Honestly, it feels like a lifetime ago when the news broke on that Sunday in December 2024. Steve Cohen didn't just open his checkbook; he basically reset the entire economy of Major League Baseball. When the dust settled, Juan Soto and the NY Mets were linked by a staggering 15-year, $765 million contract. It was the kind of number that makes your head spin, even in a world where $300 million deals have become the "standard" for superstars.
Most people saw the headline and thought, "Oh, it's just more than Ohtani." But that's where the misunderstanding starts.
If you look at the actual math, Soto’s deal is a completely different beast compared to Shohei’s. Ohtani took massive deferrals—getting paid $2 million a year now and the rest later. Soto? He’s getting $51 million every single year. No waiting. No inflation protection for the team. Just raw, liquid cash flowing from Cohen’s hedge fund to Soto’s bank account. It’s the largest "real value" contract in the history of sports, and we're finally seeing how that weight sits on a franchise after a full season in Queens.
Why Juan Soto and the NY Mets Didn't "Win" in 2025
You'd think adding a generational talent would be an instant ticket to a parade down the Canyon of Heroes. It wasn't.
The 2025 season was... complicated. On paper, Soto was incredible. He slashed .263/.396/.525 and mashed a career-high 43 home runs. He even did something nobody expected: he stole 38 bases. Seeing a guy who's usually known for a "shuffle" and a walk-rate that defies physics suddenly sprinting around the bags was a trip. But despite those "A+" individual numbers, the Mets finished 83-79. They missed the playoffs entirely.
🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
It’s a tough pill to swallow when you’re paying one guy $51 million.
The reality is that the roster around him crumbled in ways David Stearns couldn't have predicted. The rotation was a mess, and let’s be real, Soto’s defense in right field was, at times, painful to watch. He finished the year with a -12 OAA (Outs Above Average). While his bat is a flamethrower, his glove was sometimes a wet paper bag. That’s the nuance people miss—you aren't paying for a Gold Glover; you’re paying for the best eye at the plate since Ted Williams.
The Numbers That Actually Matter
If you’re obsessed with the stats, here’s how his first year in blue and orange actually shook out:
- Games Played: 160 (The guy is a tank).
- Home Runs: 43 (A new personal best).
- Walks: 127 (Led the majors, naturally).
- OPS: .921.
Even with those numbers, the "Mets being the Mets" narrative persisted because the pitching staff couldn't hold a lead if their lives depended on it. It’s why the 2026 offseason has been so frantic.
💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
The $765 Million Gamble: Is Steve Cohen Overpaying?
A lot of folks look at the 15-year term and cringe. 15 years! Soto will be 41 when this contract ends. But Cohen’s logic, which he shared with Tom Verducci, was pretty straightforward. He saw a 26-year-old hitting the market and realized players like this only appear once a decade. If you wait for the "perfect" deal, you end up with nothing.
There’s an opt-out after year five. That’s the part most fans forget. If Soto continues to play like a Hall of Famer, he could actually walk away at age 31 to try and get another massive bag. Of course, the Mets have a built-in "void" clause where they can add $40 million to the back end to keep him, but it highlights just how much leverage Scott Boras negotiated into this thing.
Moving Into 2026: The Kyle Tucker Factor
Now that we’re in January 2026, the conversation has shifted. The Mets are currently the frontrunners for Kyle Tucker, and the irony is hilarious. Tucker is looking at Soto’s $51 million average annual value (AAV) as the "floor," even though everyone knows he probably won't touch it.
The Mets are basically trying to build a "Death Star" lineup to compensate for the fact that they lost Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz this winter. It’s a risky strategy. You’re putting so much capital into two or three guys that the rest of the roster has to be filled with league-minimum "hope-and-pray" types or aging veterans on one-year flyers.
📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
What fans should actually watch for this season:
- The Move to Left Field: There’s been a ton of talk about moving Soto to left field to hide his defensive limitations. If they sign a guy like Lane Thomas or keep a defensive specialist in right, it might save the Mets 10-15 runs a year.
- The Groundball Rate: Early in 2025, Soto was hitting everything into the dirt (nearly 60% groundball rate). He fixed it in the second half. If he starts 2026 hitting 40% fly balls, he might actually hit 50 homers in Citi Field.
- The Protection: Without Pete Alonso behind him, who protects Soto? If teams can just pitch around him and walk him 150 times, his value drops because nobody is there to drive him in.
The Bottom Line on the Soto Era
The marriage between Juan Soto and the NY Mets is more than just a sports transaction. It’s a statement of intent from the wealthiest owner in the game. Even if 2025 was a disappointment in the standings, Soto proved he could handle the New York spotlight. He didn't shrink. He didn't crumble under the weight of the $765 million. He just went out, took his walks, and hit his tanks.
For the Mets to actually turn this into a championship, they have to stop treating Soto like a finished puzzle and start treating him like the first piece of a much larger one.
Next Steps for Following the Situation:
- Monitor the Kyle Tucker negotiations: If the Mets land Tucker, the protection issues for Soto disappear instantly.
- Track the defensive metrics: Watch the OAA (Outs Above Average) stats in the first two months of 2026; if Soto is still in the bottom 5th percentile, a move to DH or Left Field is inevitable.
- Check the "Contract Void" rumors: Keep an ear out for any rumblings about the Mets already looking to restructure or extend the "opt-out" protection to avoid a 2029 bidding war.