Justin Thomas at Augusta National is a riddle wrapped in a green jacket that he just can't seem to put on. Honestly, if you look at his game, he should be a perennial favorite. He’s got the high ball flight. He’s got the creative hands around the greens. He’s got the "dog" in him that wins majors. Yet, the justin thomas masters history is a weirdly lopsided tale of "almost" followed by some truly head-scratching collapses.
It’s been ten years since his debut in 2016. Since then, we've seen everything from a clinical fourth-place finish to a back-nine implosion that looked more like a weekend hacker’s nightmare than a world-class pro's scorecard.
The Peak: 2020 and the Fourth-Place Finish
People forget how close JT came during the weird, November "COVID Masters" in 2020. The course was soft, the azaleas weren't blooming, and Thomas was absolutely firing. He opened with a 66. He followed it with a 69.
He was right there.
Ultimately, Dustin Johnson went on a historic tear that nobody was stopping, but Thomas finished solo fourth at 12-under par. That remains his best ever result. For a while, it felt like he had finally cracked the code of Augusta’s deceptive slopes. He looked comfortable. He was making putts. It felt like a "when," not an "if."
📖 Related: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
That Brutal 2024 Collapse
If 2020 was the dream, 2024 was the absolute fever dream from hell. You've probably seen the highlights—or lowlights, depending on how much you like the guy.
Heading into the final four holes of his second round, Thomas was sitting at even par. The cut line was drifting toward +5 or +6. He was safe. He was basically already in the clubhouse ordering a sandwich.
Then, the wheels didn't just come off; they exploded.
- 15th Hole: Double bogey after hitting the water.
- 16th Hole: Three-putt double bogey.
- 17th Hole: Bogey.
- 18th Hole: Double bogey.
He played the last four holes in 7-over par. He missed the cut by a single stroke. It was painful to watch. He had just split with his long-time caddie, Jim "Bones" Mackay, a week before the tournament, and the lack of a stabilizing voice in his ear felt glaringly obvious as the round spiraled.
👉 See also: Simona Halep and the Reality of Tennis Player Breast Reduction
A Year-by-Year Look at the Scorecards
To really understand the justin thomas masters history, you have to see the trend. It’s a story of early consistency that has recently turned into a struggle just to see the weekend.
- 2016: T39 (Debut)
- 2017: T22
- 2018: T17
- 2019: T12
- 2020: 4th (Career Best)
- 2021: T21
- 2022: T8
- 2023: MC (Missed Cut)
- 2024: MC (The 7-over finish)
Before 2023, JT had a streak of seven straight made cuts. He was the "safe" bet for a Top 20. But something has shifted in the last two years. The pressure of the career grand slam—he only needs the Masters and the U.S. Open to complete it—seems to weigh heavy on him when he hits Amen Corner.
Why the Struggles?
Expert analysts like Butch Harmon have pointed to Thomas being "too hard on himself." When JT gets frustrated, he moves fast. At Augusta, moving fast is a death sentence. The greens require a level of patience that doesn't always mesh with his aggressive, fiery personality.
His putting has also been a bit of a roller coaster. While his approach play is consistently top-10 on the PGA Tour, his Strokes Gained: Putting numbers have dipped in high-pressure moments. At the 2024 Masters, he uncharacteristically lipped out several short ones that would have saved his round.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
What Needs to Change for 2026?
Looking ahead, the path back to the top 10 for JT involves slowing down. He’s already shown in early 2025 that the form is returning—he had a runner-up finish at the Valspar and several other top-10s. The talent hasn't left him.
Basically, he needs to survive Friday. In both 2023 and 2024, it was the second round that killed him. If he can get through the first 36 holes without a "disasterclass" stretch, his weekend scoring average is actually among the best in the field.
Actionable Insights for Following JT at Augusta:
- Watch the 15th: This hole has become a mental block for him. If he plays it even or better on Thursday/Friday, his confidence usually soars.
- Monitor the Caddie Dynamic: Since moving on from Bones, JT has had to recalibrate his on-course club selection. Look at how much he's talking to his bagman before big shots.
- Check the "Early Season" Stats: JT usually plays well in the Florida swing (The Players, Valspar). If he enters April with a hot putter, he's a legitimate threat again.
The history of Justin Thomas at the Masters isn't finished yet, but the "implosion" narrative is one he'll have to work hard to bury the next time he drives down Magnolia Lane.
Next Steps for Golf Fans:
To get a better feel for his current form, track his Strokes Gained: Around the Green stats during the West Coast and Florida swings this season. This is the best indicator of whether his "Augusta touch" is back. You should also watch his post-round interviews; a calmer, more reflective JT usually performs better at majors than the one who is visibly grinding over every blade of grass.