Most people heading to Cedar Point for a weekend of roller coasters and overpriced fries have no idea they are driving right past one of the most haunted, historically dense spots in the Great Lakes. Just a few miles across the water from the neon lights of the park lies Johnson's Island Lake Erie. It’s quiet now. Really quiet. But in 1864, this small patch of land was anything but peaceful. It was essentially a pressure cooker, holding thousands of Confederate officers in a prison camp that was never supposed to be there in the first place.
It's a weird place.
You have this picturesque, private residential community today, but right in the middle of it sits a Confederate cemetery. It’s the kind of contrast that makes your skin crawl if you think about it too long. Honestly, when people talk about Lake Erie history, they usually stick to the Battle of Lake Erie or Perry’s Victory monument over at Put-in-Bay. Johnson's Island is different. It’s grittier. It’s about the guys who didn't get a hero's monument, but instead got a wooden bunk and a thin blanket in the middle of a brutal Ohio winter.
Why they picked a tiny island in Ohio
You might wonder why the Union military would bother dragging prisoners all the way up to the frozen edge of the North. Security. That was the big one. Originally, the federal government looked at several spots, but Johnson's Island was basically perfect. It was isolated enough to prevent easy escapes but close enough to the supply hubs in Sandusky. The island—originally called Bull's Island—was leased by the government from a guy named L.B. Johnson in 1861.
He probably had no idea his name would be forever tied to a prison camp.
The government cleared about 40 acres on the southeast side. They built a stockade with 15-foot high walls. They built "blocks"—basically giant wooden dorms—to hold the men. While most Civil War prisons like Andersonville or Elmira were notorious for being death traps for everyone, Johnson's Island was specifically designated for Confederate officers. The logic was simple: if you take away the leadership, the rank-and-file soldiers are less likely to organize or fight effectively if they manage to escape.
Life inside the stockade was a psychological grind
Don't buy into the "Lost Cause" myth that this was a country club. It wasn't. While officers generally got better treatment than enlisted men, life on Johnson's Island Lake Erie was a slow, agonizing test of patience. The biggest enemy wasn't the guards. It was the boredom. And the wind. If you've ever stood on the shores of Lake Erie in January, you know that wind doesn't just blow; it bites through your soul.
✨ Don't miss: Why Palacio da Anunciada is Lisbon's Most Underrated Luxury Escape
The prisoners spent their days doing whatever they could to keep from losing their minds.
Some made jewelry out of gutta-percha buttons or freshwater shells found along the shore. Others started newspapers like The Prison Times. They held debates. They staged plays. They even had a YMCA chapter. But underneath the "civilized" activities, there was constant hunger and disease. Smallpox and "chronic diarrhea"—the polite 19th-century way of saying you were dehydrating to death—were common.
One of the most fascinating things about the site is the sheer amount of stuff the prisoners left behind. Modern archeological digs, often led by experts like Dr. David Bush from Heidelberg University, have pulled thousands of artifacts from the latrines. Why the latrines? Because that’s where you hide things when the guards are doing an inspection. They’ve found everything from handmade gambling dice to prohibited bottles of booze. It turns out, even in a high-security military prison, people find a way to have a drink.
The great escapes (and the ones that failed)
Escape was always on the menu, though it was insanely difficult. You’re on an island. You have to get over a 15-foot wall, get across a stretch of water, and then navigate through a very pro-Union state without getting caught.
Some tried to walk across the ice.
In the winter of 1864, several prisoners made a break for it when the bay froze solid. Some actually made it to Canada. Others weren't so lucky. They’d get halfway across the ice, the wind would shift, and they’d succumb to hypothermia before they could reach the mainland. There’s a story about a guy who tried to bribe a guard with a gold watch. The guard took the watch and then immediately reported the prisoner. Talk about a bad day.
🔗 Read more: Super 8 Fort Myers Florida: What to Honestly Expect Before You Book
The Johnson's Island Plot of 1864
This is the part that sounds like a movie script. There was a genuine Confederate plan to hijack a passenger steamer, the Philo Parsons, and use it to liberate the 3,000 officers on the island. The mastermind was a guy named John Yates Beall. He and a small crew of Confederates actually managed to take over the ship. They were supposed to meet up with a mole in Sandusky who would signal them when the USS Michigan (the Union’s only ironclad on the Great Lakes) was vulnerable.
The signal never came. The plot fell apart. Beall had to retreat to Canada, and the prisoners on the island stayed exactly where they were. If that plan had worked, the entire course of the war in the North could have changed. Imagine 3,000 trained officers suddenly being loose in Ohio.
What's left to see today?
If you go there now, don't expect a massive museum with gift shops and a snack bar. It’s much more somber than that. The main thing you can visit is the Confederate Cemetery. It’s a small, fenced-off area with neat rows of white marble headstones.
A few things to keep in mind for your visit:
- The Causeway: You have to pay a toll to get onto the island. It’s a private residential area, so don't go wandering into people's backyards looking for bunkers.
- The Cemetery: This is the primary public site. It features a bronze statue called "The Lookout," which was funded by the United Daughters of the Confederacy in 1910.
- The Museum: There is a dedicated museum—the Johnson's Island Civil War Military Prison Site—located nearby on the mainland (often near the Marblehead area) that houses the actual artifacts found during the digs.
The graves are sobering. Most of the men buried there died of disease or exposure. There are about 206 marked graves, though some records suggest the number might be slightly higher. Walking through the rows, you see names from Alabama, Georgia, Virginia—places that probably felt like a different planet compared to the icy shores of Ohio.
The weird reality of private vs. public history
There is a weird tension on Johnson's Island Lake Erie. On one hand, it's a historic site of national significance. On the other, it’s a gated community where people live their daily lives, mow their lawns, and host summer barbecues. It’s a strange juxtaposition to have a prison cemetery right next to a vacation home.
💡 You might also like: Weather at Lake Charles Explained: Why It Is More Than Just Humidity
Conservationists have fought for decades to preserve as much of the original stockade site as possible. Much of the land was cleared for development years ago, but the efforts of the Friends of Johnson's Island have helped protect the core areas where the most intense history happened.
Actionable steps for your trip
If you’re actually going to make the trip, don't just wing it. You’ll end up staring at a closed gate or a private driveway.
First, visit the Ohio History Connection website or the Johnson's Island Preservation Society page before you leave. They have the most up-to-date info on when the cemetery is accessible and where the current museum exhibits are being held.
Second, pair the visit with a trip to the Marblehead Lighthouse. It’s only a few minutes away and provides the perfect vantage point to look back at the island. When you see how close it is to the mainland, you’ll realize just how frustrating it must have been for those prisoners to be so near freedom yet so far away.
Third, bring binoculars. Since much of the island is private, you can see the layout of the old prison grounds much better from a distance or from certain public access points along the shoreline.
Lastly, go in the late autumn. The crowds are gone, the air is crisp, and you get a real sense of the isolation those men felt. It’s not a "fun" tourist stop, but it’s a necessary one if you want to understand the full scope of what happened during the Civil War in the North. It’s a reminder that history isn't just something that happened "down South"—it happened right here, on the edges of the Great Lakes, in the freezing cold.
Check the weather before you go. If a storm is rolling in off the lake, the causeway can get sketchy, and the island becomes a very different, much more intimidating place. Just like it was in 1864.