Monster Kit" could provide. In fact, Karen and Hal were close friends. He actually had a custom set of Ludwig drums made for her—similar to his own "Octa-Plus" kit—so she could have that massive studio sound when she went on tour. Hal frequently defended her, saying she had "the perfect time." For a singer, having a drummer's brain is like a cheat code for phrasing and rhythm.
What Modern Drummers Can Learn From Karen
In 2026, we’re seeing a massive resurgence in "pocket" drumming. The flashy, over-the-top YouTube solos are losing ground to drummers who can actually groove. Karen was the queen of the pocket.
👉 See also: Tim Dillon: I'm Your Mother Explained (Simply)
If you're a drummer looking to improve, don't just watch her solo for the speed. Watch her for the accuracy.
- Study her rudiments: Her paradiddles and flams were textbook perfect.
- Focus on Traditional Grip: It’s harder to learn but gives you a different tonal control over the snare.
- Internalize the Tempo: Karen’s "internal clock" was so steady that producers often didn't need to use a click track when she was playing.
She wasn't just "good for a girl" or "good for a singer." She was an elite-tier percussionist who happened to have a voice that defined a generation. The next time someone tries to tell you the Carpenters were just "soft rock," show them that 1976 Karen Carpenter drumming solo. It usually shuts them up pretty fast.
To really appreciate her skill, go find the isolated drum tracks for the Now & Then album. Listen to the way she hits the snare—it’s always right in the center, always consistent. That kind of discipline is rare. If you're looking to dive deeper into her technique, start by practicing "Take Five" by Dave Brubeck. Karen mastered that 5/4 time signature within a year of picking up the sticks. That’s the level of natural talent we’re talking about.