Jordan Poole is basically the wild card of the hobby. One minute he’s the "Third Splash Brother" helping the Golden State Warriors hoist a trophy, and the next, he’s leading a struggling squad in D.C. before landing with the New Orleans Pelicans. If you've been holding a jordan poole rookie card, you know the emotional rollercoaster is real.
It’s not just about the stats. It’s about the narrative. In 2022, everyone was convinced Poole was the next superstar. Prices for his Prizm Silvers and high-end National Treasures cards went through the roof. Then, the Draymond Green punch happened, the trade to Washington followed, and the market for his cards didn't just dip—it cratered. But honestly? That’s exactly why collectors are circling back now in early 2026.
The Reality of Jordan Poole Rookie Card Prices in 2026
Market fatigue is a funny thing. After the hype died, Poole became "the guy people love to meme." For a card investor, that’s actually a signal. While his 2025-26 season with the Pelicans hasn't been a scoring title run—averaging around 17.3 points per game—he's shown flashes of that elite efficiency again.
If you look at the 2019-20 Panini Prizm #272, which is essentially the "base" rookie for everyone, you can pick up a PSA 10 for a fraction of what it cost three years ago. We’re talking under $60 for a Gem Mint Prizm Silver in some auctions. Compare that to the $500+ tags we saw during the 2022 Finals run. It's a massive gap.
The high-end stuff still commands respect, though. A 2019 National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto (RPA) numbered to 99 is still a four-figure card. Why? Because the supply is fixed. Collectors who believe in a "redemption arc" for Poole are quietly stashing these away while the casual fans are looking at the next draft class.
💡 You might also like: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
Why the 2019-20 Set is Special
That 2019 draft class was top-heavy with Zion Williamson and Ja Morant. Poole was a late first-rounder, pick 28. Because of that, his cards weren't the "chase" cards at the beginning of the year.
- Prizm Silver: The gold standard. If you want liquidity, this is the one.
- Optic Rated Rookie: Collectors love the "on-card" look of the Holos.
- Select Concourse/Premier/Courtside: These have three different tiers. The Courtside (the rarest) is the one that actually holds value when the market gets shaky.
- Mosaic NBA Debut: Often seen as a "budget" alternative, but the Genesis parallels are incredibly tough to pull.
What Most People Get Wrong About Investing in Poole
A lot of people think a player's card value is a direct 1:1 reflection of their points per game. It’s not. If it were, Jordan Poole rookie card values would be higher right now. Card value is about cultural relevance and team success.
Being on the Pelicans in 2026 puts him in a weird spot. He’s a secondary or tertiary option behind their main stars. In Washington, he had the "green light," but the team was losing, so the cards didn't move. In New Orleans, he’s winning more, but his usage is lower. It's a trade-off.
You've got to watch the "clutch" moments. Poole is a rhythm player. If he has a 40-point game in the playoffs, the "I told you so" crowd rushes back to eBay. That’s when you see the 20% spikes overnight.
📖 Related: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
Grading vs. Raw: The Hidden Trap
Buying raw Jordan Poole cards on secondary markets is risky business. The 2019 Prizm set was notorious for centering issues. You’ll see a card that looks "clean" but has a 60/40 left-to-right centering. That’s the difference between a PSA 10 and a PSA 9.
In today’s market, the "PSA 9 floor" is very low. Unless it’s a rare parallel like a Mojo or a Gold Prizm, a grade of 9 often sells for the same price as a raw card plus the grading fee. It’s almost always better to buy the 10 or just stay raw if you’re looking for a quick flip.
The "Post-Warriors" Effect
Let’s be real: the Warriors' fan base is huge. When Poole left San Francisco, he lost a massive chunk of "team collectors" who only buy Warriors players. He hasn't fully captured the New Orleans market yet.
However, there is a weird sub-sect of collectors who only collect "championship contributors." Because Poole has a ring and played a massive role in getting it, his cards will always have a baseline of interest that players like Trae Young or LaMelo Ball don't have yet. He’s done it on the biggest stage. That matters for long-term "legacy" value.
👉 See also: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
Actionable Strategy for Collectors
If you're looking to get into the Jordan Poole market, don't just buy every base card you see. Be surgical.
First, look for 2019-20 Optic Holos. They look better than Prizm and have a lower pop report in high grades. Second, keep an eye on the Select Tie-Dye or Zebra parallels. These are "short-printed" and much harder to find than the standard Silvers.
Lastly, check the "sold" listings on eBay and Filter by "Auction" rather than "Buy It Now." You can often snag a Jordan Poole rookie card for 30% less if you’re willing to wait out an auction that ends at 2:00 AM on a Tuesday.
The window for "cheap" Poole cards is wide open, but it only stays that way as long as he’s a "role player." If he finds that 2022 spark again, these prices will feel like a total steal. Focus on the rare parallels and graded 10s of the core brands like Prizm and Optic to protect your downside.