Honestly, if you're a football fan, you know the drill by now. Whenever you see Kansas City v Buffalo Bills on the schedule, you clear your afternoon. You grab the wings. You prepare for your heart rate to do things your doctor wouldn't approve of. It's basically become the new Brady vs. Manning, but with more running and significantly more chaotic energy.
But there is a weird, almost cruel pattern emerging here that Buffalo fans are starting to take personally.
The Bills are incredible in the regular season. They really are. They beat the Chiefs like it’s a hobby when the leaves are still turning colors. Just this past November, Josh Allen and company walked into Orchard Park and handled Kansas City 28-21. It was the fifth time in six regular-season tries that Allen has gotten the better of Patrick Mahomes. If the NFL season ended in December, the Bills would probably have a statue of Sean McDermott outside the stadium by now.
But it doesn't.
The Playoff Curse Nobody Wants to Admit
Here is the stat that keeps Western New York up at night: Patrick Mahomes is 4-0 against Josh Allen in the playoffs.
Four and oh.
💡 You might also like: Navy Notre Dame Football: Why This Rivalry Still Hits Different
It doesn't matter if it's the "13 Seconds" game that broke everyone's brain in 2022 or the 32-29 nail-biter in the AFC Championship last January. When the stakes are at their absolute highest, Kansas City finds a way to pull a rabbit out of a hat, and Buffalo finds a way to be the hat.
Last January's AFC title game was a perfect example of the madness. The Bills actually led 22-21 going into the fourth quarter. James Cook was running like a man possessed, racking up two touchdowns. But then Mahomes did that Mahomes thing. He scrambled for a 10-yard score, hit a two-point conversion, and suddenly the Chiefs were up 29-22. Buffalo tied it back up, but a late Harrison Butker field goal and a defensive stand ended the Bills' Super Bowl dreams—again.
It’s gotten to the point where the regular season wins almost feel like a trap. They give the Bills Mafia hope, but the January results are a recurring nightmare.
Mahomes vs. Allen: By the Numbers
When you look at the raw data, it’s wild how close these two are. It’s not like Mahomes is significantly "better" in a vacuum. Honestly, Allen often looks like the more physically dominant player. He’s bigger, he runs harder, and he throws the ball like it’s been launched from a cannon.
In their head-to-head history:
📖 Related: LeBron James Without Beard: Why the King Rarely Goes Clean Shaven Anymore
- Total Record: 5-5 (dead even).
- Regular Season: 5-1 in favor of Josh Allen.
- Postseason: 4-0 in favor of Patrick Mahomes.
- Postseason Passer Rating: Mahomes clocks in at a ridiculous 123.7 against the Bills, while Allen sits at a very respectable 100.2.
The difference isn't talent. It's usually one or two plays. A missed field goal by Tyler Bass. A defensive lapse in the final 13 seconds. A fumble at the worst possible moment. Kansas City has developed this "survive and advance" DNA that Buffalo hasn't quite replicated when the pressure is 100 times higher.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Rivalry
A lot of talking heads like to say the Bills "choke." That’s sorta lazy. If you watch the games, they aren't falling apart. They’re playing elite football. The problem is that the Chiefs under Andy Reid have turned late-game execution into a science.
The Bills actually out-gained the Chiefs in their last playoff meeting. They had more rushing first downs. They controlled the clock. But the Chiefs are comfortable being uncomfortable. They don't panic when they're down by 10. They just wait for that one window to open.
The Road to 2026: Can Buffalo Flip the Script?
So, where do we go from here? As of January 2026, the Bills are once again looking like a powerhouse. They finished the 2025 regular season strong and are currently sitting with some of the best odds to win Super Bowl LX. Vegas has them at around +650, which is right up there with the heavy hitters.
But here’s the kicker. To get there, they almost certainly have to go through Kansas City. Again.
👉 See also: When is Georgia's next game: The 2026 Bulldog schedule and what to expect
The Chiefs are chasing history, trying to maintain their grip on the AFC after three straight Super Bowl appearances. They've rebuilt their receiving corps with guys like Xavier Worthy, who has become a massive headache for the Bills' secondary. Meanwhile, Buffalo is leaning on a more balanced attack, with James Cook proving he can carry the load and a defense that—while occasionally prone to the "big play" lapse—is as gritty as they come.
Actionable Insights for the Next Matchup
If you're betting on or just watching the next iteration of Kansas City v Buffalo Bills, keep these specific keys in mind:
- The "Middle 8" Minutes: Pay attention to the last four minutes of the second quarter and the first four of the third. The Chiefs are notorious for "double-dipping"—scoring right before half and right after. This is where Buffalo usually loses control of the momentum.
- Pressure Without Blitzing: In their January 2025 loss, the Bills struggled to get home with just four pass rushers. If Mahomes has more than three seconds in the pocket, you're toast. Watch for how Matt Milano and Greg Rousseau are used to disrupt the rhythm early.
- The Josh Allen "Hero Ball" Factor: Allen is at his best when he's improvising, but his most successful games against KC are when he takes the 5-yard check-down to Dalton Kincaid instead of forcing the 40-yard bomb.
- Red Zone Efficiency: The Bills settled for field goals in key moments last time. Against Mahomes, three points is basically a turnover. It’s four-down territory as soon as they cross the 35-yard line.
The narrative won't change until Buffalo wins a game that ends with a trophy presentation. Until then, the regular season dominance is just a prelude to the real test.
Watch the injury reports as we head deeper into the 2026 playoffs. Specifically, keep an eye on the Bills' secondary. If they aren't at 100%, Mahomes will pick them apart just like he has every January for the last half-decade. It's the greatest rivalry in modern sports, but for Buffalo, it’s a hurdle that’s starting to feel like a mountain.
To stay ahead of the next matchup, track the defensive DVOA rankings for both teams heading into the divisional round, as the higher-ranked defense has won three of the last four postseason meetings. Focus on third-down conversion rates in the fourth quarter, which remains the single most predictive stat for this specific rivalry.