Baseball is a weird, cruel business. One day you’re hitting 100 mph on the radar gun and looking like the future of a bullpen, and the next, you’re clearing out a locker in Fenway Park because you couldn’t find the strike zone with a map and a flashlight. That’s basically the story of Jorge Alcala Red Sox tenure. It was short. It was high-velocity. And ultimately, it was a reminder that throwing hard doesn't mean much if you're serving up meatballs to big-league hitters.
The Red Sox thought they found a diamond in the rough when they traded for Alcala in June 2025. They needed help. Their bullpen was gassed, leading the majors in innings pitched at several points, and the front office was desperate for an arm that could miss bats. They sent Andy Lugo to the Minnesota Twins to get him. It felt like a low-risk, high-reward move at the time.
What Went Wrong With Jorge Alcala and the Red Sox?
Craig Breslow, the Red Sox Chief Baseball Officer, loves "stuff." He’s a former pitcher himself, so he looks for the metrics that scream potential. Alcala had that. His fastball averaged 97.1 mph, and he had a slider that was once one of the best in the American League. But potential doesn't win games in the AL East.
The honeymoon period was actually pretty decent. People forget that. From mid-June through most of July 2025, Alcala looked like he might actually stick. He appeared in 14 games and allowed exactly one earned run. His ERA during that stretch was a microscopic 0.69. Fenway fans were starting to think they’d fleeced the Twins.
Then came the collapse. It wasn't gradual; it was a cliff.
In his final five appearances for Boston, Alcala was essentially a batting practice pitcher. He got shelled for five earned runs in just 3.3 innings. The most damning part? He gave up four home runs in that tiny window. You can’t survive in the bullpen if you're giving up a long ball every single inning. On August 5, 2025, the Red Sox decided they'd seen enough and designated him for assignment.
The Stats That Defined His Stay
If you look at the raw numbers, his 3.31 ERA in Boston doesn't look "DFA-worthy." But ERA for a reliever is a dirty liar. His FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) was way higher, which basically means he was getting lucky until he wasn't.
He walked 10.5% of the hitters he faced in a Red Sox uniform. That’s a dangerous game to play. When you pair those walks with the fact that he was allowing 2.20 home runs per nine innings, it’s a recipe for a blown lead. His slider, which used to be his bread and butter, was getting hammered for a .389 average. Honestly, it’s hard to stay in the Bigs when your secondary pitch is that predictable.
The Trade That Didn't Age Well
When Boston traded Andy Lugo for Alcala, the hope was that pitching coach Andrew Bailey could "fix" him. Bailey has a reputation for being a whisperer for struggling arms. But Alcala's issues seemed deeper than just a mechanical tweak.
There was a specific game against the Kansas City Royals on August 4, 2025, that felt like the final nail. Alcala came in and gave up two home runs and a double in just a third of an inning. It was ugly. It forced Alex Cora to burn high-leverage arms like Aroldis Chapman in a game that should have been a blowout. When a "low-leverage" guy starts making the "high-leverage" guys work harder, he's usually gone the next morning.
Where is Jorge Alcala now?
After the Red Sox dumped him, the St. Louis Cardinals took a flyer on him. That didn't go great either—he finished his 2025 stint there with a 5.02 ERA. By November, the Cardinals non-tendered him, making him a free agent.
Fast forward to right now, early 2026. Alcala is currently in the Toronto Blue Jays organization. He signed a minor league deal in December 2025. He's a "depth" guy now. He'll likely start the season in Triple-A Buffalo, hoping to show he can still throw strikes consistently enough to merit another shot at the majors.
Lessons from the Jorge Alcala Experiment
The Jorge Alcala Red Sox era was a classic case of chasing "pure stuff" over "pitchability." Boston took a swing at a guy with a 100 mph arm and missed. It happens. But for a team that is trying to compete with the Yankees and Orioles, these "reclamation projects" have to start hitting at a higher rate.
If you’re a Red Sox fan looking for what's next, keep an eye on David Sandlin. The team is trying to convert him into a high-octane reliever, and he might be the homegrown version of what they hoped Alcala would be.
📖 Related: Who Won Last Night's Notre Dame Game? The Reality Behind a Brutal Saturday
Key Takeaways for Fans
- Velocity isn't everything: Alcala proved that 97 mph is very hittable if it's straight and in the middle of the plate.
- Watch the FIP, not the ERA: Relievers can hide behind a low ERA for a few weeks, but the underlying numbers usually catch up.
- Roster flexibility is king: The Red Sox didn't hesitate to move on once Alcala became a liability, showing that Breslow is willing to admit a mistake early rather than letting it fester.
The reality is that Alcala will probably bounce around a few more teams because of that arm. Coaches always think they can be the one to solve the puzzle. For the Red Sox, the puzzle remained unsolved.
If you want to track how the Boston bullpen is shaping up for the 2026 season, you should check the latest roster updates on SoxProspects or the official MLB transaction log, as the team has been aggressive in moving on from the "Alcala-style" gambles in favor of more consistent strike-throwers.