Let’s be real. Jon Jones has never actually been beaten inside an octagon.
If you look at his professional record, there’s that one pesky "1" in the loss column, right next to a sea of wins and a couple of weird "no contests." But anyone who watched the night of December 5, 2009, knows the truth. Jon Jones didn't lose a fight to Matt Hamill. He lost a fight to a prehistoric, misunderstood, and frankly nonsensical piece of the Unified Rules of Mixed Martial Arts. We're talking about the Jon Jones 12 6 elbow—the most controversial foul in the history of the sport.
It was The Ultimate Fighter: Heavyweights Finale. Jones was a young, lanky phenom with wrestling that looked like it belonged in a video game. He took Hamill down and just started melting him. It was a mismatch. Then, in the heat of a ground-and-pound flurry, Jones dropped a series of vertical, straight-down elbows.
Referee Steve Mazzagatti stepped in. The crowd thought it was over. It was over, but not how anyone expected. Because those specific elbows followed a straight line from "12 o'clock to 6 o'clock," Jones was disqualified.
Why the 12 6 Elbow Even Exists (And Why It’s Dumb)
You might wonder why a sport that allows you to kick a man in the ribs or choke him unconscious draws the line at the direction of an elbow. The history of this rule is basically a game of "telephone" mixed with old-school martial arts myths.
When the Unified Rules were being drafted in the late 90s, regulators in New Jersey were watching old martial arts demonstrations. They saw guys breaking stacks of ice blocks with vertical downward strikes. They thought, "Man, if that can break four inches of ice, it’ll definitely kill a human being." Seriously. That was the logic. There was no medical study. No kinetic energy analysis. Just a group of suits getting spooked by a karate demonstration.
The Jon Jones 12 6 elbow became the poster child for this absurdity because it was applied so inconsistently. If Jones had angled his arm just ten degrees to the side, it would have been a "diagonal" strike and perfectly legal. The physics wouldn't have changed much. The damage to Matt Hamill wouldn't have changed much. But because it was a straight vertical line? Disqualification.
The Mazzagatti Factor
We have to talk about Steve Mazzagatti. Dana White has spent over a decade publicly trashing the guy, and this fight is the primary reason.
📖 Related: Louisiana vs Wake Forest: What Most People Get Wrong About This Matchup
When Jones landed the strikes, Hamill was already essentially finished. He had a dislocated shoulder from a previous takedown and was just covering up. After the elbows landed, Mazzagatti paused the fight. Here is where it gets weird: Hamill had his eyes closed because he was leaking blood and hurt. Mazzagatti asked him if he could continue. Hamill is deaf. He couldn't hear the question.
Because Hamill didn't respond, the ref assumed he was incapacitated specifically by the illegal fouls, rather than the three minutes of legal beating he’d just endured.
The Kinetic Myth vs. Reality
If you ask a physicist about the Jon Jones 12 6 elbow, they’ll probably laugh. There is no scientific evidence that a vertical elbow carries more lethal force than a horizontal one. In fact, many fighters argue that a horizontal "slicing" elbow is much more dangerous because it catches the skin and creates massive lacerations that stop fights via TKO.
Jones wasn't using the "ice break" technique. He was in a mounted position, using gravity and his long reach to create downward pressure. It’s effective, sure. But is it more dangerous than a roundhouse kick to the temple? Not even close.
For years, fans and pundits like Joe Rogan have campaigned to have this rule removed. They argue it’s an artifact of a time when the sport was trying to prove it wasn't "human cockfighting." Now that MMA is a global, multi-billion dollar business, keeping a rule based on ice-breaking myths feels... well, it feels amateur.
The Push to Overturn the Record
Recently, there’s been a massive shift in how the MMA world views this. With the Association of Boxing Commissions (ABC) finally voting to lift the ban on the 12-6 elbow in 2024, the conversation around the Jon Jones 12 6 elbow DQ has reignited.
Dana White has been vocal about working with the Nevada State Athletic Commission to get that loss overturned to a "No Contest."
👉 See also: Lo que nadie te cuenta sobre los próximos partidos de selección de fútbol de jamaica
If that happens, Jon Jones officially becomes the only fighter in history to navigate a twenty-year career at the highest level without a single legitimate loss. That’s insane. Whether you like the guy or not, the stats are the stats. The only thing that ever truly beat Jon Jones was a rulebook that didn't understand physics.
Impact on the "GOAT" Debate
When people argue about who the Greatest of All Time is—Jones, GSP, Anderson Silva, or Khabib—the "loss" to Hamill is always brought up by the haters.
"He's not undefeated," they say.
Technically, they're right. But it's a "well, actually" kind of right. It’s a technicality that ignores the reality of what happened in the cage. Hamill himself has said he didn't feel like he won that fight. When the guy who got the "W" acknowledges it was a fluke, the rest of us should probably listen.
What This Means for Future Fighters
Now that the rules have changed, we’re seeing a new generation of fighters training these vertical strikes. They’re great for breaking through a high guard when an opponent is pinned against the fence.
But for Jones, the damage—to his record, at least—was done long ago. He spent the peak of his career having to explain away a disqualification that shouldn't have happened.
Honestly, the Jon Jones 12 6 elbow situation taught the MMA world a lot about the need for better officiating and more scientific rule-making. It showed that a referee’s lack of awareness (like asking a deaf fighter a verbal question) can change the legacy of an athlete forever.
✨ Don't miss: Listen to Dodger Game: How to Catch Every Pitch Without a Cable Bill
Lessons from the Chaos
If you're a fighter or a student of the game, there are a few things to take away from the Jones/Hamill debacle:
- Know the specific commission rules. Even if they’re stupid. Even if they’re about to change. If you're fighting in a jurisdiction where a certain move is banned, you can't use it. Period.
- The "Rule of 45 Degrees." For years, fighters were taught to "angle" their elbows. Even a slight tilt makes a 12-6 elbow legal. It’s a silly game of semantics, but it keeps your win bonus in your pocket.
- Context matters. The reason Jones got DQ'd wasn't just the strike; it was the perception that the strike ended the fight. If Hamill had gotten up and kept fighting, Jones likely would have just been docked a point.
The Final Verdict on the 12 6 Elbow
The Jon Jones 12 6 elbow isn't a story about a dirty fighter. It's a story about a sport’s growing pains.
MMA used to be the Wild West. Then it became overly regulated by people who didn't understand it. Now, we’re finally reaching a middle ground where the rules are starting to reflect the actual mechanics of combat.
Jones is currently at the tail end of his career. He’s moved to Heavyweight, he’s won more titles, and he’s dealt with plenty of his own self-inflicted drama outside the cage. But that night in 2009 remains the biggest "what if" in terms of his professional standing.
If you want to truly understand the sport, you have to look past the record. You have to look at the footage. Jones was dominant. The rules were flawed. The referee was confused. It was a perfect storm of nonsense that resulted in the most famous "1" in sports history.
To stay ahead of how these rules continue to evolve in modern MMA, keep an eye on the unified rule updates for 2025 and 2026. The 12-6 elbow is officially a relic of the past in many jurisdictions now. If you're training, start incorporating vertical strikes into your bag work—just make sure your local commission has caught up with the times before you let them fly in a real bout.
The best way to respect the history of the Jon Jones 12 6 elbow is to make sure we never let a "paper loss" define a fighter's legacy again. Check your local athletic commission’s handbook before your next sanctioned event to see if the "New Rules" are in effect, as the rollout across different states is still ongoing. Managing your cage position to avoid "accidental" verticality is still a high-level skill worth mastering, regardless of the rule change.