If you watch the Buffalo Bills on a Sunday, you’re basically watching a science experiment in human physics. Josh Allen shouldn't be able to do what he does. At 6-foot-5 and roughly 237 pounds, he moves like a linebacker but throws like he has a literal cannon for an arm. But beyond the eye test, the stat sheet is getting weird. Like, "historically impossible" weird.
People love to argue about MVPs and Super Bowls, but the numbers don't really care about your Twitter debates. Honestly, we’ve reached a point where Josh Allen: only QB in NFL history is a phrase that pops up every single time he steps onto the turf. He isn't just breaking records; he is inventing new categories of productivity that didn't exist when guys like Dan Marino or Joe Montana were playing.
The Five-Year Streak Nobody Can Touch
Let's talk about the big one. The "40 Club."
Coming into the 2024 season, everyone was wondering if Allen could keep up his insane pace. He didn't just keep it up; he shattered the ceiling. By the end of the 2024 regular season, Josh Allen became the first player in NFL history to record five consecutive seasons with 40 or more total touchdowns.
Think about that for a second. To get to 40 touchdowns once is a career year for most "elite" quarterbacks. To do it five times in a row? That’s unheard of.
Even the greats couldn't stay that consistent. Drew Brees managed a three-year streak. Aaron Rodgers has six such seasons in his entire career, but they weren't back-to-back like this. It’s the ultimate proof of his dual-threat nature. If the passing lanes are clogged, he just runs it in. If the box is stacked, he launches a 60-yard missile.
👉 See also: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
Why the "Dual-Threat" Label is Actually an Understatement
Usually, when we say a guy is a dual-threat, we mean he's fast. We mean he’s Lamar Jackson or Michael Vick. But Allen is a different kind of problem.
In late 2025, during a gritty Week 13 win against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Allen officially took the throne. He scored his 76th career rushing touchdown, surpassing the legendary Cam Newton for the most rushing touchdowns by a quarterback in NFL history.
And he did it much faster than Cam.
- Cam Newton: 75 rushing TDs in 148 games.
- Josh Allen: 76+ rushing TDs in significantly fewer games (reached 79 by end of 2025).
It’s not just about the total volume, though. It’s the combination. We’re looking at a guy who has 200+ passing touchdowns and nearly 80 rushing touchdowns before he even turns 30. That shouldn't be possible. He also holds the record for the most games with both a passing and a rushing touchdown. He hit his 50th game with that stat line in late 2025—another "only QB in NFL history" moment.
The 2024 MVP Campaign and the "Turnover" Myth
There was always this narrative that Josh Allen was a "sugar high" quarterback. You know the vibe—lots of big plays, but lots of interceptions. Well, 2024 basically killed that talking point.
✨ Don't miss: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Allen finished that season with 41 total touchdowns and only 8 turnovers. That is surgical. He led the Bills to an AFC East title by Week 13 (the earliest since 2009) and beat two 14-win teams in the same season. No other team has ever done that.
The most "Josh Allen" stat from that year? He became the first QB to ever record a passing, rushing, and receiving touchdown in a single game. He’s basically playing Madden on Rookie mode while the rest of the league is on All-Madden.
Surpassing the Legends
We grew up hearing about Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. Those guys were the gold standard for "early career" success.
But look at the first seven seasons. When you stack them up, Allen actually has more total touchdowns (262) than Mahomes, Manning, or Marino had in that same window. He also has the most wins (76) and total yards (30,595) through a player's first seven seasons.
It’s weird to think about because the Bills haven't grabbed that elusive Super Bowl ring yet. Critics use that to downplay the stats. But from a pure "what can one human do on a football field" perspective, we haven't seen this before.
🔗 Read more: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
He’s the only player with 35+ total touchdowns in four straight seasons. Then he made it five. He’s the first QB with 6+ rushing scores in seven straight years. The list just keeps going.
What Most People Get Wrong About His Longevity
There's this fear that he’s going to "break" because of how he plays. People said the same thing about Cam Newton. And yeah, Cam’s body eventually gave out.
But Allen's 2025 season showed a shift. He’s still a "bull," as some analysts call him, but his pocket presence has evolved. He’s taking fewer unnecessary hits while still maintaining that 1.6 rushing touchdowns per game average.
If he stays on this trajectory, he won’t just hold the QB rushing record; he might start threatening the all-time touchdown records held by the "statues" who never left the pocket.
Actionable Takeaways for Football Fans
If you're tracking Allen's career or looking for how this changes the game, keep an eye on these specific milestones:
- The 30th Birthday Factor: Allen turns 30 in May 2026. Watch his rushing volume in the 2026 season. If it doesn't drop, he's on pace to set a rushing TD record that might never be broken by any position, let alone a QB.
- The "Consecutive 40" Watch: Every year he hits 40 total TDs now is just adding to a record that literally no one else is even close to touching.
- Fantasy Football Value: Despite the "turnover" narratives, his floor remains the highest in the league because of those goal-line carries. He is the "vulture" and the "star" all in one.
Josh Allen isn't just a great player in 2026; he's a statistical anomaly that is forcing us to rewrite what we think is possible for the position.
Next Steps for Deep Stats: Check the official NFL Research database for the "Games with 3+ Pass TDs and 1+ Rush TD" category. Allen recently broke a tie with Tom Brady and Drew Brees for the most such games ever (11). Tracking this specific metric is the best way to see if his dual-threat production is slowing down as he enters his 30s.