If you’ve spent any time on Paramount+ or Showtime lately, you’ve definitely seen his face. Johnathan Nieves is one of those actors who just feels like he's about to be the next big thing. He has that classic leading-man energy but with a raw, theater-trained edge that makes him stand out in a sea of Hollywood clones. Honestly, most people first caught him as the brooding Mateo Vega in Penny Dreadful: City of Angels, but his career goes way deeper than a single period piece.
From the gritty streets of Chicago theater to the neon-soaked hallways of Rydell High, Nieves has built a filmography that’s surprisingly diverse. He isn't just a "pretty face" for teen dramas; he’s a co-founder of the Visión Latino Theatre Company and a legitimately accomplished dancer. But if you’re here, you probably noticed something weird happened during his most recent big break.
Let's get into the actual timeline of Johnathan Nieves movies and tv shows and address the elephant in the room regarding his sudden "disappearance" from certain projects.
The Breakthrough: Penny Dreadful and Beyond
Before he was a T-Bird, Nieves was making a name for himself in prestige TV. In 2020, he landed the role of Mateo Vega in Penny Dreadful: City of Angels. This wasn't just a side gig. Mateo was the emotional, volatile core of the Vega family—a kid caught between his heritage and the chaotic influences of 1938 Los Angeles.
Nieves played Mateo with a Sorta heartbreaking vulnerability. You could see the internal struggle in every scene where he was tempted by the Pachuco culture or manipulated by supernatural forces. It was a "star-is-born" moment. Critics loved him, even if the show itself was cut short after just one season.
📖 Related: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us
But it wasn't his first time on a major set. Look closely at his early credits and you'll see a pattern of "one-and-done" guest spots in massive franchises:
- Chicago Fire (2015): He played a character nicknamed "Bloody Nose." Not exactly a starring role, but a start.
- Shameless (2016): A quick appearance during the peak of the show's Gallavich era.
- New Amsterdam (2018): He guest-starred as Javi Pagan.
- Better Call Saul (2018): He popped up as David in the episode "Quite a Ride."
- Grey’s Anatomy (2019): He played Hunter Martinez. If you’re a Grey’s superfan, you know those guest spots are basically a rite of passage for rising actors.
Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies and the Richie Mystery
In 2023, Nieves landed what should have been his definitive breakout: Richie Valdovinos in Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies. He was the leader of the T-Birds, the "bad boy" with a heart of gold, and a primary love interest. He even got to showcase those dance skills we mentioned earlier. His performance of "Hit Me Again" was a genuine highlight of the series.
Then, things got weird.
Fans started noticing something was off toward the end of the first season. In episodes 8 and 9, Richie basically stopped having close-up shots. In some scenes, it looked like they were using a body double or even some questionable CGI to paste his face onto another actor. Then, his character was abruptly written off to military school.
👉 See also: Adam Scott in Step Brothers: Why Derek is Still the Funniest Part of the Movie
What actually happened? Honestly, neither Paramount nor Nieves has given a full, official "tell-all" statement. However, rumors from the set and eagle-eyed Reddit sleuths suggest he left the production before filming wrapped. Because the show was eventually canceled and scrubbed from Paramount+ (a brutal move by the studio), the "Richie Mystery" remains one of those weird TV footnotes that fans still debate.
Every Johnathan Nieves Movie and TV Show You Can Actually Watch
If you're trying to binge his work, here is the roadmap. It’s a mix of indie films and major network hits.
See You Yesterday (2019)
Produced by Spike Lee, this Netflix original is a must-watch. It’s a sci-fi drama about time travel and police brutality. Nieves plays Eduardo, and while the movie focuses on the lead duo, his presence adds to the grounded, Brooklyn-authentic feel of the film.
The Theater Roots
You can't understand his screen acting without looking at his Chicago stage work. He’s been in everything from In the Heights to Jesus Hopped the 'A' Train. He’s a "working actor" in the truest sense. He didn't just land in LA; he earned his stripes in front of live audiences at the Steppenwolf Theatre.
✨ Don't miss: Actor Most Academy Awards: The Record Nobody Is Breaking Anytime Soon
Recent Projects: Boots (2025)
Keep an eye out for Boots. It’s a more recent project that aligns with his move toward more complex, dramatic narratives. He’s consistently choosing roles that reflect his Latine heritage while pushing back against simple stereotypes.
Why Johnathan Nieves Still Matters
In a world where actors are often TikTok stars first and performers second, Nieves is a throwback. He’s got the theater background. He’s got the musical talent. He has the ability to jump from a gritty crime drama to a Technicolor musical without breaking a sweat.
The industry is currently in a weird spot with streaming cancellations—the fact that Rise of the Pink Ladies was pulled from its platform is a tragedy for the whole cast. But Nieves has a habit of bouncing back. His work in Penny Dreadful alone proved he can lead a massive production.
Actionable Insight for Fans:
If you want to support his work, don't just look for him on the big streamers. Check out the Visión Latino Theatre Company online. Since he's a co-founder, that's where his creative heart truly lives. Also, keep an eye on indie circuits; actors with his "Richie" experience often pivot to heavy-hitting independent films to re-establish their brand after a studio project goes sideways.
Don't let the "military school" write-off fool you—he’s far from done.