Let's be real for a second. If you lived through the 2010s, you didn't just hear Justin Bieber’s music—you lived through his dating life. It was everywhere. From the "Jelena" tags on Tumblr to the chaotic Instagram captions that had us all refreshing our feeds at 2 a.m., his romantic history is basically a time capsule of pop culture.
But here is the thing. Most people only remember the big names. They think it’s just a straight line from one superstar to a supermodel. Honestly? It was way messier and more interesting than that. The list of people who carry the Justin Bieber ex gf label is a mix of childhood sweethearts, "it girls," and high-profile models who were often caught in the crossfire of some very public growing pains.
The Jelena Era: More Than Just a "First Love"
We have to start with Selena Gomez. You can't talk about Justin's past without her; it's practically the law. They met in 2009 when they were just kids—Justin was 15 and Selena was 17. Their managers actually set up the meeting, which sounds so business-like for a romance that would eventually break the internet a thousand times over.
By 2011, they were "Instagram official" before that was even a formal term. They made their red carpet debut at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party, and for a few years, they were the golden couple. But the cracks showed early. They broke up for the first time in late 2012, and then it was a whirlwind of "are they or aren't they" for the next six years.
It wasn't just puppy love. Justin later described the relationship as a "marriage kind of thing" where they were way too invested for their age. They fought hard. They loved hard. They even had a brief reconciliation in late 2017, riding bikes and going to church together, before ending it for good in March 2018. Just months later, Justin was engaged to Hailey. Talk about emotional whiplash for the fans.
🔗 Read more: Game of Thrones Actors: Where the Cast of Westeros Actually Ended Up
The Ones You Might Have Forgotten
While the world was obsessed with Selena, there were plenty of other women in the mix. Some were brief flings, others were "just friends" who clearly weren't just friends.
Caitlin Beadles: The First One
Before the fame went stratospheric, there was Caitlin. She’s often called his first real girlfriend. They dated in 2008 when he first moved to Atlanta to work with Usher. Even after they broke up, they stayed close—he even flew to see her after she was in a serious boating accident. It’s one of those rare, wholesome chapters in a usually chaotic history.
Sofia Richie: The Summer of Drama
Remember August 2016? Justin started dating Sofia Richie, who was only 17 at the time. The backlash from fans was so intense that Justin actually deactivated his entire Instagram account. He told fans that if they didn't stop the hate toward Sofia, he was done. Selena Gomez even weighed in on the comments, telling him to stop posting photos of his girlfriend if he couldn't handle the heat. It was peak celebrity messiness. They only lasted about six weeks, but the impact on his social media presence was huge.
The "Church Dates" and Paola Paulin
Around 2017, Justin started getting really public about his faith. This led to a string of dates with actress Paola Paulin. They were spotted at Hillsong Church multiple times. Insiders at the time said he was "smitten," but like many of his relationships during his transition phase, it fizzled out as he focused more on his personal growth and health.
💡 You might also like: Is The Weeknd a Christian? The Truth Behind Abel’s Faith and Lyrics
The Model Phase: From Baskin to Yovanna
Between the "on" and "off" periods with Selena, there was a revolving door of high-fashion connections.
- Yovanna Ventura: They were a thing in 2014. He called her his "sweetheart" on Instagram. Later, she was spotted with The Weeknd right after he broke up with Selena, which felt like some very intentional Hollywood chess.
- Baskin Champion: In early 2018, right after the final Jelena split, Justin was seen with Baskin at a Craig David concert. Rumor has it he was just trying to make Selena jealous. If that was the goal, it definitely got the tabloids talking.
- Chantel Jeffries: She was famously in the car with him during his 2014 DUI arrest in Miami. They reconnected briefly in 2016, but it never seemed to turn into a long-term thing.
Why the "Ex Gf" Narratives Still Matter
It’s easy to dismiss this as gossip, but these relationships shaped the artist he became. You can hear the heartbreak and the regret in albums like Purpose. He was growing up in a fishbowl. Every girl he grabbed coffee with became a global news story.
Most of these women have moved on to massive success. Sofia Richie is now a style icon and a mother. Selena Gomez is an Emmy-nominated actress and billionaire business owner. They aren't just "exes"—they are individuals who survived the intense scrutiny of being attached to the biggest pop star on the planet.
What Really Happened with Hailey?
A lot of people forget that Hailey Bieber was technically a Justin Bieber ex gf before she was his wife. They had a casual, non-exclusive thing in 2015 and 2016. They even did a GQ interview where Justin called her someone he really loved but didn't want to "be held down" by.
📖 Related: Shannon Tweed Net Worth: Why She is Much More Than a Rockstar Wife
Then, they didn't speak for two years. Total radio silence. When they reconnected in June 2018 at a conference in Miami, the spark was different. They went from "exes who don't talk" to "married at a courthouse" in about three months.
Actionable Insights for Following Celeb History:
- Check the Timeline: When looking at his past, always cross-reference the years. Many of these "relationships" overlapped with his breaks from Selena, which explains the constant drama.
- Verify the Source: Much of the 2014-2017 era was fueled by "insider" quotes to E! News and People. Look for direct social media confirmations (or deletions) to see what was actually real.
- Respect the Present: Most of these women are now married or in long-term relationships. While the "Justin Bieber ex gf" label helps in a search engine, their current lives are far removed from the 2012 tabloids.
If you are trying to piece together the full puzzle, start by looking at the music release dates. Usually, a new single meant a new "mystery woman" was about to be spotted by the paparazzi.