Patrick Mahomes makes it look easy. It isn't. Before the no-look passes and the three Super Bowl rings in five years, the history of Kansas City Chiefs QBs was, frankly, a long stretch of "just good enough." Fans spent decades watching the team trade for other people's veterans. It worked sometimes. Usually, it didn't.
Now? The league revolves around Arrowhead.
If you want to understand the current dynasty, you have to look at the drought that came before it. For nearly 30 years, this franchise didn't win a playoff game. That’s a lot of Sundays spent watching guys like Steve Bono or Tyler Thigpen try to make magic out of nothing. We're talking about a team that went from 1987 to 2017 without winning a single game with a quarterback they actually drafted. Think about that. That is a statistical anomaly that feels more like a curse.
The Trade-In Era: Montana, Green, and Smith
For a long time, the strategy for Kansas City Chiefs QBs was basically "check the San Francisco 49ers' leftovers." It sounds harsh, but look at the names. Joe Montana. Steve Bono. Alex Smith.
Joe Montana coming to KC in 1993 was the biggest thing to happen to the city since jazz. He was older, sure. His elbow was held together by hope and tape, but he brought a swagger that hadn't existed since the Len Dawson days. He took them to an AFC Championship game. He beat Steve Young in a head-to-head duel that people still talk about at Jack Stack Barbecue. But Joe was a short-term fix. He was a luxury rental.
Then came Trent Green. Honestly, Green is one of the most underrated players in NFL history. From 2001 to 2005, he threw for over 4,000 yards in three consecutive seasons. You have to remember, that was back when 4,000 yards actually meant something—it wasn't just a Tuesday afternoon stat like it is now. He was the pilot of the "Greatest Show on Surf," backed by Priest Holmes and the best offensive line ever assembled (Will Shields and Willie Roaf were literal brick walls). Green was efficient, tough as nails, and probably deserved a Ring of Honor spot much sooner than he got it.
But the most pivotal "veteran" was Alex Smith.
When Andy Reid arrived in 2013, he traded for Smith. People called him a "game manager." It was meant as an insult. Smith took it as a job description. He won. A lot. He stabilized a franchise that had just gone 2-14 and was reeling from tragedy. Smith wasn't going to throw a 70-yard bomb off his back foot, but he was going to protect the ball and keep the chains moving. Most importantly, he was the guy who sat in the room and taught a kid from Texas Tech how to be a pro.
The 2017 Draft and the Death of the Curse
Everyone remembers the 2017 NFL Draft. The Chiefs traded up to the 10th spot. They took Patrick Mahomes.
At the time, draft "experts" hated it. They called him a "system QB." They said his mechanics were broken. They were wrong. Mahomes sat for a year behind Alex Smith, which might be the most important year in the history of Kansas City Chiefs QBs. He learned how to read a defense without the pressure of starting. When he finally took the field in 2018, he didn't just play well—he broke the league. 50 touchdowns. 5,000 yards. An MVP trophy in his first year as a starter.
It changed the math for the entire city. Suddenly, "close enough" wasn't the goal. The goal was the Lombardi.
The Mount Rushmore of Kansas City Signal Callers
If we’re being real, the list of truly elite Kansas City Chiefs QBs is a short one. You’ve got Mahomes at the top, and it’s not even a debate anymore. He’s passed everyone. But who else fills out the ranks?
Len Dawson: The original. The man who was photographed smoking a cigarette and drinking a Fresca at halftime of Super Bowl I. He was the MVP of Super Bowl IV. For fifty years, he was the gold standard in Kansas City. He wasn't just a player; he was a broadcaster and a local icon. His "cool under fire" demeanor defined the franchise for generations.
Patrick Mahomes: What is there left to say? He has three Super Bowl MVPs. He has the highest career passer rating in playoff history. He makes throws that look like they belong in a Pixar movie. He is the reason the Chiefs are now a global brand rather than a regional favorite.
Trent Green: As mentioned, the volume stats and the consistency during the early 2000s put him here. He survived the transition from the "Martyball" era to the high-flying Dick Vermeil era without missing a beat.
Alex Smith: You can argue for Montana here, but Smith played more games and won more consistently. He led the team to four playoff appearances in five years. He was the bridge to the dynasty.
The Names You Probably Forgot (For a Reason)
It hasn’t always been Hall of Fame highlights. Being a fan of Kansas City Chiefs QBs in the late 2000s was a test of faith.
Do you remember the Brodie Croyle era? Zero wins. Literally. Croyle went 0-10 as a starter. Then there was Matt Cassel. The Chiefs gave him a massive contract after he filled in for Tom Brady in New England. It was a disaster. Cassel had one good year in 2010—the "Pro Bowl" year where he threw 27 touchdowns—but the rest was a blur of interceptions and three-and-outs.
Then you had the "brief cameos."
- Elvis Grbac: He beat out Rich Gannon in a controversy that still divides older fans.
- Tyler Palko: A dark time for everyone involved.
- Brady Quinn: A high-profile bust who couldn't find his footing in KC.
- Damon Huard: Actually played surprisingly well when Green got hurt, but never had the "it" factor.
The frustration of these years is exactly why the current era feels so sweet. When you’ve watched Tyler Thigpen lead the team in rushing because nobody could catch his passes, you don't take Patrick Mahomes for granted. Not for one second.
Why the System Works Under Andy Reid
A quarterback is only as good as the guy calling the plays. Since 2013, the Kansas City Chiefs QBs have benefited from the brilliant, slightly eccentric mind of Andy Reid.
Reid is famous for his "taco-sized" play sheet and his ability to evolve. Most coaches get old and stubborn. Reid gets older and weirder—in a good way. He takes plays from high school teams, 1940s archives, and Madden. He creates space.
When Mahomes arrived, Reid didn't force him into a traditional West Coast Offense. He merged his system with the "Air Raid" concepts Mahomes used at Texas Tech. They created a hybrid. It relies on horizontal stretch, vertical speed (thank you, Tyreek Hill), and the gravitational pull of Travis Kelce.
✨ Don't miss: Malvern Prep Football Schedule: What Really Happened This Season
But it’s also about the backup. Look at Chad Henne. In the 2022 playoffs, Mahomes went down with a high ankle sprain against the Jaguars. Henne, a veteran who had been holding a clipboard for years, came in and led a 98-yard touchdown drive. That doesn't happen by accident. It happens because the QB room in Kansas City is run like a laboratory.
The Future: Life After the Dynasty?
Mahomes is under contract basically forever. He has a "rolling" deal that keeps him in KC through the early 2030s. But the landscape of Kansas City Chiefs QBs will eventually change.
The challenge now isn't finding a starter; it's managing the cap. When you pay a quarterback $45 million or $50 million a year, you can't afford to keep every superstar. We saw it with the Tyreek Hill trade. We’ll see it again. The quarterback has to be the force multiplier. He has to make "average" receivers look like Pro Bowlers.
Mahomes has proven he can do that. In 2023, with a group of receivers that led the league in drops, he still managed to navigate a path to a Super Bowl win in Las Vegas. That is the hallmark of the elite.
Key Stats Every Fan Should Know
- Most Wins: Patrick Mahomes (passed Len Dawson's 93 wins in record time).
- Most TD Passes in a Season: Mahomes (50 in 2018).
- The "Draft Drought": 30 years between drafting Todd Blackledge in the first round (1983) and Patrick Mahomes (2017).
- Playoff Wins: Mahomes has 15+. The rest of the franchise combined before him? Less than half that.
What You Should Take Away
If you're looking at the history of Kansas City Chiefs QBs, the lesson is clear: patience is a virtue, but aggressive scouting is a necessity. The Chiefs spent decades being "safe." They took the safe veterans. They made the safe trades. It got them winning seasons, but it didn't get them rings.
Taking the risk on a high-ceiling prospect like Mahomes broke the cycle.
For fans and collectors, the "era" of a quarterback matters. The Dawson era was about establishing the AFL's legitimacy. The Green era was about offensive fireworks. The Mahomes era is about global dominance.
Next Steps for Chiefs Enthusiasts:
- Study the All-22: If you want to see why Mahomes is different, watch the coaches' film. Notice how he manipulates safeties with his eyes. It’s a masterclass in psychology.
- Respect the Backups: Keep an eye on the QB2 spot. In the Reid era, the backup is always one play away from a 90-yard drive. Understanding the "Henne Role" or the "Carson Wentz Role" helps you appreciate the depth of the roster.
- Track the Cap: Follow sites like OverTheCap. As Mahomes' contract evolves, the way the Chiefs build the team around him will shift. Watch how they prioritize offensive line talent to protect their billion-dollar asset.
The story of the quarterback in Kansas City used to be a tragedy. Now, it's a blueprint for the rest of the NFL. Just don't expect anyone else to replicate it anytime soon. Turns out, finding a unicorn is actually pretty hard.