It’s January 2026. If you’re a football fan, your Twitter feed is probably a disaster right now. Half the world is ready to crown the Kansas City quarterback as the greatest to ever lace them up, and the other half is busy digging through his 2025 stats to prove he’s finally "fallen off."
The truth? It’s complicated. It’s always complicated with Patrick Mahomes.
People love to talk about the "Mahomes Magic" like it’s some kind of fairy dust he sprinkles on the ball before every snap. But honestly, if you look at how he actually played this past season—and the absolute mess he’s had to navigate—you’ll realize the flashy no-look passes are basically the least interesting thing about him. We’ve reached a point where his greatness is so normalized that we’re bored by it. We’re nitpicking a guy who, despite a grueling 2025 campaign, still finished with 3,587 passing yards and 22 touchdowns in 14 games before a nasty ACL/LCL injury sidelined him.
That’s the reality. He’s human. He gets hurt. He throws picks. But the narrative that he’s just a "system QB" or that Andy Reid is doing all the heavy lifting? That’s where most people get it wrong.
The 2025 Reality Check: Why the Stats Look Different
Let’s be real for a second. If any other signal-caller in the league put up Mahomes' 2025 numbers—roughly 3,600 yards and a 2:1 TD-to-INT ratio—we’d be talking about a Pro Bowl season. For Mahomes, people called it "lackluster."
Why? Because we’re comparing him to the 2018 version of himself. Back then, he was chucking the ball 50 yards downfield to Tyreek Hill every other play. It was track meet football. It was fun. But the NFL caught up. Defenses started sitting in that deep "shell" coverage, basically daring Mahomes to be boring. And for a while, he resisted. He’d try to force the "hero ball" throws, which led to those "WTF" interceptions we saw a few years back.
But the Kansas City quarterback evolved.
📖 Related: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
In 2025, we saw a much more tactical version of Mahomes. He started taking the "death by a thousand paper cuts" approach. Short slants. Check-downs to Isiah Pacheco. Moving the chains with his legs (he actually averaged a career-high 6.6 yards per carry this year). He’s learned that a boring five-yard completion is better than a 40-yard highlight-reel incompletion.
"He’s basically become a more mobile version of Tom Brady," one Reddit analyst recently noted. "The big-play Chiefs aren't dead, but they’re not the identity anymore."
Honestly, that’s a scary thought for the rest of the league. A Mahomes who is willing to be patient is a Mahomes who wins Super Bowls while playing "bad" football.
The Current Depth Chart Disaster
If you’re looking at the Chiefs' roster right now, it’s a bit of a horror show. With Mahomes on Injured Reserve following that knee injury late in the 2025 season, the quarterback room in Kansas City is... thin. Very thin.
- Chris Oladokun: The lone healthy survivor. He’s 28, has bounced around practice squads for years, and suddenly he’s the guy.
- Patrick Mahomes (IR): The GOAT-in-waiting, currently rehabbing and hoping to be back for Week 1 of the 2026 season.
- Gardner Minshew (IR): Brought in to be the "elite backup," but he also caught the injury bug.
This isn't just a personnel issue; it’s a massive salary cap headache. The Chiefs are projected to be roughly $52.7 million over the cap heading into the 2026 league year. When you have a Kansas City quarterback making $45 million a year (with a cap hit jumping to a staggering $78.2 million in 2026), you can’t afford to have a lot of "misses" on the rest of the roster.
Brett Veach is going to have to work some serious magic this offseason. We’re talking about cutting veterans like Jawaan Taylor or Mike Danna just to keep the lights on. It’s the price you pay for greatness. You get the rings, but you lose the depth.
👉 See also: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
What Most People Miss About the "Mahomes Legacy"
There’s this weird debate that always pops up: Is he better than Brady?
If you look at the raw talent, it’s not even a contest. Brady never had the arm talent or the mobility Mahomes has. But Brady had the longevity and the "cold-blooded" efficiency. Mahomes is 0-2 against Brady in the playoffs, and for a lot of fans, that’s the end of the conversation.
But here’s what’s missed: Mahomes is doing this in an era of defensive complexity that Brady rarely faced in his prime. Defensive coordinators are literally inventing new schemes just to stop #15. He’s the most scouted, most analyzed, and most pressured player in sports. And he’s still winning.
Even in a "down" year like 2025, he was leading a team that featured a rotating door of wide receivers. Aside from Rashee Rice and the aging (but still legendary) Travis Kelce, the weapons haven't been elite. He’s making it work with Tyquan Thornton and Xavier Worthy—guys who have speed but are still learning the nuances of Andy Reid’s complex playbook.
The Andy Reid Factor: Who Deserves the Credit?
You can't talk about the Kansas City quarterback without talking about the "Big Red" mastermind.
Andy Reid has been in Kansas City since 2013. He’s won 72.9% of his games. He’s a first-ballot Hall of Famer. Some critics say Mahomes is just a product of Reid’s system. They point to Alex Smith’s success before Mahomes as proof.
✨ Don't miss: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
Sure, Alex Smith was great. He was steady. He won games. But Alex Smith didn't win three Super Bowls. He didn't make the throws that defy physics. Reid provides the blueprint, but Mahomes is the one who goes off-script when the building is on fire.
The relationship between the two is sort of like a great jazz duo. Reid provides the melody and the structure, but Mahomes is allowed to improvise during the solo. That trust is what makes the Chiefs' offense so hard to defend. Even when you play the perfect coverage, Mahomes will scramble, wait 7.5 seconds, and then flick a sidearm pass to a spot that shouldn't exist.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season
If you're following the Chiefs into this upcoming year, here is what you actually need to watch for. Don't get distracted by the talking heads on ESPN. Focus on these three things:
- The Rehab Timeline: Watch the reports on Mahomes' ACL/LCL recovery. A mobile Mahomes is a dangerous Mahomes. If he loses that 5% of "twitch" in his knee, he’ll have to lean even harder into that "pocket passer" role he flirted with in 2025.
- The Salary Cap Purge: Keep an eye on March 11. That's when the new league year begins. If the Chiefs can't restructure Mahomes' deal or find $50 million in savings, the roster around him is going to get even younger and more inexperienced.
- The Deep Ball Evolution: In early 2025, Mahomes vowed to bring back the "chuck-and-duck" deep shots. It worked for a few weeks with Tyquan Thornton before the injury. If they can find a way to keep defenses honest while maintaining the "boring" efficiency, the league is in trouble.
The Kansas City quarterback isn't just a player anymore; he's a benchmark. Every young QB drafted this year will be compared to him. Every defensive coordinator will spend their summer trying to solve him. Whether you love him or hate him, you can’t look away.
Kansas City’s future depends entirely on #15’s right knee and Brett Veach’s calculator. It’s going to be a wild 2026.
To stay ahead of the curve on the Chiefs' roster moves, monitor the official NFL transaction wire during the second week of March. This is when the "cap casualties" will be announced, and we'll see exactly what kind of support system Mahomes will have for his comeback season. Focus specifically on the status of the offensive line; without a clean pocket, even a healthy Mahomes struggles to find his rhythm.