Fantasy football is a game of "what if," and Josh Palmer is the king of that hill. Honestly, if you’ve been holding him in dynasty leagues, you’ve probably felt like a person waiting for a train that already left the station. Or maybe it’s just delayed. Again.
There was a time when josh palmer fantasy dynasty value was the ultimate "sleepy" asset. People pointed at his 2022 season—72 catches for 769 yards—as the definitive proof that he was a WR2 in waiting. He was the guy who stepped up when Keenan Allen and Mike Williams were hurt. Then he went to Buffalo. We thought the Josh Allen connection would be the spark.
It wasn't.
The 2025 season was a bucket of cold water. Palmer finished with just 22 catches over 12 games in Buffalo. He didn't even find the end zone once. While Khalil Shakir and Keon Coleman took over the lion's share of targets, Palmer looked like a depth piece that wandered onto the wrong side of the fantasy map.
The Buffalo Disappointment and Reality Check
Why did it go so wrong? Basically, the Bills' receiver room became a hodgepodge. You had Shakir dominating the slot, Coleman developing as the X, and a rotation of guys like Tyrell Shavers and Brandin Cooks getting snaps. Palmer was out there—he played 84% of the snaps in the Week 18 win over the Jets—but he had one catch. One.
That’s the Josh Palmer experience in a nutshell. High snap share, low impact.
💡 You might also like: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
In dynasty, we often confuse "opportunity" with "talent." Just because a guy is on the field doesn't mean he's earning targets. Palmer’s target rate in 2025 was a measly 16.6%. Compare that to the elite guys who hover around 25-30%, and you see the problem. He’s a "connector" in a real-life offense, not a focal point for your fantasy team.
Breaking Down the Contract Situation
If you're looking for a silver lining, it’s the money. Buffalo didn't bring him in for peanuts. He signed a three-year, $30 million deal (with upside to $36 million) in 2025. That’s a significant investment.
- 2026 Cap Hit: $11.85 million.
- Guaranteed Money: He has $4.84 million of his 2026 salary fully guaranteed, and another $3 million triggers if he’s on the roster in mid-March.
- Dead Cap: If the Bills cut him before June 1, 2026, they eat $11.24 million in dead money.
What does this mean for his josh palmer fantasy dynasty outlook? He isn't going anywhere. The Bills are financially committed to him through at least the 2026 season. In a world where roster spots are gold, knowing a guy has "job security" is something, even if the production hasn't followed yet.
Why We Keep Falling for the Post-Hype Sleeper Narrative
It’s easy to look at Palmer and see the physical tools. He’s 6'1", 210 pounds, and he’s shown he can win on the outside. In 2023 and 2024, he averaged over 15 yards per reception. He has "big play" potential written all over him.
But dynasty managers are getting tired.
📖 Related: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
The "post-hype sleeper" label only works for so long. Eventually, you’re just "post-hype." Most experts currently rank him around the WR85 to WR90 range in dynasty. He’s essentially a throw-in for larger trades. If you're starting him in a 12-team league, things have gone horribly wrong for your roster.
The truth is, Palmer is a victim of his own versatility. Because he can play the X, the Z, and some slot, coaches love him for depth. He can fill any hole. But for fantasy, we want the guy who does one thing so well that the quarterback has to look his way. Palmer doesn't demand the ball. He waits for it. And Josh Allen has plenty of other places to go.
Comparing Palmer to Other Dynasty Assets
If you have Palmer on your roster, you're likely wondering if you should swap him for a draft pick or a younger flyer. Let's look at the landscape:
- Ladd McConkey: His former teammate in LA. McConkey has already lapped Palmer in terms of targets and consistency. It's not even a conversation anymore.
- Keon Coleman: The younger, more athletic version of what Palmer was supposed to be in Buffalo. Coleman is the future; Palmer is the bridge.
- Late Round Rookies: Honestly, a 2026 3rd-round pick might have more "upside" than Palmer at this stage.
Actionable Strategy for Dynasty Managers
So, what do you actually do with him?
If you own him, you can’t sell him for much. A 2026 4th-round pick? Maybe. You’re better off holding him through the 2026 preseason. If he has one big "hype" game or an injury happens to Keon Coleman, that’s your window to exit.
👉 See also: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
If you don't own him, don't go looking for him. There are better dart throws on the waiver wire—guys like Tyrell Shavers or even deep-stash rookies who haven't hit their ceiling yet. Palmer has shown us his ceiling, and it's a room with very low rafters.
The Move to Make Now:
Check your league's trade block. If someone is desperate for WR depth because of injuries heading into the 2026 season, package Palmer with a 3rd-round pick to move up into the 2nd round. Use his name value and his "starting role" in Buffalo to upgrade your draft capital.
The window for Josh Palmer to be a fantasy star hasn't just closed; it’s been painted shut. He's a solid NFL player, but in the world of josh palmer fantasy dynasty rankings, he's a roster-clogger. Don't let the "Josh Allen factor" trick you into holding him until his value hits zero.
Next Steps:
- Identify the Keon Coleman or Khalil Shakir owner in your league.
- Offer Palmer as a "handcuff" or "insurance" for a 2026 3rd-round pick.
- Scour the waiver wire for 2nd-year WRs with higher target-per-route-run (TPRR) metrics to replace his roster spot.