It’s hard to remember now, but there was a time when seeing Johnny Depp in mascara and a tricorn hat felt like an actual event. When Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales hit theaters in 2017, the vibe was different. It felt heavy. Not just because of the massive CGI budget or the fact that Disney was trying to course-correct after the messy On Stranger Tides, but because we were watching a superstar at a crossroads.
Johnny Depp Dead Man Tells No Tales isn't just a movie title; it’s a time capsule of a specific moment in Hollywood history where the "reely-big-sequel" machine started to show its gears.
Jack Sparrow used to be the cool, unpredictable uncle of the action world. By 2017, he’d morphed into something else. Some fans called it a caricature. Others saw it as Depp just leaning into the paycheck. Honestly, looking back on it nearly a decade later, the film is way more interesting as a study of a franchise trying to find its soul than it is as a simple pirate romp.
The Messy Reality Behind the Scenes
Making a movie this big is never easy. But this one? It was a nightmare. Production in Australia was plagued by delays that sounded more like tabloid fodder than trade news. Most people remember the headlines about Depp’s finger injury, which reportedly shut down production for weeks. That wasn't just a minor hiccup. It cost the studio millions.
It’s fascinating because the directors, Joachim Rønning and Espen Sandberg, were fresh off the indie success of Kon-Tiki. They knew how to handle water. They knew how to make the ocean look terrifying and beautiful. But they were stepping into a machine that was already vibrating apart.
Depp's performance in this fifth installment feels... tired. There, I said it. While he still has that signature sway, the wit felt a bit recycled. You can almost see the weight of the personal turmoil he was going through at the time leaking into the character of Jack Sparrow. Instead of the clever trickster who stayed three steps ahead of everyone, Jack in Dead Men Tell No Tales felt like he was just lucky to be alive. He was a passenger in his own movie.
Javier Bardem and the "Ghost" Problem
One thing the movie absolutely got right was the villain. Javier Bardem as Captain Salazar is genuinely creepy. The way his hair floats as if he’s constantly underwater—even when he’s standing on dry land—was a masterstroke of visual effects.
Bardem didn't just phone it in. He brought that No Country for Old Men intensity to a Disney flick. He played Salazar as a man driven by pure, unadulterated petty spite.
It worked.
But even a great villain can’t fix a script that feels like it’s checking boxes. We had the young lovers (Brenton Thwaites and Kaya Scodelario) who were basically "Will and Elizabeth Lite." We had the MacGuffin (Poseidon’s Trident). We had the big naval battles.
It was all there. Yet, something felt missing.
🔗 Read more: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Why the Fans Stayed (And Why They Left)
If you look at the box office, the movie did fine. Better than fine. It cleared $800 million globally. But in the world of billion-dollar Disney hits, "fine" can sometimes feel like a failure.
The audience was splitting.
Long-time fans were happy to see Geoffrey Rush back as Hector Barbossa. His arc in this movie is arguably the best part of the whole thing. It gives the film a weird, emotional gravity that the rest of the slapstick humor tries to undermine. When Barbossa makes his big sacrifice, it actually lands. It’s one of the few moments in the later Pirates films that feels earned.
On the other side, critics were brutal. They pointed out the plot holes. Like, how did Jack get his compass? The movie gives us an origin story that completely contradicts what we saw in Dead Man’s Chest.
To a casual viewer, who cares? To a nerd who has watched these movies twenty times? It’s a glaring error that suggests the writers weren't really talking to the fans anymore.
The Johnny Depp Factor in 2017
We have to talk about the context. In 2017, Johnny Depp's public image was beginning to shift. The legal battles with Amber Heard hadn't reached the televised fever pitch of 2022, but the rumblings were there. The industry was watching him closely.
There was a sense that Dead Men Tell No Tales was a "must-win" for him.
His salary for the film was astronomical. Some reports put it north of $90 million when you factor in back-end deals. That's a lot of pressure on one man's shoulders, especially when he’s playing a character who is essentially a drunk clown.
Interestingly, the movie tries to de-age him. The flashback sequence with "Young Jack" was some of the best de-aging tech we’d seen at the time. It reminded us why we fell in love with the character in the first place—the swagger, the arrogance, the sheer coolness of a pirate who didn't care about the rules.
But seeing the CG version of young Depp only highlighted how much the real Depp had changed.
💡 You might also like: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Technical Wizardry vs. The Story
Let’s be real: the movie looks incredible.
The "Silent Mary" (Salazar’s ship) is a terrifying piece of design. It’s basically a giant ribcage that "eats" other ships. That’s cool! No matter how you feel about the plot, you can't deny that the technical teams at ILM and Moving Picture Company (MPC) brought their A-game.
The ghost sharks? Terrifying.
The parting of the sea at the end? Epic.
But great VFX can't hide a script that feels like it’s stuck in the mud. The movie spends so much time explaining its own lore that it forgets to just be fun. The original Curse of the Black Pearl was a miracle because it was a movie based on a theme park ride that actually had a soul. By the fifth movie, it felt like we were back on the ride—safe, predictable, and a little bit hollow.
What Really Happened with the Script?
Jeff Nathanson, who wrote the screenplay, had a tough job. He had to bridge the gap between the original trilogy and a new generation.
There were early drafts that looked very different. Rumor has it that Terry Rossio (the OG writer) had a version with a female villain, but it was reportedly nixed because of concerns that it wouldn't sell as much merchandise. If that’s true, it’s a shame. A fresh dynamic might have saved the film from feeling like a "Greatest Hits" album.
The Actionable Truth: Is It Worth a Rewatch?
If you’re a Johnny Depp completionist, you’ve already seen it. But if you’re wondering if it holds up, the answer is "kinda."
It’s a great "laundry movie." You know, the kind you put on in the background while you’re folding socks. It’s colorful, the music (by Geoff Zanelli, stepping in for Hans Zimmer) still bops, and Javier Bardem is always a delight to watch.
But don't expect the magic of the first film.
Here is what you should actually do if you want to revisit this era:
📖 Related: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
- Watch the first 20 minutes: The bank heist sequence is classic slapstick Depp. It’s over-the-top, ridiculous, and genuinely funny. It shows that he still had the physical comedy chops.
- Skip to the Barbossa scenes: Geoffrey Rush is the MVP here. Focus on his relationship with Carina Smyth. It’s the only part of the movie with real heart.
- Pay attention to the post-credits scene: If you missed it, there’s a teaser involving Davy Jones. It’s a reminder of what could have been if the franchise hadn't hit a wall.
Where Does Johnny Depp Go From Here?
Since Dead Men Tell No Tales, Depp’s career has been a rollercoaster. He was dropped from the Fantastic Beasts franchise. He won a high-profile defamation case. He’s been making smaller, European-focused films like Jeanne du Barry.
There’s constant talk about Pirates 6.
Disney executives have played it coy. Jerry Bruckheimer has gone on record saying he’d love to have Depp back. Depp himself once said he wouldn't return for "$300 million and a million alpacas," but Hollywood has a way of making people change their minds.
If he does come back, it can’t be more of the same. The "drunk and lucky" version of Jack Sparrow has run its course. For a sixth film to work, we need the Jack who is actually the smartest man in the room—the one who just pretends to be a fool.
Dead Men Tell No Tales served as a loud, expensive closing chapter for the original vibe of the series. It was a movie made at the height of studio excess, featuring a star at the height of his personal chaos.
It’s a fascinating mess.
If you want to understand the modern blockbuster landscape, you have to look at this movie. It’s the bridge between the era of the "Star Vehicle" and the era of the "IP-Driven Universe."
Ultimately, the lesson of the fifth Pirates movie is simple: even the greatest characters can overstay their welcome if they don't evolve. Jack Sparrow is a legend, but even legends need a new map every once in a while.
Next steps for the curious fan:
- Re-watch The Curse of the Black Pearl right after Dead Men Tell No Tales. The contrast in Depp’s energy is staggering and tells you more about his acting journey than any interview ever could.
- Look up the concept art for Captain Salazar. The early designs were even more nightmarish and show a version of the movie that was much darker and perhaps more daring.
- Check out the "making of" featurettes regarding the ship builds. In an era of green screens, the fact that they built actual, floating ships for some of these scenes is a testament to the craftsmanship that still exists in big-budget filmmaking.