He was the "can't-miss" kid. Honestly, when the Arizona Diamondbacks took Justin Upton (often referred to by his full name, Justin Irvin Martin Upton) with the first overall pick in the 2005 MLB Draft, the expectations weren't just high. They were astronomical. People were looking for the next Ken Griffey Jr. or Alex Rodriguez. They saw a teenager from Virginia with lightning in his hands and thought they were witnessing the birth of a deity in a baseball jersey.
Does he get enough credit? Probably not.
Baseball history is a weird, fickle thing. We tend to remember the Hall of Famers and the absolute busts. We forget the guys who were just really, really good for a really long time. Upton falls into that strange middle ground where his career was a massive success by any objective metric, yet because he was a number one overall pick, some folks still act like he left something on the table. It’s a bizarre way to look at 325 home runs.
The Scouting Phenom from Chesapeake
If you were around the scouting scene in the mid-2000s, the name Upton was legendary. His brother, B.J. Upton, had already gone second overall a few years prior. But Justin? Scouts whispered that he was better. He had the "five tools." He was fast, he could throw, he could hit for average, he had raw power, and his defensive ceiling was through the roof.
✨ Don't miss: Who Kansas City Play: The 2026 Schedule and Why It Matters
It didn't take long for him to move. He debuted at 19. Think about that. Most 19-year-olds are figuring out how to do laundry in a college dorm, and Justin Upton was facing major league sliders.
His 2011 season was the peak of the Arizona era. He finished fourth in the MVP voting. He hit 31 homers and stole 21 bases. He was 23 years old. At that moment, it felt like the world was his. But the Diamondbacks were a restless franchise. They traded him to Atlanta in a blockbuster move that changed the trajectory of his career and arguably the organization.
Why the "Inconsistent" Label Stuck
You’ll hear this a lot if you talk to old-school Braves or Tigers fans: "Justin Upton was streaky."
It’s a fair critique, mostly. Upton was a volume producer. He would go on a tear for three weeks where he looked like the best player on the planet, hitting .400 with 10 home runs. Then, he’d disappear for a month. The strikeouts would pile up. The swing would look a little long.
But look at the back of the bubblegum card. The numbers don't lie. Between 2009 and 2019, he was one of the most consistent power threats in the league. He didn't just stumble into four All-Star appearances. He earned them by being a reliable source of 25 to 30 home runs a year.
A lot of the "inconsistency" narrative comes from the fact that he played for five different franchises. Arizona, Atlanta, San Diego, Detroit, and the Angels. When a player moves that much, fans never quite claim them as "theirs." He was a mercenary of sorts. A very productive, very expensive mercenary who gave you Silver Slugger-level production almost every time he put on a new cap.
The Contract and the Later Years
Money changes how we view athletes. When the Tigers gave him a six-year, $132.75 million deal, the pressure shifted. He performed well in Detroit, but by the time he got to the Angels, the injuries started to bark. A toe injury here, a knee issue there.
The end of a career is rarely pretty. In 2022, the Angels released him despite owing him $28 million. It was a cold reminder of how the business works. He had a brief cup of coffee with the Mariners, but the bat speed wasn't quite what it used to be.
What We Get Wrong About the Upton Legacy
The biggest mistake fans make is comparing Justin Upton to an imaginary version of himself. We compare him to the "Perfect #1 Pick." If you stop doing that and just look at the peers of his era, his value becomes obvious.
- He has more career home runs than many Hall of Fame outfielders.
- He was a cornerstone of multiple playoff teams.
- He stayed remarkably durable until his early 30s.
He wasn't Mike Trout. He wasn't Mookie Betts. But he was a Tier-2 superstar for a decade. In a sport where most prospects never even make it to the "Show," that is a monumental achievement.
Actionable Takeaways for Evaluating Careers
When you're looking back at players like Upton, or even current prospects who are struggling with high expectations, keep these points in mind:
- Contextualize the "Bust" Label: Never use the word "bust" for a guy with over 300 home runs. It’s factually illiterate. If a top pick gives you 15 years of MLB service, the pick was a success.
- Look at OPS+: Upton’s career OPS+ sits around 117. That means he was 17% better than the league average hitter for his entire career. Over 7,000+ plate appearances, that is incredibly difficult to do.
- Peak vs. Longevity: Appreciate that Upton provided both. He had a high ceiling (2011) and a very long, productive floor.
- Value the Trade Market: The fact that teams were always willing to trade high-level prospects to get him shows how much professional front offices valued his skill set, even when fans were frustrated by his strikeout rate.
Justin Upton didn't need to be the greatest player of all time to be great. He was a force of nature in the box, a gentleman in the clubhouse, and a player who defined an era of power hitting in the National and American Leagues. Whether he eventually gets some veteran committee love for the Hall of Fame remains to be seen, but his impact on the game is undeniable.