Six years. It’s been more than six years since Tyler Smith, a 23-year-old with everything to live for, was found dead in a drainage ditch in Galesburg, Illinois. Honestly, if you follow true crime, you've probably heard his name on Unsolved Mysteries or Hell and Gone. But for his family, this isn't a "case study" or a podcast episode. It’s a reality that doesn’t have an ending yet.
Tyler wasn't some random guy looking for trouble. He was a Western Illinois University grad and an Army National Guardsman. He had literally just been accepted into the police academy in San Jose, California. Think about that for a second. He was weeks away from starting his dream career as a cop, only to end up face-down in three inches of water in a concrete canal.
The Night Everything Changed in Galesburg
On September 14, 2018, Tyler went out with friends in downtown Galesburg. It was supposed to be a "last hurrah" before his next chapter. They were bar hopping. They were having a good time. But at some point, Tyler got separated from the group.
This is where things get weird.
His phone shows he was walking. He made several calls starting around 11:05 PM. He looked lost. Surveillance footage from a Casey’s General Store caught him walking north toward the railroad tracks at 11:48 PM.
Four minutes later, his phone stopped registering movement.
When he didn't show up for National Guard drills the next morning, people knew something was wrong. His body was found twelve hours later in Cedar Fork Creek. The local police pretty much looked at the scene and decided it was an accidental drowning. Case closed. Move on.
But his mother, Sandra Halsne, wasn't having it. And frankly, neither was anyone else who looked at the details.
Why the "Accidental Drowning" Theory Doesn't Fit
You've got to understand the physical layout of where he was found. To get to that spot in the ditch, Tyler—who was a fit, athletic guy—would have had to climb chain-link fences, cross railroad tracks, and then somehow fall 20 feet into a tiny amount of water.
Does that sound like an accident? Or does it sound like something else?
📖 Related: The US Invasion of Mexico: What Really Happened During the War of 1847
- The Injuries: Independent investigators pointed out bruising on his face.
- The Marks: There were marks on his wrists that looked suspiciously like he’d been handcuffed or bound.
- The Clothes: His clothes were wet, but they weren't "dirty" in the way you'd expect from someone falling 20 feet into a muddy, industrial drainage area.
- The "Blood-Like Substance": Police reports mentioned a "blood-like substance" under his face in the water.
Despite all this, the Galesburg Police Department and the Knox County Coroner didn't call a crime scene technician. They didn't canvass for witnesses. They didn't even keep his clothes as evidence or check for DNA under his fingernails. Basically, they treated it like a routine "drunk guy fell in a hole" situation.
The Push for Justice for Tyler Smith
The family didn't just sit back and cry. They got to work. They hired Mitchell Drake, a retired homicide investigator with 35 years of experience. He spent 170 hours reviewing the case for free because it bothered him so much. His conclusion? Tyler was likely dead before he was thrown over that railing.
Because of the family’s relentless pressure—and that massive $25,000 reward they put up—the Illinois State Police (ISP) Division of Criminal Investigations officially stepped in back in 2020.
That was a huge win. But "stepping in" and "solving" are two different things.
👉 See also: Japan Earthquake: Where Exactly Is the Ground Shaking Right Now?
Investigation updates have been slow. We know the ISP is treating it as an open case. We know they've asked for tips. But as of early 2026, the people responsible for what happened that night in the creek haven't been brought to light.
Why People are Still Talking About This Case
There's a lot of local speculation that Tyler might have run into the wrong people. Some even point to a later case—William Avery in 2020—who was found in a similar way in almost the same spot. Is there a connection? The "Smiley Face Killer" theory often pops up in these discussions, but most experts think that's more internet urban legend than reality.
The real issue here feels like a systemic failure of initial investigation. When the first 48 hours of a death investigation are botched, getting justice for Tyler Smith becomes a marathon, not a sprint.
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of folks assume that because it’s been years, the case is "cold" and dead. That’s not true. The ISP is still active. The family still holds an annual 5K in Tyler’s hometown of Rochelle to keep his name in the news.
The biggest misconception is that Tyler was just too drunk to walk. Yes, he’d been drinking. But he was a National Guardsman. He was a football player. The idea that he’d just tip over a high railing into a ditch and die in a couple of inches of water—without leaving a trail of scuffs or struggle—just doesn't pass the "sniff test" for anyone who has seen the site.
What Can Actually Be Done Now?
If you’re looking to support the cause, it’s not just about sharing a hashtag. It’s about keeping the pressure on the right places.
📖 Related: Is Trump in Office Now? What Most People Get Wrong
- Contact the ISP: The Illinois State Police Zone 2 Investigations is still the lead. If you know anything—even a small detail about who was hanging around the downtown bars or the railroad tracks that night—call 815-632-4010, Ext. 230.
- Support the Foundation: The annual 5K and the "Justice for Tyler Smith" Facebook page are the hubs for the family’s efforts. Money raised often goes back into the community or toward keeping the reward fund alive.
- Spread the Facts: Avoid the wilder conspiracies. Stick to the botched investigation details and the suspicious physical evidence. The more people know how the GPD handled (or mishandled) the start of this, the more likely we are to see accountability.
Tyler Smith was a son, a soldier, and a future officer of the law. He deserved a proper investigation from day one. Since he didn't get that, the least the public can do is make sure his story doesn't fade into the background. There is still a $25,000 reward on the table. Someone in Galesburg knows exactly what happened between 11:48 PM and 11:52 PM.
The truth is usually right there in the gap.
Keep an eye on the Illinois State Police updates and stay vocal on social media. Public pressure is often the only thing that keeps these "stalled" cases moving toward an actual courtroom.