Let’s be real for a second. If you look up Justice League Part One today, you’re basically looking at a ghost. It’s this weird, cinematic phantom limb that haunts DC fans whenever a new superhero trailer drops. Back in 2014, when Zack Snyder and Warner Bros. laid out their massive roadmap, this wasn't just a movie; it was supposed to be the North Star of the DCEU.
Then everything changed.
The title itself eventually got swallowed up by a sea of production drama, tragic personal loss, and a studio that completely panicked after Batman v Superman didn’t get the "universal acclaim" they were hunting for. What was originally announced as Justice League Part One basically morphed into the theatrical cut we saw in 2017—which most people agree was a bit of a Frankenstein’s monster—and then later, the four-hour odyssey known as Zack Snyder's Justice League.
The Original Vision vs. The Reality We Got
When Zack Snyder and screenwriter Chris Terrio first started mapping this out, it was massive. We’re talking Kirby-esque, space-opera massive. The plan was to have a two-part epic. Part one was intended to introduce the team and the threat of Steppenwolf, ending on a cliffhanger that would lead directly into a second film where Darkseid turns Earth into a wasteland.
But the studio got cold feet. They saw the "dark and gritty" complaints and decided they wanted more jokes. They wanted a lighter tone. They wanted "fun."
Honestly, it’s kinda fascinating to look back at the 2014 press release. It felt so certain. You had the whole slate: The Flash, Cyborg, Green Lantern Corps. Justice League Part One was the anchor. But by the time cameras actually started rolling in London in 2016, the "Part One" branding was already being hushed up. They started calling it just Justice League. They claimed it was always meant to be a standalone story, but anyone who has read the original scripts knows that wasn't exactly the whole truth.
Why Justice League Part One Became a Production Nightmare
The production was a pressure cooker. You had Zack Snyder trying to maintain his deconstructed take on these gods, while Warner Bros. executives were literally on set, monitoring the humor levels. Imagine trying to paint a masterpiece while three managers are standing over your shoulder suggesting you use more yellow because "people like yellow."
Then the unthinkable happened. Zack Snyder’s daughter, Autumn, passed away.
✨ Don't miss: Do You Believe in Love: The Song That Almost Ended Huey Lewis and the News
Snyder stepped down to be with his family. Enter Joss Whedon. The guy who did The Avengers was brought in to "finish" the film, but what followed was a massive overhaul. Millions of dollars in reshoots. Henry Cavill’s infamous CGI upper lip because he had a mustache for Mission: Impossible – Fallout. The tonal whiplash was enough to give an entire audience migraines.
The movie that was supposed to be Justice League Part One—the first half of a grand myth—was chopped up, lightened, and squeezed into a two-hour runtime because of a mandate from then-CEO Kevin Tsujihara. He wanted those bonuses, and a two-hour movie meant more screenings per day.
The Evolution of the "Snyder Cut"
For years, fans obsessed over the "Snyder Cut." They flew banners over Comic-Con. They used the hashtag #ReleaseTheSnyderCut until it became a cultural phenomenon. And eventually, it worked. HBO Max (now just Max) gave Snyder the budget to finish his version.
Is Zack Snyder’s Justice League technically Justice League Part One? Sorta. It’s more like Parts 1, 2, and 3 of a five-part story condensed into one giant sitting. It restored the Knightmare sequence—that post-apocalyptic future where Superman goes bad after Darkseid kills Lois Lane. This was the stuff that was supposed to bridge the gap between the first and second movies.
Watching it, you see the bones of what the original 2014 plan was. You see the setup for a New Gods war. You see Martian Manhunter showing up at the end. It’s a glimpse into an alternate timeline where the DCEU actually stayed the course instead of rebooting every three years.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Sequel
There's a huge misconception that Justice League Part One was just going to be a "setup" movie with no payoff. If you look at the storyboards that leaked from the Dallas exhibition years ago, the original plan for the sequel was wild.
- Batman and Catwoman were going to have a child.
- The Riddler was going to be the one to solve the Anti-Life Equation.
- The Flash would have to travel back in time (the "Am I too soon?" scene from BvS) to warn Bruce.
This wasn't just another superhero flick. It was an operatic tragedy. But because the first part struggled so much with its identity, the second part was basically vaporized. It’s one of the biggest "What Ifs" in Hollywood history.
The Current State of the Justice League
Fast forward to now. James Gunn is running the show. The "Snyderverse" is officially in the rearview mirror. We’re getting a new Superman, a new Batman, and eventually, a new Justice League.
But the legacy of Justice League Part One lingers. It changed how fans interact with studios. It proved that a vocal enough fanbase can actually force a multi-billion dollar corporation to change its mind. It also served as a cautionary tale about "studio interference." When you try to make a movie by committee, you usually end up with something that pleases nobody.
The irony is that today’s audiences actually seem to crave the long-form storytelling that Snyder was trying to do. We see it in streaming series. We see it in the way the MCU (mostly) used to build toward Infinity War. Snyder was just doing it with a tone that was perhaps a few years ahead of—or behind—what the general public wanted at that exact moment.
Sorting Fact from Fan Theory
If you're digging through old forums, you'll find a lot of junk. People claim there's a "Whedon Cut" that's four hours long (there isn't). Others say Snyder had already filmed the entire second movie (he hadn't).
What we do know is that a massive amount of concept art exists for the continuation of the Justice League Part One storyline. We know that Ben Affleck had written a Batman script that tied into these events, featuring Deathstroke. We know that Ray Fisher’s Cyborg was meant to be the "heart" of the entire franchise.
It’s a bit sad, honestly. Regardless of how you feel about the movies themselves, you have to respect the ambition.
Key Takeaways for the DC Curious
If you're trying to make sense of the mess, here's the deal. Don't look for a DVD that says Justice League Part One. It doesn't exist under that name.
💡 You might also like: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
- The 2017 Version: This is the "theatrical" cut. It's short, weirdly bright, and mostly ignored by the current fandom.
- The 2021 Version: This is the four-hour "Snyder Cut." It's the closest thing we have to the original vision for Part One and the seeds of Part Two.
- The Future: James Gunn’s Superman (2025) is the hard reset.
For anyone who wants to really understand the DNA of this project, you should check out the book Release the Snyder Cut by Sean O’Connell. It breaks down the timeline of the "Part One" announcement to the eventual HBO Max release with a lot of behind-the-scenes detail that clarifies why things fell apart.
The story of this movie is ultimately a story about the tension between art and commerce. It's about a director who had a specific, polarizing vision and a studio that was terrified of not being the next Marvel. In the end, we got a glimpse of greatness, a lot of confusion, and a fan movement that changed the industry forever.
How to Navigate the DC Backlog
If you want to experience the "intended" journey of Justice League Part One, you have to watch the films in a specific order to catch the threads. Start with Man of Steel, then move to the Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (Ultimate Edition)—don't even bother with the theatrical version of that one. After that, go straight into Zack Snyder's Justice League.
Skip the 2017 theatrical cut entirely unless you're a glutton for punishment or really want to see what bad CGI looks like on a $300 million budget.
By following that path, you’ll see the narrative arc that was supposed to define a decade of cinema. You’ll see the setups that were meant to pay off in a sequel that will likely never happen. It's a fascinating look at what could have been a true modern myth, now relegated to the "what if" category of film history.
For those looking to stay updated on where the League goes next under James Gunn, keep an eye on official DC Studios announcements. The days of "Part One" and "Part Two" are over, replaced by a more cohesive, singular vision that hopefully avoids the production hell of the mid-2010s.
Next Steps for DC Fans
- Watch the "Ultimate Edition" of BvS: It restores 30 minutes of plot that makes the setup for Justice League actually make sense.
- Track the "Knightmare" Storyboards: Search for the Jim Lee-illustrated storyboards from the Dallas exhibit to see the planned ending for the trilogy.
- Follow James Gunn’s Threads: If you want to know how the next Justice League will form, his social media is surprisingly transparent about which characters are being established first.