If you’ve spent any time in the toy aisle at Walmart over the last few years, you’ve seen her. The blonde side-pony. The oversized bow. The 18-inch frame that looks suspiciously like an American Girl doll but costs about a third of the price.
The JoJo Siwa My Life doll isn't just another piece of plastic merch. It’s a weirdly specific cultural artifact from the peak of the Siwanator era. Honestly, while JoJo herself has moved on to "Karma" and a much more adult aesthetic, these dolls are still circulating on the secondary market like crazy. Parents love them because they don't break the bank. Kids love them because they get to live out their pop star fantasies without needing a Netflix deal.
But there’s a lot of confusion about what these dolls actually are. Is it an American Girl? Is it just a cheap knockoff? Let’s get into the weeds of what makes this doll tick.
What Really Happened With the JoJo Siwa My Life Doll?
Basically, the My Life As brand (which is a Walmart exclusive) partnered with Nickelodeon to release a line of dolls based on JoJo. These weren't just random dolls with bows slapped on them. They were designed to represent specific moments in her career.
You’ve got the 2017 OG version that came with her dog, BowBow. Then came the 2018 "Selfie Stick" version. In 2019, they dropped the "Dance Party" doll. By the time 2021 rolled around, we saw the "Pop Star" iteration with that iconic rainbow faux-fur jacket.
Most people don't realize that these dolls are technically "licensed reproductions." This means the quality is a step above your average dollar-store fashion doll, but they still have that "playline" feel. The bodies are soft torso with plastic limbs. The eyes open and close—a feature that always feels a little creepy to some, but kids usually find it "realistic."
The 18-Inch Comparison: Is It Actually "Good"?
I’ve seen people argue about this on Reddit for hours.
👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
If you put a JoJo Siwa My Life doll next to an American Girl doll, you’ll notice the differences immediately. The My Life doll has a rotating neck, which is actually a pretty cool feature that AG dolls lack. It makes for much better "posing" if your kid is into taking doll photos for Instagram.
However, the hair is "rooted" rather than a wig. If you don't know what that means: it's plugged directly into the scalp. Over time, rooted hair gets frizzy faster than a high-quality wig. If your kid is rough with a hairbrush, JoJo might end up looking like she just finished a 3-hour concert in a hurricane.
The clothes are a major selling point. Most 18-inch doll clothes are interchangeable. You can take a $40 outfit from the American Girl store and stick it on your $35 JoJo doll. It works perfectly.
The Varieties You’ll Find Today
Since these aren't always sitting on store shelves in 2026, you're likely looking at eBay or Mercari. Here’s a quick breakdown of what to look for so you don't get scammed.
- The 2017 Bomber Jacket Edition: This one is the "holy grail" for collectors. It came with a plush BowBow and a silver bomber jacket. If you find one New In Box (NIB), expect to pay a premium.
- The 2018 Unicorn Sweater Set: Very "Peak JoJo." It came with a selfie stick and a purse. It captures that 2018 YouTube energy perfectly.
- The 2019 Dance Party Doll: This version moved toward more athletic gear and was focused on her tour.
- The Pop Star (Rainbow Fur) Doll: Probably the most visually striking. The jacket is super soft, and she comes with stick-on earrings.
One thing that's kinda funny? Some people actually buy these just to "rebody" them. They take the JoJo head and put it on a more articulated body from a different brand. It’s a whole subculture.
Why the Secondary Market Is So Wild
Honestly, the pricing is all over the place. I’ve seen people trying to sell a used JoJo Siwa My Life doll for $80 when it originally retailed for around $35.
✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
Don't do that.
Unless it's a rare, unopened 2017 edition with the dog, you shouldn't be paying triple digits. Most of these are still "play-quality." If the hair is matted or the joints are loose, it’s worth maybe $15 to $20.
The reason the price spikes is purely nostalgia and the fact that Walmart doesn't restock the older versions. When a specific outfit becomes "rare," people lose their minds.
A Quick Warning on Quality
Let's be real: these dolls have some known issues.
- The Arm Socket: There are plenty of reports of the arms popping out if they're pulled too hard.
- The Feet: They are slightly smaller than American Girl feet. This means some AG shoes won't stay on, while others fit like a glove. It’s a trial-and-error situation.
- The Skin Tone: The vinyl can sometimes have a slightly grayish or "plasticky" undertone compared to the warmer tones of more expensive brands.
How to Care for Your JoJo Doll
If you managed to snag one, you want it to last.
First off, stop using a human hairbrush. The oils from your skin and the harsh bristles will ruin the synthetic hair. Use a wire-bristle wig brush. It’s a $5 investment that saves the doll's life.
🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
If the hair gets "the frizzies," you can actually do a "boil wash." It sounds terrifying, but dipping the hair in hot (not boiling!) water and combing it out can reset the synthetic fibers. Just don't melt her face.
Pro Tip: If the doll’s limbs get loose and she can't stand up anymore, you can actually "re-string" her. There are plenty of tutorials online. It involves opening the torso and tightening the elastic cords. It sounds like surgery, but it’s basically just arts and crafts.
What to Do Next
If you're looking to buy a JoJo Siwa My Life doll right now, check the local Facebook Marketplace first. Shipping an 18-inch doll is expensive because they're heavy and require large boxes. You can usually find a parent whose kid has outgrown their JoJo phase willing to let the doll go for $10 if you pick it up yourself.
Before you buy, ask for a photo of the hair. If it looks like a bird's nest in the picture, it's going to be ten times worse in person. Look for "play-ready" dolls that have been kept on a shelf rather than in a toy box.
If you’re a collector, focus on the 2017-2019 era. Those dolls represent the "classic" JoJo brand that defined a generation of kids. Even as JoJo herself evolves into her new era, these dolls remain a time capsule of a much brighter, bow-filled time.
Check the vinyl for marks. If there’s ink or marker on the face, use a tiny bit of 10% benzoyl peroxide cream (acne cream) and leave it in the sun for a few hours. It’s a weird trick that actually lifts the stain without damaging the plastic.
Keep the bows. The bows are the most lost part of these sets, and a JoJo doll without a bow is basically just a regular doll. If you have the original bow, you've got 50% of the value right there.